Putting a Value on Nature's Free Services

468 Words1 Page

Putting a Value on Nature's Free Services

Unlike other issues we have read so far, this issue was trying to

weigh and value the externalities the environment was facing. Overall,

the both arguments were suggesting the same point: environmental

services should be valued. However, the arguments differed in a sense

that one of them was suggesting it was possible these services, on the

other hand, the other was suggesting it was hard to measure this

value. First argument was for measuring the value, whereas the second

one was against this.

First argument was using examples from animals like bees and forests

of India, Amazons, South America and areas nearby, over and over.

Presenting issue from both perspectives-consumer and producer-this

argument made a better job drawing a clear in image in my head. "For

the timber and plantation barons of Indonesia…homes and

livelihoods"(pg4, 2nd paragraph). As in this phrase from the issue,

the producers-the barons in this case-value how much crop can they

make out of a forest but they don't consider the cost of the nature's

services. "Many of these services(nature's free services) are

indispensable to the people who exploit them, yet are not counted as

real benefits, or as a part of GNP."(pg5, 3rd paragraph). Nature's

services cannot be replaced by manpower therefore, once destroyed

there is no way of being able to use it again. The examples given in

the argument are helpful enough to understand that humans are

destroying the environment and day-by-day the natural resources are

depleting. Nobody disagrees this fact. What is more important and hard

to determine, however, is to measure the cost/value of using these

resources. Here are some ways presented by the book to measure this

cost:

· Measuring the economic value of a service that manpower can build to

replace a service that nature provides. (Ex: Mangrove Forests; pg8,

4th paragraph)

· Measure the economic value to a society if they did not have this

natural service. (Ex: New York City; pg9, 3rd paragraph)

Even though these ways of measuring value seem logical and efficient,

Open Document