Does Taiwan Have The Right to Be Autonomous?
opinion Essay
2061 words
Taiwan has a very long history with China in its early years of colonization, and since China gave Taiwan to Japan during the World War II, Taiwan formed an autonomous government and wanted to gain political autonomy from China. The problem considering the autonomy of Taiwan has been around for centuries. On one hand, Taiwanese people claim their land was separated from the Mainland China for a long time and should be reasonable to gain autonomy, while the Chinese government says that Taiwan is still an inseparable part of China and should maintain unified. Many of us are concerned whether Russia has the right to claim Crimea as one of its lands, and the problem between China and Taiwan is similar. There have been discussions in Asia about whether Taiwan has the right to be independent, which is to gain political independence from China, but settling this complicated dispute is not easy. If wrongfully put, the economy of both lands could be harmed, and the worst case would be war between the two lands. Taiwan has the right to be autonomous, but the fact could be that they shouldn’t be autonomous. Speaking from different angles, it would be best if Taiwan can maintain its current relationship with China, if not even closer relationship.
Taiwan was founded by China and had a long history of being governed, but the land was given to Japan during World War II in return of truce and thus has no owner ever since. During World War II, Taiwan rebelled against the ruling of Japanese government, and many say that the idea of Taiwan Independence emerged at that time. After Japan lost the war, the country signed a treaty to return all of its occupied lands, but in the treaty, there was no specific assignment of the belongings of the cover...
... middle of paper ...
.../www.roc-taiwan.org/LV/ct.asp?xItem=345712&ctNode=7925&mp=507>.
J. Michael Cole, August 23, 2013, ‘No Missiles Required: How China is Buying Taiwan’s "Re-Unification"’.
Shih-hwang Chiang, Oct 2013, < http://thediplomat.com/2013/08/no-missiles-required-how-china-is-buying-taiwans-re-unification/>
Keri Phillips, April 29, 2014, “Student protests over free trade deal shake Taiwan”< http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/rearvision/taiwans-sunflower-student-movement/5418698>.
Feb 19, 2014 “China respects Taiwan system, Xi tells Taipei ex-VP Lien”< http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asiapacific/china-respects-taiwan/1002882.html >
http://www.gov.hk/en/about/govdirectory/govstructure.htm
In this essay, the author
- Opines that taiwan has a long history with china in its early years of colonization, and since china gave taiwan to japan during the world war ii, taiwan formed an autonomous government and wanted political autonomy from china.
- Explains that taiwan was founded by china and had a long history of being governed, but the land was given to japan during world war ii in return of truce.
- Opines that taiwan has no official belonging, and it has shifted from one government to another but wasn't very satisfied with any of them.
- Opines that taiwan has been self-governed since 1950, but it has never officially been independent before, and lacks experience when handling problems without aid from its mother countries.
- Argues that taiwan's democratic progressive party should be autonomous because they have governed their country very well. however, the chinese government is in a balanced relationship with taiwan in terms of trade, communication, and investment.
- Opines that taiwanese people feel insecure about the government because they shift so quickly. they fear that when the prc is in charge again, time will return to 60 years ago.
- Explains that after world war ii, japan gave up control over taiwan and taiwan was put under the administrative control of the republic of china government since 1945. china specified the "one country, two system" policy and allowed taiwan to maintain their political stand.
- Analyzes how the kuomintang of china (kmt) is inclined to have a unified china, and ma ying-jeou is reelected with 51.6% of the vote.
- Opines that the chinese government wants to re-unite with taiwan to exploit its resources and make it one of the many insignificant cities in its land.
- Explains that taiwan lowered the threshold for chinese investors to invest in the island. this deepens the bond of taiwan with mainland china and both lands benefited in this investment relationship.
- Explains that taiwan has a long history of investment in mainland china. the percentage of trade between them has grown exponentially since 1996, reaching us$168.96 billion in 2012. harming the relationship could result in the end of many million-dollar businesses.
- Explains that chinese investors are harshly censored when investing in taiwan by many different forces, and any politically inclined investment is called to end immediately.
- Argues that the free trade agreement is an example of china trying to buy taiwan with its money and power. the agreement has led to massive student protests in taipei.
