“Envy is ignorance; imitation is suicide” (Emerson, 370). John Knowles is the author of “A Separate Peace” based on a boy’s school during WWI. Gene is a teenage boy that has trouble being true to himself. “A Separate Peace” explains how Gene’s envy affects his relationship with himself, Phineas, and how he does achieve peace.
Gene’s imitation of Phineas affected himself in multiple ways. Gene became jealous of, his best friend, Phineas. Alton comments, “Gene realize that his real enemy is himself and his impulse towards mindless destruction—and he believes he overcame this enemy only after causing Phineas’ death” (Alton). The quote expresses, Gene though his enemy was his best friend, but in actuality it was himself the whole time. Also,
…show more content…
Gene is a conformist unlike Phineas. Alton comments, “Later he wants to become Phineas as when he tries on his clothes and feels confident” (Alton) He is not true to himself. Gene has never developed his own identity.
Another reason, Gene’s envy causes Phineas Death. “His relationship with Phineas revealing the flaws in his own character which led to Phineas death” (Alton). Gene emulates Phineas initially. Gene goes with Phineas on a forbidden beach trip and he begins to be late for dinner. In summary, Gene preferred to be more like Phineas than himself.
Gene does achieve peace. Gene fought a personal war with himself. “In the end, inner peace is achieved only after fighting one’s own, private war of growing up” (Alton). War symbolizes the internal setbacks of being adolescence to maturity. Gene has matured since he accomplished the war. Gene realized his enemy was within himself. In the novel. “Looking back now across fifteen years, I could see with great clarity the fear I had lived in, which must mean that the interval I had succeeded in a very important undertaking: I must have made my escape from it”(Knowles,1). The quote addresses, Gene has achieved peace when he recognized living in fear to be himself affects important people around him. Lastly, Gene understands he’s better off without
The first time his inner enemy is shown in the novel, is when Gene believes that Finny is out to make him fail; “Finny had deliberately set out to wreck my studies” (53). Phineas persuades Gene to go surfing at the beach, play blitzball, and attend the summer session meetings to loosen him up and have fun, not to make him fail. Gene cannot realize that Finny is doing this for Gene’s benefit, because his inner enemy distorts friendship from evil and fear. Gene’s inner enemy causes a key turning point in this novel, Finny’s fall. Gene’s enemy takes over his mind and jounces the branch to hurt the “enemy,” Phineas. Though Finny is the one physically falling, Gene is metaphorically falling into a hole filled with all his sins, because his inner enemy, too, pushed him. This causes Gene to feel like a worthless ant for the rest of the novel. Many of the students at Devon have an inner enemy that makes them feel like an ant. Quackenbush is mean to anyone he thinks is inferior to him. Brinker resents his enemies. On the other hand, Leper faces his enemy, but then gives up. These students believe that their real enemy is literally the Germans, but truly it is themselves putting up walls and making them feel like miniscule ants. All except Phineas. Phineas is the only one towhich the quote doesn’t apply because he never, “constructed at infinite cost to
The novel, A Separate Peace, by John Knowles describes the life highschool life of Gene Forrester through the flashbacks he experienced 15 years after his graduation. Throughout the novel Knowles takes us on a journey that revolves around Gene and his friend Finny as they go through their years in a private high school. While reading the novel one can see that Gene takes his hero journey during his highschool time as he makes the choices that will dictate not only his hero journey but his entire life.
When Gene sees that Phineas would much rather lie for him, than to believe it himself, he becomes extremely guilty for his actions. A moment, which occurred during those few seconds, has now caused him to see the pain he has inflicted on Phineas and how much Phineas really cares for him. This guilt continues to come out during novel until Phineas’ foreshadowed death. Gene’s guilt is extremely evident when Phineas breaks his leg a second time. As he sits in the infirmary with Phineas, all he could say was sorry. There was nothing more that he could do. From the beginning of the novel, we learn of a death and not until the final chapters of the book do we learn that this death is Phineas’.
Facts: Chet is basically Gene's only real competition in school for valedictorian but Chet doesn't really notice it as competition because his love of learning is so sincere. Also, he is amazing as tennis and playing the trumpet, and was even asked by Finny to play at their winter get together when the band can't come.
In the novel, A Separate Peace, by John Knowles, the main character, Gene, transforms from a clueless individual, to one who understands events by the middle of the novel, when he starts to gain knowledge. By the end of the novel, Gene is a wise individual who has obtained his knowledge with age.
In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby many characters are not as they seem. The one character that intrigues me the most is James Gatsby. In the story Gatsby is always thought of as rich, confident, and very popular. However, when I paint a picture of him in my mind I see someone very different. In fact, I see the opposite of what everyone portrays him to be. I see someone who has very little confidence and who tries to fit in the best he can. There are several scenes in which this observation is very obvious to me. It is clear that Gatsby is not the man that everyone claims he is.
