Ege's Test

1514 Words4 Pages

What once used to be such an underappreciated structure of the human body has now become a much respected structure which serves multiple functions in the lower extremity. The menisci are used in almost every ambulating task and have proven to be an integral part in knee functioning, including shock absorption and stability, with many others.1 Meniscal lesions are a very common injury and the accuracy of diagnostic testing is not very clear. Arthroscopy is currently the gold standard for correct identification due to its high accuracy but is highly invasive and can be very costly to patients.2 Due to this, we looked at the evidence for diagnostic accuracy for meniscal lesions, focusing on the cost-effective strategies of diagnostic clinical …show more content…

The purpose of this study was to compare the diagnostic value of a new weight bearing McMurrays Test (Ege’s) with McMurray’s and joint line tenderness (JLT). The Ege’s test is one of the few meniscal tests performed under weight bearing conditions which mimics the activities precipitating the symptoms of the injury, resulting in an increased diagnostic value. There weren’t any significant differences between the 3 tests to detect the tears. However, Ege’s test was found to have better diagnostic value. Lateral meniscal tears were diagnosed more accurately with all of the tests. The study also interpreted which test was most appropriate for different types of tears and whether associated lesions had any effect on the diagnostic values of the 3 tests. Additional lesions resulted in increased false positive and false negative test results for all 3 tests. The authors concluded that Ege’s test, in conjunction with traditional diagnostic tests and thorough examination, may improve accuracy of meniscal injury diagnoses for patients without concomitant lesions and that a carefully conducted interview and physical examination are the most important means of diagnosis for a meniscal …show more content…

The article was a retrospective, level III study involving 88 subjects with more than 2 MRIs acquired before surgical intervention. The subjects were divided into groups based on their MRI findings. The groups were further divided into subgroups based on their knee pathology, including meniscal injury. According to this study, it cannot be concluded that the timeliness of an MRI on an injured knee, including meniscal pathology, affects the need for surgical intervention.11
Shepard et al12 is a level III, retrospective study to determine the accuracy of MRI in diagnosing anterior meniscal lesions. The anterior horn of the meniscus bears little weight and tears are frequently asymptomatic. A total of 947 MRI images of the knee were studied, 76 of those presented with a diagnosis of an anterior horn lesion, and only 31 of those subjects opted to have arthroscopic surgery. The arthroscopy revealed 26% true positive and 74% false positive lesions on the anterior horn. Physical examination is an important tool that should be paired with MRIs to prevent unnecessary

More about Ege's Test

Open Document