- Opines that blogs show that many people are for the agreement, but are against the abuse of power of the current president, ma ying-jeou, in taiwan.
- Opines that china respects taiwan and is trying to settle disputes through meetings and talks.
- Opines that although china is making many promises now, the government may not actualize the promise it made. they fear that once reunited, taiwan will become one of the "best small-states provinces."
- Opines that china granted hong kong self-governance rights that allow them to have their own executive authorities. this compromise to the working style of the prc but also a political view that mainland china did not agree on.
- Argues that taiwanese people don't want to be considered chinese because they believe that china has low-educated people who are not civilized.
- Opines that taiwan has the right to become autonomous, but should remain the current status with china because it is beneficial for both countries.
- Analyzes how taiwan-china trade reached us$168.96 billion in 2012: china customs.
- Cites j. michael cole's article, "no missiles required: how china is buying taiwan’s "re-unification".
- Cites shih-hwang chiang, keri phillips, and channel news asia.
Let Our AI Magic Supercharge Your Grades!
Related
- explanatory
- opinion
- analytical
- argumentative
- America's Open Door Policyexplanatory essayIn the First Sino-Japanese War in 1895, China at the time confronted impending risk of being parceled and colonized by colonialist powers...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the open door policy alluded to the united states strategy in the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century sketched out in secretary of state john hay's open door note. the arrangement proposed to keep china open to exchange with all nations on an equivalent premise.
- Explains that the open door strategy was established in yearning of american organizations to endeavor chinese markets, but it also tapped the profound situated sensitivities of individuals who restricted dominion.
- Explains that in the first sino-japanese war in 1895, china faced impending risk of being parceled and colonized by colonialist powers, such as britain, france, russia, japan and germany.
- Explains that every nation tried to avoid hay's appeal, taking the position that it couldn't submit itself until alternate countries had consented.
- Explains that the united states dissented that russian infringement in manchuria after the boxer rebellion was a violation of the open door policy.
- Explains that the open door policy alludes to the new approach advertised by deng xiaoping in december 1978 to open the way to remote organizations that needed to set up in china.
- Explains that four sezs were set up in 1980, namely shenzhen, zhuhai and shantou in guangdong, and xiamen in fujian.
- Explains that china was 32nd on the planet in export volume, yet it had multiplied its reality exchange and got thirteenth biggest exporter in 1989.
976 wordsRead More - Confucianism and Its Implications in Modern Chinaopinion essay“What Taiwan Wants; Premier Lien on China, Trade and Confucianism.” Asiaweek. http://web.lexis-nexis.com/universe/document?_ansset=GeHauKO-EZYRMsSEZYRUUARA December 15, 1995.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that confucianism is a time-enduring philosophy that has stood up to invading clans, war, resentment, enforcement and infringement of new philosophies, and eventually revival.
- Explains that this is not an attempt to reinstate confucianism as it once was, but rather the idea of it going through a modernization process in which one includes parts that are beneficial to society.
- Explains that the ideas of confucianism are based on the values he expresses that are essential to human beings in order to become gentleman.
- Opines that one must be open and willing to account that the ideas of confucius are present even when they do not seem to be implemented or those persons don't feel that they possess them in aconfucian sense.
- Explains that confucianism layouts the way one should be, act, and present himself towards and to others. history can tell much about a nation and its society.
- Explains that confucius had been criticized in mainland china and the chinese people's living standard was under the bottom of the world from the beginning of this century until 1977.
- Analyzes how mao zedong and other communist revolutionaries in china publicly attacked confucianism because the social and political ideas were considered authoritative and class-ridden.
- Explains that the secret of japanese success is that it practiced the traditional chinese principles: social positions are determined by merits and learning.
- Opines that confucianism is not the reason for this backwardness; one can look at japan and other asian nations that are backed by a confu
- Explains that communism does not promote learning and knowledge unless it is what the government sees fit, while confucianism promotes knowledge and learning.
- Opines that the confucianist drive for educational excellence is a key reason for the high performance of east asian students in science, mathematics and classical music.
- Opines that traditional confucian values have supported korean growth. the focus on education and self-cultivation encouraged mass education.
- Explains that confucianism is prevalent in the economic powerhouses of east asia known as the five dragons.
