House On Mango Street And The Whale Rider

1943 Words4 Pages

In the novella House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros, Esperanza is an individual who discovers the power of language through her experiences. On the other hand, in the film the Whale Rider directed by Niki Canaro, Pai is a character who illustrates the power of tradition through family ties and connections. From a girl who moves into a house in Chicago in the search to find the ‘real her’ to a girl named Pai who lives in Australia and makes an impact on her Grandfather’s culture, Pai and Esperanza are individuals who are influenced by family, culture, traditional beliefs, respect, and gender equality. Even though these two characters share qualities which make them similar, they both lead different objectives and journeys. Pai’s family …show more content…

From dancing and singing, chanting and performing, telling the fables and story of the Whale Rider and his adventure riding the whale, she participates in a role with a significance that is bigger than herself. Being influenced in this way, she realizes how important it is for her lifestyle to be influential in the face of learning her role and traditions edited and revised in order to understand the Whale Rider better. Esperanza’s involvement in cultural views are more focused on the power of language rather than the impact of family roots and traditional activities. “...But I believe she doesn’t come out because she is afraid to speak English, and maybe this is so since she only knows eight words.” Esperanza learns that the lack of languages (which associates with her sense of culture) can mean powerlessness and a lack of confidence. In other words, she is more observant of her surroundings than engaging and constantly learns by listening. On the other hand, Pai uses the Taiaha to practice fighting with a boy which is a traditional activity practiced in her culture. This piece of evidence connects with the impact of family roots because of the fact that ancestors have had a different perspective of culture than she …show more content…

In the movie, Pai hears the argument between her grandfather and father about having a daughter instead of a son. What this demonstrates is how Pai has the power and the issue of family roots and how she is constantly influenced about her family’s perspective on her identity. If we consider the reaction of Pai, her family influence impacts her because of the fact that she is more aware of how her grandfather thinks of her and how her family might perceive her as. “If you give me five dollars I will be your friend forever. That’s what the little one tells me. Five dollars is cheap since I don’t have any friends except Cathy who is only my friend till Tuesday.” In this situation, Esperanza seems desperate when it comes to paying Lucy money in order to be her friend.It also shows how her friends have taken on a huge influence on her because of the fact that she feels like she needs friends in order to fit in the House on Mango Street and feel comfortable with herself in this once new neighborhood. In one scene, Pai becomes more distressed over time in her performance because her Grandfather couldn’t make it because of the whales on the beach. Pai certainly values and looks up to her Grandfather although he dislikes her for trying to change their perspectives on culture, but he still loves her. Her tears and emotion in that scene was caused because of

Open Document