Making Sacred Space With The Virgin Of Guadalupe Rhetorical Analysis

1396 Words3 Pages

The engaging binational study by Elaine A. Pena, in her book Performing Piety: Making Sacred Space with the Virgin of Guadalupe, explores the devotion to the Virgin of Guadalupe in three settings: Des Plaines, Illinois; Tepeyac, Mexico City, Mexico; and Rogers Park, Chicago, Illinois. She argues that acts of worshiping to the Virgin create sacred space through devotional labor[ Elaine A. Pena, Performing Piety: Making Sacred Space with the Virgin of Guadalupe (Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2011), 10.] (such as prayer, dance, song, pilgrimage, festival and shrine maintenance) along public streets or deserted highways across the US-Mexico border. With the outcome of devotional capital, worshipers are able to share social, political …show more content…

Because of the importance of original Tepeyac for Spanish governors to render the religious conversion of indigenous residents under the name of the Lady Guadalupe during the colonial Mexico, Pena points out the physical significance of the first Tepeyac, which is also shown by the replica in Des Plaines. However as Pena emphasizes, “the act of reproducing a place... Is only the first step”[ Elaine A. Pena, Performing Piety: Making Sacred Space with the Virgin of Guadalupe (Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2011), 43.]. She believes that the space becomes sacred only when devotees’ embodied performances “inscribe their histories, beliefs, and aspirations on the environment”[ Elaine A. Pena, Performing Piety: Making Sacred Space with the Virgin of Guadalupe (Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2011), 43.]. Pena also clarifies that “the Second Tepeyac solidified its dual role as religious sanctuary and political safe haven”[ Elaine A. Pena, Performing Piety: Making Sacred Space with the Virgin of Guadalupe (Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2011), 48.], which is not only a place in which the worshipers can fulfill their spiritual appeals, but also a center for immigration services. As a result, the Virgin of Guadalupe here embodies the struggle of immigrants from all over the world rather than just being a national symbol of Mexico, as that …show more content…

With performing devotional labor, Pena is able to strengthen the connection between the importance of physical layout and the significance of history as well and culture, demonstrating the possibility that sacred space is of a universal meaning around the world and unifying the global cult of the Virgin of Guadalupe. Her focusing on the two all-female pilgrimages provides readers with a new perspective of faith embodiment different from that of male practitioners, to whom most of traditional researches pay attention. More than that, Pena’s merit of unfolding an indispensable social-religious relationship in sacred space makes Performing Piety an outstanding and even provocative work: the immigrant services in the Second Tepeyac expands the significance of the Virgin to a worldwide level; peregrinas from Queretaro are categorized into different sectors of the pilgrimage by their economic status; women from Zitacuaro bring their familial appeals to the Virgin; and the threat from the relocated immigrants to the local European-Americans instigates the ethnic conflicts between the worshipers and

Open Document