Hannah Whitley posted this image on twitter, saying “When you just wanna look like @Zendaya but you get a dress code violation for being too provocative (emoji) #senioryearblues” According to Teen Vogue, Hannah (photo on the right), wore an outfit inspired by Zendaya, and received a violation for being too provocative. Part of the problem is calling it provocative. This could be considered being shamed, and infers that you were trying to be provocative, which is an insult. While it was violating an odd, strict dress code, this outfit seems perfectly fine for school. Dress codes adding shame and being overly strict and sexist has been a problem for years.
Let’s start with what our school thought. I had a few of my friends hand out a survey,
…show more content…
According to Huffpost, there are codes that don’t discriminate race, gender, religion, etc. “All the listed rules, which prohibit things like violent imagery and hate speech, not tank tops and ripped jeans, apply to “students,” not boys or girls.” - Emily McCombs. Females are often violating more because they are thought of as distracting to boys. What about girls getting distracted, and why should girls be blamed for some boy’s bad behavior. We could change dress codes to go by what will be less focused on what girls wear, and more about what students in general wear. Boys can just pay attention to school work and not a distraction. They can write a history paper even if they can see a kneecap or shoulder, and distractions should barely even be a problem. There was even a school that made a new dress code, and it is pretty genius. Their dress code was called Oregon NOW, and it didn’t go by gender, just by gender neutral rules that everyone can go …show more content…
First of all, the fingertip rule isn’t a useful idea. If you have average length arms, you’ll be fine. If your arms are really short, you’ll barely ever be reported. And if you have very long arms, you probably can’t even wear cargo shorts, or any shorts above the knee at all! Contrary to most dress codes , it is a great idea to support dress codes that don’t go by gender. The kids at schools that do say what boys and girls can separately wear grow up, and usually follow these gender norms, too. Schools with neutral codes have kids that grow up and don’t worry about gender standards. Something that many people overlook is that kids can actually pay attention better if they are comfortable with what the are wearing, but not if they are constantly worried if they’ll get dress coded, they could become stressed or come late picking out and acceptable outfit.
Typically, dress codes are in the mindset that boys will be distracted, and girls get the violation. This obviously isn’t fair. Boys should be getting violations if they are distracted, and if an outfit is really that bad, then the need to get a violation. Not for a tank top that shows shoulders. People say that they are fair and enforce uniformity, but girls get dress coded VERY often, and for many different consequences. There should be only a few consequences, or equal consequences, if two people are wearing the same outfit. Dress codes should have rules for
Life is full of distractions and, for high school students, inappropriate clothing has the potential to grab much attention. However, does the matter of clothing warrant strict rules? I agree that, like alcohol, the students’ attire should have rules regarding whether or not the choices in clothing are suitable for a public school setting. I also agree that violators of school rules should receive punishment for their lack of compliance to the school policies. However, there is a fine line. Some schools, like Carroll High School, are taking dress codes too far. One rule in particular hinders the students’ ability to wear pants with holes in them. It makes sense that holes located in certain places might cause a...
Multiple reports are taken from females who experience the shorter end of the stick due to increased fashion interests and sexist mindsets of their school staff. An individual’s choice of dress is a reflection of themselves, a form of identity. Officials conclude that clothing choices increase the risk of bullying. Punishment for those who violate the strictly enforced rules consist of in-school suspension until someone from home can bring replacment clothes, humiliating “shame suits” , or any other creative punishment the school decides such as detention, etc. Shame suits are humiliating outfits that those who broke the rules must wear as a form of punishment, most of the time these consist of extremely unflattering clothes that have written phrases on them indicating that their appearance is due to their violation of the school rules. Punishments indicated place risk on the violators education caused by missed classes. Few in society do approve of the dress code as it controls female students’ modesty, banishes a distraction, and preserves the professional atmosphere inside a school. Issues involving the apparel enforcements include sexism, repressed self- identity, and punishment issues will be discussed within this
Dress codes regulate what can be worn in certain places, such as schools and facilities. These codes are controversial where ever they are enforced. People tend to think that the government does not have the power to tell them they cannot wear certain articles of clothing and the fact that some schools do it can throw people into a fit. Some people believe that dress codes stifle personal expression, that a dress code is the same thing as a uniform. Many people do not remember that individualism goes beyond clothes, and that a dress code will help kids to be more than the clothes they have or do not have. Dress codes allow students to set themselves apart from others by their actions not their appearance.
