Julia Savaglio Cross Cultural Influence

1070 Words3 Pages

In Paula Savaglio’s article, “Big-Band, Slovenian-American, Rock, and Country Music: Cross-Cultural Influences in the Detroit Polonia,” she focuses on Polish American musicians in the Detroit metropolitan area. More specifically, she concentrates on the cross-cultural influences in their “musical style, repertoire, and careers” (Savaglio 24). The article is divided into two sections: the first section focuses on Polish American bands from the 1930s to the 1950s, the second centers around Polish American bands after the 1960s. The article emphasizes the effects of Americanization or assimilation into the mainstream culture. Also, it provides the reader with an understanding of how the Polish American musician maintained several aspects of his/her …show more content…

She argues that the younger generation plays in a similar fashion as their predecessors. For example, many of these younger generation Polish American musicians play in the same context as their forefathers; they are playing in Polish churches, weddings, bars, and more. The Polish context provides the musicians with an audience that is majority Polish American. In order to support her argument, Savaglio used several sources illustrating the different venues that polka music was played. For example, she used a personal statement from Ed Siwiec to illustrate polka bands being used in a wedding situation. The majority of her argument was supported through personal communication with those involved with polka bands and music. Therefore, these personal communication sources could possibly contain bias. In order to avoid biases and provide supporting evidence, Savaglio should have gathered additional sources to prove or disprove the personal communication sources. Coupled with additional sources, the personal communication would have provided enough evidence to prove her thesis. This argument was relatively strong because it allowed the reader to hear personal accounts from those involved with polka music, however, it was not supported very well. If …show more content…

She argues that they have been successful in their efforts to maintain their traditions because they have only assimilated slightly to the mainstream culture, while still remaining true to their origins; this allowed the Polish American heritage to remain constant. By continuing to use traditional music, the Polish Americans have been able to distinguish themselves from other ethnic groups within American society. Savaglio has illustrated this as being one of her strongest arguments. She uses a wide-variety of sources to support her argument such as personal communication, news accounts, and articles. These sources are relatively free of bias because she uses the news and articles to support the personal

Open Document