Kip Kinkel And Michael Carneal-Assisted Suicide Case Study

630 Words2 Pages

Kip Kinkel and Michael Carneal have many factors in common, as well as many factors that they do not share between one another. The timing of the shootings were very close in range, Michael’s incident took place in 1997 and Kip’s barley a year later, in 1998. Both of the young men suffered from some form of psychological disorder, for Kip it was Major Depressive Disorder and in Michaels case, Paranoid Schizophrenia. Mental health concerns were present in both boys but as one can imagine the manifestation of these two disorders are entirely different. Because of Kip’s dyslexia he struggled academically, however Michael was a good student and kept good grades. This is an area where the boys had contrasting issues, but with school comes bullies, which was the case for the two. Due to their smaller size both boys encountered bullying while at school. But the outcome from the bullying is different in the two cases, Kip would retaliate and had quite the record of disciplinary problems, while Michaels record was clean.
The media such as television, music …show more content…

Emotions for both boys drove thoughts of anger, resentment and hatred. Kip ultimately took his shooting to a different and more personal level when he killed his parents, Michael however did not. This may lead one to believe the internal driving forces behind Kip’s actions was really rooted at home, and not school. Both boys acquired stolen guns, which they received from a classmate. Thankfully, in both stories the fatalities were few but that does not excuse either of their actions. The strongest similarity these boys share is their sentencing, both are imprisoned, Michael is serving three life sentences for the three deaths and another 120 years for the five counts of attempted murder and Kip was sentenced to 111 years in prison, without the possibility of

Open Document