- Explains that singapore brought in confucian thoughts and ideas in the 1970s to strengthen and grow, both in economy and socially.
- Explains that confucianism in singapore will be interpreted as a code of personal conduct for modern singapore and promoted in the form of public debate and discussion over the media.
- Opines that confucianism's definitive aspect involves the golden mean – applying moderation in human relations and avoiding prejudice.
- Explains the concept of the golden mean and the idea of filial piety, which promotes a family-based or human relations-oriented society.
- Opines that china's past has not had that privilege, at least not for the past half century or so. communism was the form of government used in china beginning in 1949.
- Opines that the people had the duty to obey and support the government as long as it provided good government. if not, they could rebel and replace the ruler with someone with a new mandate of heaven.
- Opines that china needs to expand on the ideas of human rights. the idea of rebelling is wrong, but making sure that the government is benevolent towards the people is excellent.
- Explains that confucianism is not just the advocacy of obedience to government, but also the accountability of government. if people really want to learn from it, they have to open up to more enlightened values, such as freedom of expression, the dignity of the individual and other human rights.
- Argues that the chinese must have a good system for electing politicians. the confucian system is not the best way.
- Analyzes how confucianism could reconcile with democracy by giving an underlying moral framework to the one-man-one-vote system and the market. this would encourage the voter to calculate not only in his self-interest, but also that of his community.
- Argues that people would have to choose from those who knew the background of their nation and whom they felt would benefit the community, not just their own desires.
- Opines that confucianism would provide a stronger foundation for chinese and vietnamese society in the next century than class struggle and the dictatorship of the proletariat.
- Explains that many people claim that there is no relevance between a philosophy (or way of life) and economics. they dispute the lack of connection between nations virtues and the economic progress that it makes.
- Explains that some academics have looked to culture for an explanation and concluded that confucian ethics, stressing the claims of the community over the individual, are the key.
- Explains that confucius strongly promoted the idea of the community over the individual in any economy, and that this idea is holding china back, or giving them a backwards movement.
- Explains that filial piety coincides with economics through business. a strong business must have relationships between boss and employee and other relevant relationships. the family structure underlies the business, governmental, and societal structures.
- Opines that confucianism must be viewed with an open mind to bring it in to light of modernization and the modern world in general.
- Opines that in confused times like ours, we would do well to consider it, even if it does no more than add to our stock of ideals.
- Opines that re-institution of confucian ideas and philosophies to the modern era will develop china and create a better society, government, and economy allowing it to grow and prosper.
- Cites hahm chaibong's article on confucianism and its implications for the industrialization and democratization of east asia.
- Cites asiaweek's article, "confucian comeback; the master’s teachings are a boon to the modern world."
- Opines that confucianism must make 3 great adjustments to back asian revival.
- Cites de bary, william theodore, and englehart, neil a. the rise and fall of confucian ethics in singapore.
- Explains that "hearts and minds new life for confucianism?" korea times.
- Cites relyea, scott. the legacy of confucius in contemporary chinese interpretations of human rights.
- Explains that a seminar on confucian business was held in shanghai, xinhua, on october 23, 2000.
- Cites tucker, mary evelyn, "introduction to confucian spirituality" and "what taiwan wants" by premier lien.
3387 wordsRead More - Cuban Missile Crisisexplanatory essayStood until 1970…when President Carter asked that the U.N. sees Taiwan as China…The U.N. agreed
In this essay, the author
- Explains that cuban exiles, which were against castro, were ready to sail to cuba and help the u.s. take over cuba.
- Explains that khrushchev believes that he can do what ever, because kennedy will back down. in 1961, president kennedy and chair met in vienna.
- Explains that the monroe doctrine of 1823 said no one would'mess' with the western hemisphere unless, the u.s. knew about it.
- Describes how white settlers from europe landed in south africa in a manifest destiny.
- Narrates how the reagan administration told apartheid to change in the 1980s.
- Opines that the u.s. will continue to talk and trade with china and long as that try to change their ways.
- Explains that in poland people started to rebel against the government, because it was a communist government. when this wave hit china, the chinese government didn't want this rebellion happening.
- Describes how president kennedy and chairman khrushchev agreed to remove missiles from cuba and turkey.
