Is Odysseus Justified Essay

854 Words2 Pages

In Homer’s The Odyssey, the character of Odysseus is renowned as a noble epic hero. However, is Odysseus’ reputation truly justified by his intellect and cunning? Is he truly one “who for all craft am noted among men, and my renown reaches to heaven” (80)? Or is he, as a mortal man, also susceptible to the temptation of pride and boastfulness? Nevertheless, while Odysseus shows instances of rashness and naivety during his journey, such as lingering in the cyclops’ cave and revealing his name to Polyphemus, he evidently matures as a character and epic hero throughout the journey, such as when he disguises himself when he returns to Ithaca and when he devises a plan to defeat the suitors. While the argument may be over whether Odysseus is a true …show more content…

Some of these instances occur even before he begins his journey from Troy to Ithaca. For example, while fighting in Troy, Odysseus disguises himself as a beggar to enter Troy and also devised the plan of the Trojan horse, which allowed the Achaeans to win the war. These instances not only reveal Odysseus’ cleverness, but also his braveness. During his journey home to Ithaca, Odysseus’ intelligence and cunning is evident when he initially does not tell Polyphemus his real name, but calls himself “Noman”, so that none of the other cyclops will help Polyphemus when he cries out. He also devises the plan of getting Polyphemus drunk, blinding him, and then escaping by holding on to the sheep. After learning his lesson from revealing his true identity to Polyphemus, Odysseus justifies his cleverness by disguising his identity when he returns to Ithaca, so that he can devise a plan to slaughter the suitors without risking his …show more content…

Throughout the story of The Odyssey, Odysseus is both punished for his pride and rewarded for his ingenuity. When he lingers in the cave of Polyphemus, Odysseus ends up losing six of his men to the cyclops even though he boastfully attests that “He (Polyphemus) thought to tempt me, but he could not cheat a knowing man like me” (85). As a result, when Odysseus reveals his identity as they are sailing away from the island, Polyphemus pleads with his father Poseidon to punish the crew and to “vouchsafe no coming home to this Odysseus, spoiler of cities,…let him come, in evil plight, with loss of all his crew, on vessel of a stranger, and may he at his home find trouble” (89). This curse comes true, as Odysseus is the lone survivor of Poseidon’s storm and meets trouble with the suitors as soon as he returns to Ithaca. However, while Odysseus is punished for his pride, he is able to learn from his mistakes, and is accordingly rewarded for his ingenuity and cunning. By stating that his name is “Noman” and by getting Polyphemus drunk, he and his men are able to escape the cave, and when he disguises himself in Ithaca, he is able to successfully defeat all of the suitors and take back his home and city as

Open Document