Martin Pugh's Analysis Of The Victorian Suffrage Movement

798 Words2 Pages

Martin Pugh, in his evaluation of women’s suffrage, focuses his narrative on the Victorian Suffragists, especially from the 1870s to 1890s, arguing- unlike many other historians- that their contribution to the securing of votes for women was instrumental. Presented through 10 essays, focusing on specific topics related to the Suffragist movement, Pugh provides an in depth analysis of both the tactics and political climate the Victorian Women’s Suffrage movement faced. Organised in roughly chronological order, the prose is fluent with constant reference to central ideas featuring in each text, consolidating Pugh’s point. The focus of chapter one is on the tactics employed by the suffragist movement and highlights the importance of a parliamentary …show more content…

However, he abstains from examining cultural influences in favour of factual evidence, which may detract from his writing (as mentioned by Jacqueline de Vries in her review). The exploration of the environment is continued through chapter two, via Pugh’s analysis of the debates surrounding the movement. He reaches the important conclusion that “by the 1900s parts of the Anti-Suffragist case had become irrelevant”. This chapter can be confusing however, as the author jumps from problems internal to the suffragists to problems brought forward by the anti-suffragists. While he does mention the solutions reached by the suffragists, the reader must thoroughly inspect all the other essays in order to gain an understanding of the effect these debates had on the policies adopted by the Victorian movement. On the other hand, it acts as an introduction to topical areas of discussion for the less informed reader. A deeper analysis can be found from chapter 3 onwards. These arguments are strengthened by the amount of evidence used- not just documents produced by the movement’s members, but parliamentary minutes and newspaper articles. This creates an informed understanding of the social and political climate which aids the readers’ own …show more content…

Chapter 4 follows this line of thought in which he details the motivational effect possessed by the international suffragist movements of New Zealand, Australia, and to some extent America. In an attempt to reconcile these movements with the British, Pugh neglects the social history of the international movements and perhaps can be accused of generalising the causes. He returns to the home isles in Chapters 5 and 6, where he details the fluctuating support given by the liberal party and the rising sympathy offered by the conservatives. He demonstrates the problem of reconciling the fight for the vote to party politics- the women attempted to pacify everyone- resulting in a more conservative approach. This view is particularly interesting to myself as the reader, as it introduces the idea that the Suffragist movement was not in fact as revolutionary as contemporary thought would suggest. Finally, in chapters 7 through 10, Pugh catalogues the

More about Martin Pugh's Analysis Of The Victorian Suffrage Movement

Open Document