Comparative Analysis of Proposals in Classic Literature

400 Words1 Page

The passages from Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice and Charles Dickens’ Our Mutual Friend, two men attempt to persuade their women into marrying them though marriage proposals. While both proposals state the men’s intentions of marriage, Headstone’s proposal is more effective than Collins’ because he clearly shows his affection for her, includes benefits for her family, and takes consideration of his audience.
In the excerpt from Austen’s novel, William Collins writes his marriage proposal for Elizabeth Bennet as though he were presenting a business proposition. Collins structures his arguments much too logically for a marriage proposal, by using the words “first” and “secondly.” These transition words present his reasons in the format of

Open Document