Progressive Argumentative Essay

1150 Words3 Pages

Most people generally believe Progressives lived in cities, were college educated, and wanted change (through government). And this definition does apply to Progressives, but not all of them. According to George Mowry, the majority of Progressives came from the middle class, wanted to advance humanity, and feared losing their “position” in society. Gabriel Kolko argues that big businessmen were Progressives because they inspired the federal regulation during the era. James J. Connolly presents the argument that Progressives were immigrants (lower class) who wanted to gain access to municipal power. Each of these three arguments presents the Progressives in a different class, but Connolly seems most persuasive because of his use of sources and …show more content…

The majority of Progressives, according to Mowry, were from the middle class. The families Progressives came from seemed economically stable, and most had a college education, even the women. Many Progressives were lawyers (as might be expected of politicians) or newspaper editors. Except for the women who came more from the Midwest, Progressives came from old American stock with British origins. The New England influence was again dominating. Mowry believed Progressives were ambitious and ruthless for human advancement. They were attracted to the countryside, as cities became more alien in character through a great influx of immigrants. Progressives desired to improve the plight of the workingman, but was more hostile to a labor union than a corporate monopoly, due to the power of a corporation. According to Mowry, Progressives were individualistic and emphasized leadership. They feared their loss of status. Progressives chose to fight their battles in terms of political programs. They first wanted to preserve themselves, and then to refashion the world after their own image. Progressives set themselves apart and believed efficient government could only be run from an educated …show more content…

Mowry claimed that Progressives were from the middle-class, wanted to “improve” society, and wanted to protect the individualist (themselves). Kolko interpreted Progressives as big businessmen that wanted to avoid and reduce competition to create more stability. He claims that big businesses were the ones to create the laws and federal regulation during the time of the Progressive era. Connolly, differing from both Mowry and Kolko, explained Progressives as members of ethnic groups, immigrants. These individuals were considered more like lower class individuals. Each ethnic group used different means for their own ends. Out of the three interpretations, Connolly presented the most persuasive, using specific examples of Progressivism in immigrant communities. Progressives, though being defined in three different classes, had a common goal: reform. Each group, no matter the class, wanted to make a change to better themselves and in turn society. The Progressive Era advanced society with the many ways one could be a

Open Document