In the 2015 article on The Atlantic on The Sexism of School Dress Codes, stating that "Many of these protests have criticized the dress codes as sexist in that they unfairly target girls by body-shaming and blaming them for promoting sexual harassment. Documented cases show female students being chastised by school officials, sent home, or barred from attending events like prom." (Zhou, l.) There are more dress code policies for the females compared to the males. For example, girls should not use backless shirts, no spaghetti tops, no crop-tops that exposes the stomach, no short shorts, no miniskirts, etc. Boys on the other hand have no specific dress code policies. Dress codes may come off as sexist for women and they get insulted by it. An article on the problem with dress code from The Daily Princetonian stating "- women are policed so that they are no longer distracting to men, while men, if policed at all, are never told to change for the benefit of the opposite sex. The most prominent example that comes to mind when thinking of male-specific supplements to dress codes relates to sagging pants, an urban trend where pants are worn low to expose many inches worth of boxers. Efforts to ban these practices have never once mentioned how visible boxers would tortuously distract nearby females. Rather, they focus on visible underwear being inappropriate for a learning or work environment.", based on that article, dress codes seem to be a little too specific on what girls should or should not be allowed to wear, while boys only have a few dress code policies to worry
Both Male and Females have complained that the dress code is “sexist and “biased” toward young women. One teenager said that the school should be an all-boys school. Since the code only applies to women. Another student said that “it was humiliating to be pulled aside like an object” to be told that her outfit is inappropriate.
According to greatschools.org, “Enforcing a strict dress code can place the focus of school on clothing and rules, rather than on education.” Most schools have specific uniforms that a child must wear in order to attend. Many children that go to school, have single parents and / or more than one ...
“When you interrupt a girl’s school day to force her to change clothes, or send her home because her shoulders are showing, you are telling her that making sure boys have a ‘distraction free’ learning environment is more important than her education. Instead of shaming girls for their bodies, teach boys to not view girls as objects” (anonymous internet user). School dress codes have been a hot topic in the news lately. Girls have been sent home for wearing things they thought followed the dress code, but, apparently, their teachers did not. Students at Wisconsin Lutheran High School (WLHS) should be able to wear what they want because all the students should have the right to express themselves, be comfortable in their learning environment,
Pants below waist, baggy shirts with sexist signs, and piercings, this is not a good view early in the morning. That’s why the school should implement a uniform policy. Uniforms should be mandatory in school. Uniforms make the school appear more professional. Also with uniforms students won’t compare themselves with each other. Moreover uniforms can help students save time. Additionally parents won’t have to waste so much money on clothes hence will have a better budget.
There’s such a difference in how school dress codes treat males and females. Girls are disciplined disproportionately. A lot of students, not just girls, find this divergence unfair; beyond the fact that boys are rarely called out for dress code violation. Biased rules can have a very negative impact on girls confidence and sense of self. Girls tend to feel judged and chastised by these restrictions.
I feel that school dress codes mainly focus on women. Anyone, male or female will know that any dress code is made to help, but when they are only aimed at women it’s not okay. We have to fit within the tight boundaries of the dress code, not able to express ourselves. It’s almost like the Renaissance. We just gave life a restart, and found this lump of creativity. I feel that we should give the dress code a restart.
Discrimination in School Dress Codes While scrolling through social media, I’m sure you have seen girls post their outfits they got dress coded for and the hashtag #IAmMoreThanADistraction. For years, students, especially girls have been discriminated for what they wear. Discrimination is an unfair treatment of different groups or people; discrimination can be based on race, age, or sex. Complaints on the dress code at public schools have been heard around the world. Issue have been with shorts and skirts being too short, leggings that are a “distraction to boys”, and shoulders showing.
The school is openly telling a young woman in this school what she can and can not wear, and how she can not express her own body at the risk of distracting others. The boys’ dress code regulations is far shorter and is only one sentence. “Boys don’t sag your pants.” These dress code regulations are sexist but hidden with the excuses of what appropriate school attire is. Some girls do not conform to this rule and I do not blame them.
Boys have a shorter list of rules than girls do. These rules shames girls for wearing what they like. The new policy being
Uniforms do not need to be implemented because of the girls or the boys. Schools always make strict rules because as teachers say, ¨The boys get distracted.¨ But boys can control themselves, they can handle a girl wearing shorts made for a girl. Some boys that I asked said that they think that the boys and girls should be even and be able to both be able to show their collar bone or just not showing the collar bones at all(Zhou Li). They don't get as distracted as much as you think they do. The boys are more focused on school work, socializing with their friends, or messing around like boys
We see stories Social media has more stories of girls being sent home because of dress code violations. Maybe the problem isn’t the students, but dress codes in general. Dress codes ultimately disrupt the pursuit of knowledge for the students, encourage gender bias, and can be dangerous. If we want the younger generations to succeed in the education system, we should utilize school uniforms. Uniforms in schools from elementary to high schools, will promote gender equality and facilitate student safety.