- Explains that khrushchev's first letter said that the russians would pull the missiles out of cuba if the u.s. promised to not invade cuba.
- Opines that time is necessary to come up with a situation and give the opponent time to back off.
- Narrates how a communist rebellion starts small but grows very large, led by mao, in 1949, and kai-shek is left with only two options.
- Explains that president carter asked that the u.n. sees taiwan as china and cater said that they would protect taiwan. china is experimenting on putting communism and capitalism together.
1172 wordsRead More - defining of a peoplanalytical essayBefore these different interpretations of the actions that transgressed on February 28 are discussed the initial expectations for the future of Taiwan after WWII held by the Taiwanese and KMT must be understood as they were the fuel and foundation for the countering interpretations. When it was known that the KMT would hold jurisdiction of Taiwan, the Taiwanese had “euphorically optimistic expectations” of returning to Chinese rule, believing that the Sate building of Taiwan would be an “immediate success, if not perfection” (Myers, 168, 169). This delusion stemmed from their fifty year experience of the highly efficient Japanese government, and they naturally expected the KMT administration to perform with a “similar efficient system, cum democracy” (Mye...
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the boston massacre of 1770, the 1836 battle of the alamo and the protests for civil rights led by martin luther in the 1960s all contributed to the united states identity.
- Analyzes how the initial expectations for the future of taiwan after wwii held by the taiwanese and kmt were the fuel and foundation for countering interpretations.
- Analyzes how the kmt's expectations of the taiwanese were dashed from the moment they stepped onto the island. the civil war explains the undisciplined and uncultured state of their soldiers.
- Analyzes how the taiwanese became dissatisfied with the efficiency of the new regime and their unscrupulous soldiers and officials. they self-identified as an "ethnically bound 'we group'
- Analyzes how the polarized stances and contradicting expectations helped explain the tension and disdain that accumulated into the eruption of violence during the february 28 incident.
- Analyzes how the kmt's initial reaction and interpretation of the riots of february 28, once concessions made by chen yi failed, was that of rebellion. generalissimo deployed war ships and additional troops to sternly quell the dissidents insurrection
- Opines that sending troops to squelch a rebellion is justifiable, but the shooting and bayoneting of men and boys, raping of women, and looting homes and shops would prove moral permissiveness.
- Opines that the kmt's murderous actions would not be fully endorsed by the generalissimo to the extent of violence that is depicted by survivors of the incident.
- Analyzes the kmt's preference that the blame for the brutal actions of the event and the misrule that led to the riots did not fall on their administration.
- Analyzes how the february 28 incident was outlawed, but the memory of those killed was echoed in the harsh actions of the kmt under martial law.
- Explains that the taiwan independent movement (tim) was a group of taiwanese people who had lived at the time of the uprising and stood behind the sentiment that reunification made no sense.
- Analyzes how the kmt's forced silence of mentioning the incident and casting all the blame on communists and 'ambitious' taiwanese solidified a more vehement animosity towards their regime from the taiwan
- Explains that the kmt has gained a large base of public support as evident in their ability to hold direct presidential elections and remain in office. their change of stance on the february 28 incident from forbidding open discussion to acknowledging the regimes role in the violence.
- Analyzes the contemporary poignancy of the february 28 incident to the taiwanese people. it has received different interpretations throughout the years and survived the attempts of washing it from history.
1501 wordsRead More - Tradition of Tension and Oppressionanalytical essayXinjiang’s past status throughout Chinese history has been used as justification both for and against its incorporation into PRC, depending solely on political perspective. As a sparsely populated and resource-rich vast buffer region between the Soviet Union and the People’s Republic, Xinjiang was strategically and economically valuable. When the Peoples’ Liberation Army entered the province in 1949, despite a lack of familiarity with either the geography or the people, they successfully quelled resistance efforts . A provin...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that xinjiang's population was linguistically isolated due to its geographical position and the stark landscape of deserts and mountain ranges.
- Analyzes how the chinese communist party's language reforms distanced the uyghur population from the islamic tradition and modified arabic script.
- Analyzes how the chinese communist party's efforts to promote a stronger, more unified chinese identity only served to slightly dilute the culture and language of the uyghurs.