In A Separate Peace by John Knowles, Gene, Finny, and Leper fear recognizing their own flaws and learning about the harsh realities of a world at war because it affects their decision making causing them to make poor decisions, such as severely hurting one another, more frequently.
When looking at Jay Gatsby, one sees many different personalities and ideals. There is the gracious host, the ruthless bootlegger, the hopeless romantic, and beneath it all, there is James Gatz of North Dakota. The many faces of Gatsby make a reader question whether they truly know Gatsby as a person. Many people question what exactly made Jay Gatsby so “great.” These different personas, when viewed separately, are quite unremarkable in their own ways.
The development of the war occurs with the maturing of Gene and most of his fellow students. The negative diction associated with the war revealed how Gene feared and even hated just the idea of war. In the end, however, he realized his own involvement in the war included no real warfare. As the war continues, Gene gives up on childlike activities like games and instead joins the war efforts. Through the setting of the Devon School, Knowles shows how war can reach even the most sheltered places. War molds our youth and thus molds our
Gene dismisses his shadow during his first few encounters with it, quickly rejecting the darkness inside himself by conjuring up excuses for his undesirable desire. In a scene where Finny attempts to talk his way out of trouble, Gene’s shadow makes an appearance, as he believed, “this time [Finny] wasn't going to get away with it. I could feel myself becoming unexpectedly excited” (Knowles 27). The excitement of Finny getting into trouble is caused by Gene’s shadow, as he describes its presence as unexpected. Gene has become introduced to his shadow, but does not yet know the full extent of the darkness existing within himself. Shadows contain darker emotions, such as envy, anger, or hatred, that we hide from the outside world as these emotions are perceived negatively. In Gene’s shadow, jealousy rises, as he compares himself
The novel, A Separate Peace, by John Knowles, is the coming of age story of Gene Forrester. This novel is a flashback to the year 1943, when Gene is attending Devon School during his senior year and the summer before it. "Gene's youth and inexperience make him ill-equipped to deal with situations that require maturity" (Overview: A Separate Peace 2). However, Gene is a follower of Finny and therefore gains experiences that provoke his development into adulthood. Some of these experiences include: breaking Finny's leg, training for the 1944 Olympics, and killing Finny. Through these three experiences Gene is forced to grow out of his childish-self and become a man.
Before Charlie had the operation preformed on him, he had friends at the bakery he worked at. They were not really his friends because they always made jokes about Charlie, but he was not smart enough to realize it. As he gets smarter he loses his friends because they think he is just trying to act smart.
Gene is a well-educated, athletic individual. He takes his school work seriously and keeps to himself, meaning he doesn’t favor standing out or being in the spotlight. He is a follower, especially when it comes to his best friend, Phineas. Throughout the book, he often compares himself to Phineas and talks about how perfect Finny is.
...tes the opposite of Charlie wanted. Charlie was born to smile which most people cannot do. It is evident that the operation made Charlie loses friends because it was not his true personality.
After the operation, Charlie also suffered from disillusionment. In the bakery he used to have friends. Friends that would talk to him and care about him. "...Why? Because all of the sudden your a bigshot. You think you are better than the rest of us..." Charlie then realized that he had no friends but merely knew people that made fun of him. The bakery employees just liked him because they could blame their mistakes on Charlie. Then, they could not do this after the operation, so they all turned against Charlie. "...I had to find out just how much they knew. I found out. Nothing..." "Both frauds" Charlie also found out about Nemur and Strauss. He realized they were not professionals, but two men that were taking a shot in the dark. Charlie felt like an expendable lab specimen. Thus, Charlie had lost his friends and knew now he was just a like a lab rat. Charlie had lacked faith in his fellow man. "...Thoughts of suicide to stop it all while I am still in control..." Everyday Charlie lost a piece of himself. He was starting to regress and thought about suicide to end his up and down life. He became irritable and edgy around people at the university. He would become mad at people very quickly and then yell at them. His self-centered and arrogant personality was a symptom of his regression. People stayed away from him because he was becoming a madman and was unpredictable. Because of this, Charlie became lonely in his last weeks before he regressed totally. "...Intelligence without the ability to give and receive affection can lead to a mental breakdown..." Charlie experienced social inadequacies while he was intelligent. "...You know as well as I do, you don't need to work here anymore..." Charlie lost his job because he was to smart to work in a bakery. He could not socially interact with people he worked with and the people he met. Also, Charlie could not perform with Alice or Fay. "...I saw him watching me with his eyes wide open. I couldn't do it..." He experienced illusions when he tried to make love with Alice. The "Charlie" inside of himself emerged and started to regain control of his mind. All in all, Charlie suffered from the pain of not knowing how to deal with his peers and decisions.