J Edgar Film Analysis

570 Words2 Pages

J. Edgar, a 2011 film staring Leonardo DiCaprio, is biographical drama that is, obviously, about J. Edgar Hoover. It was written by Dustin Lance Black, a LGBT rights activist as well as a gay man himself. It focuses on both the public political life and the private life of J. Edgar Hoover, the first Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). The film jumps around in time, as the main premise is that J. Edgar is retelling the story of the FBI to a writer so that the public can know the truth. It is clear that the social climate of the time, one of extreme homophobia, affected J. Edgar endlessly in the aforementioned public political life and private life that he led. In real life, J. Edgar Hoover’s sexuality was never made explicitly clear but many believe he was a homosexual, as he never had girlfriends and spent most of his time with one man in particular, Clyde …show more content…

Hoover’s first lines are “Let me tell you something. The SCLC has direct Communist ties. Even great men can be corrupted, can't they? Communism is not a political party. It is a disease. It corrupts the soul, turning even the gentlest of men... into vicious, evil tyrants. What we are seeing is a pervasive contempt for law and order.” On the surface, this is clearly about the Red Scare that took place around 1920. As shown in the film, fear of radical communists led Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer to lead his “Palmer Raids”, which J. Edgar Hoover oversaw when he was only twenty-four years old. At the time, he was the director of the Radical Division of the Justice Department. Hoover had a list compiled of radicals who simply were thought to have held communist ideals, not just those who had committed crimes, and as a result, “more than 5,000 persons were arrested” (Foner 760). There is a dual meaning to J. Edgar’s monologue,

Open Document