- Describes davis, elizabeth van wie, and asian affairs: an american review 35.1 (2008).
- Explains mcmillen, donald h., chinese communist power and policy in xinjiang, 1949 - 1977.
- Explains that the xinjiang autonomous region is isolated from its central beijing-based government by rough terrain, a language barrier, and starkly different religious traditions and economic structure.
- Analyzes how the chinese communist party tentatively began land reforms in xinjiang, emphasizing the timidity with which it originally approached the dismantling of islam.
- Explains fedyshyn, oleh s., gladney, dru c.
- Cites moseley, george, and web. of slavists, canadian. the uighurs between china and the ussr.
1594 wordsRead More - Darwin's law of natural selection reveals that the natural world is indeed a brutal place, where those unfit for their environment will be supplanted by the better adapted. Just as the Galapagos Islands showcased the process of evolution within the natural world, the island of Taiwan has been a petri dish for natural selection of the political sphere even as the first western powers showed interest in the island. This early pre 1750s period of Taiwanese history had the factions of the Taiwanese Aborigines, Chinese and Dutch all striving for control over the island. As in early Taiwan along with the rest of the world, typically the actuality of who will have de facto rule is often dictated by military might rather than modern ethical ideal of who morally has the right to govern but this strength to grasp power is not the sole aspect of legitimacy to rule. There must also be additional attributes to gain power and keep it, such as the will to claim the title of ruler and a level of political competency to govern the land and its people. Looking back in hindsight the Taiwanese Aborigines, in comparison to the Dutch and Chinese, fulfill the requirements of political legitimacy, through military strength, governing prowess, drive for ownership and modern ethical views, answering the historical question, that has seeped into current political issues, of what faction had the right to rule early Taiwan.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that darwin's law of natural selection reveals that the natural world is a brutal place where those unfit for their environment will be supplanted by the better adapted.
- Argues that the qing dynasty never had a firm grasp on taiwan and the vast majority of taiwan remained wild and left to the aborigines.
- Analyzes how the historical ethics of this time and the concept of right to land ownership counters the modern ideals of appreciation for other cultures and ethnic equality.
- Analyzes how the dutch used military force against violent uprisings and the ming dynasty rather than on the inhabitants of taiwan.
- Explains that the taiwanese aborigines remained in control of the majority of taiwan even though they had a less advanced and developed military juxtaposed to the dutch and chinese's.
- Argues that the fabricated morals and ideals of dutch and chinese officials to take advantage of the aborigines can be vilified as much as the european policies in the americas.
1930 wordsRead More - North Korean Regime of Confucian Communismanalytical essayLipman, Jonathan Neaman., Barbara Molony, and Michael Edson. Robinson. Modern East Asia: An Integrated History. Boston: Pearson, 2012. Print.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that north korea is not just a communist "hermit kingdom" created by soviet troops during the korean war, it is also an important confucian state that shares fundamental similarities to its neighbours.
- Explains that confucianism, one of the most significant east asian philosophies, had been present in the korean peninsula since the 4th century.
- Explains confucianism's decline after the kabo reforms, and the hegemonic ideology of the north and south during the korean war.
- Analyzes how kim il-sung resurrected confucianism and neo-confucian values in his new socialist kingdom to legitimize the hereditary rule of the kim family.
- Analyzes the north korea regime through the lens of juche ideology and how it matches the confucian values.
- Explains that north korea and china are the only restrictive regimes in east asia. the prc is its closest ally and arguably the most able to wield influence in pyongyang.
- Compares how north korea and south korea used confucian family structure and father-like leadership to be considered the great fathers of the nation.
- Explains that north korea has many historical and cultural similarities with other east asian countries, due to the commonly shared background of confucianism and neo-confuciannism.
- Explains chung, young-soon, and the resurrection of confucianism in north korea.
- Explains dolan, ronald e., and robert l. worden. japan: a country study. washington, d.c.
- Explains the importance of confucian values to kim jong il's system.
- Opines that lipman, jonathan neaman., barbara molony, and michael edson. modern east asia: an integrated history.
- Describes nanto, dick k., and mark e. manyin. china–north korea relations.
- Explains that north korea: a country study. washington, d.c.: federal research division, library of congress, 1994.
