Comparing Night And Life Is Beautiful

709 Words2 Pages

The horrors of Holocaust and the experience of extermination shaped the lens through which many Jews viewed the world. Consequently, there is great diversity among accounts and recollections of the Holocaust experience that bears witness to the idea that no two perspectives are the same. For example of this principle, look no farther than the similarities and differences between the accounts of Eliezer Wiesel’s semi-autobiography “Night” and the perspective presented in the movie “Life is Beautiful.” While each account portrays a coming of age story for a young Jew in a concentration camp with his father, by and large the portrait of life amidst the atrocity is radically different. Indeed, the tone of each tale, the father son relationship, …show more content…

While “Night” connotes a feeling of darkness, despair, and desperation, “Life is Beautiful” conveys an infectious sense of sunny optimism despite uncertainty; each title fulfills its namesake. For example, “Night” portrays an uncensored view of what the calamity of camp life entailed, including the sight of babies burned in an open pit (Wiesel, 2006). “Life is Beautiful,” on the other hand, presents Guido who shields his son, Joshua, from the reality of the situation via the thousand-point game. However, while Joshua may be oblivious to the horror, the audience is not, which results in a lingering mood of sorrow despite the veneer of comedy. All things considered, “Night” and “Life is Beautiful” present distinct tones about the events of the …show more content…

Arguably, Joshua is not much different than when he first entered the camp; the primary difference, however, was the death of his father. Although Eliezer too lost his father, the Holocaust molds Eliezer’s perception about himself and the world. As evidenced by the final lines of “Night,” saying “I had not seen myself since the ghetto. From the depths of the mirror, a corpse gazed back at me. The look in his eyes, as they stared into mine, has never left me.” Eliezer views himself as a fundamentally different person; spiritually, mentally, and physically the Holocaust has molded him. The Holocaust assuredly influenced Eliezer, however, there was much less influence on

Open Document