Horace Greeley Letter To Lincoln

975 Words2 Pages

In August of 1862, Horace Greeley, the editor of the New York Tribune, published an open letter addressed to Lincoln. In this letter, Greeley portrayed his discontent with Lincoln’s lack of commitment regarding emancipation. In response, Lincoln wrote back a letter that presented the safety of the Union as his core motivation and argued that slavery was merely a tool to achieve this. He stated that his paramount objective was “to save the Union and [was] not either to save or destroy slavery.” However, Lincoln was not indifferent to slavery; Lincoln’s objective was to free the slaves. The roadblocks Lincoln faced in outright freeing the slaves were the Border States and northern pro-slavery advocates, as they were prominent backers of the Union …show more content…

As Greeley had published his letter to Lincoln in the New York Tribune, Lincoln was not responding solely to Greeley, but to the nation as a whole. Thus, Greeley’s letter to Lincoln was an opportunity for Lincoln to reach a national audience. When Lincoln responded to Greeley in August of 1862, he had already finished writing and presenting a draft of the Emancipation Proclamation by July of 1862. However, Lincoln did not use the presence of a national audience to publicize or even mention the proclamation. Instead, Lincoln used the presence of a national audience to plant the seeds of emancipation by creating a sound logic behind it. In the letter, in order to both augment the Border States’ confidence in his policies and to propose emancipation as a foundation for the Emancipation Proclamation, Lincoln stated “If I could save the Union without freeing any slaves I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it…” This allowed Lincoln to be pragmatic as it painted him as a Unionist, but also planted the seeds for emancipation with decreased backlash for the …show more content…

In 1862, early on in the war, Lincoln proposed to Congress a “state-sponsored program of gradual emancipation” twice. These proposals even included compensated emancipation. However, both of Lincoln’s propositions were shut down. Lincoln realized gradual emancipation was not a viable option, as states were divided on their views regarding slavery as an isolated issue. Lincoln needed to incentivize emancipation with a larger goal to unite the Union army and the Union as a whole toward it. Hence, Lincoln merged winning the war and actions on slavery on open forums such as the response to Greeley. In doing so, Lincoln could shift the Civil War’s purpose to an ideological war for emancipation when the Emancipation Proclamation was issued. The Union, with the goal of winning the war, would fight for emancipation, the tool to win the war and the North itself would rally behind emancipation to preserve the

Open Document