- Explains young, whan kihl, and the cultural dimension and context of north korean communism.
- Explains that worden, robert l., andrea matles savada, and ronald e. dolan. china: a country study. washington, d.c.
- Opines that north korea: the kim family tree.
1827 wordsRead More - A New Great Depressionargumentative essayIn 1972, President Nixon visited China, and declared the open trade between America and China, a country that has been isolated from the West since 1949. Although most people remember President Nixon with his Watergate Scandal, he also opened a new trading era with People’s Republic of China. Nixon was in fact known as an anti-communist, and his presidency was during the Cold War, a political and military tension era between the US and the Soviet Union. In 1949, Chairman Mao Zedong established the People’s Republic of China. Known as a communist, Mao at that time was Stalin’s biggest supporter. China’s alliance ...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that china is now able to challenge the america's decades-long dominant position in economic area.
- Explains that nixon declared the open trade between america and china, a country that has been isolated from the west since 1949.
- Explains how nixon's hard work paid off when he warmed up the relationship between china and america by sending a team of ping-pong players to china to play.
- Explains that the opening trade between the us and china changed the world's economic pattern.
- Compares china's gdp as percent of world economy to that of the us. the us economy was three times the size of china, but by the end of 2013, it was only twice as large.
- Explains that america didn't want to see china's economic rise, but was confident that they could control the growth of the chinese economy by controlling the yuan currency.
- Explains that every country's currency needs a fixed amount of monetary aggregates; too much will cause inflation, while very little would cause deflation.
- Explains that if china sells its 1.6 trillion american securities, a new great depression would take place all over the world.
- Analyzes how the us-china relationship developed from two strangers to twin brothers. the us tried so hard to keep the younger brother vulnerable, but he could not stop him from catching up.
- Explains rawski, thomas g., "the rise of china's economy." foreign policy research institute.
- Explains that china overtakes japan as world's second-biggest economy.
1839 wordsRead More - Tensions have risen drastically between China and Japan, both claiming ownership of the uninhabited islands in the East China Sea. These two states, both want control of the islands, since the discovery of undersea oil reserves which the islands possess. The dispute intensified once the United States transferred administrative control of the islands to Japan in 1971, this sovereignty widely contested by China. This dispute is current but is best understood by looking at the history of Chinese foreign policy and the behavior of these actions through the use of state level analysis and the concept of nationalism.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes the tensions between china and japan, both claiming ownership of the uninhabited islands in the east china sea, since the discovery of undersea oil reserves.
- Explains the history of the islands, known as senkaku in japan and diaoyu in china.
- Explains that china's statecraft can be understood by looking briefly at the history, a state which had oppressive governments and revolutions throughout its existence, molding it into what it is today.
- Analyzes how china's authoritative government helps to keep people sentimentally attached to their country and fight for it. the chinese have recently used propaganda through a television series called "the anti-japanese knight."
- Concludes that the dispute between china and japan over the control of the islands in the east china sea can be explained by looking at history of chinese politics through the state level of analysis and understanding the concept of nationalism.
- Narrates how andrew sorkin's dealbook anxiety rising over relations between japan and china comments. new york times. cooper, helene.
- Analyzes how the senkaku/diaoyu dispute isn't going away any soon.
1059 wordsRead More - Diaoyu Islands Essayopinion essayThe dispute on the Diaoyu islands/senkaku concerns a dispute over territorial ownership of these islands between China and Japan as well as Taiwan. China disputed the transfer of the islands to Japan by the US after its administration of the islands came to the end in 1972. The dispute is worsening, especially, by the islands’ rich nature resource, the shipping lanes and the most important is that natural gas (Lohmeyer, 2008). As Japan argues that a survey of the islands has found them that belong to them, and China provides the evidence that indicates that they belong to China and were taken as part of Japan’s imperial conquests. Although the US has no official position regarding the islands, they have to ensure that any attack on the islands would require the US to aid Japan due to the US and Japan’s Treaty of Mutual Security and Cooperation
In this essay, the author
- Explains the dispute on the diaoyu islands/senkaku concerns a dispute over territorial ownership of these islands between china and japan as well as taiwan.
- Explains that they acted in the simulation as the chinese community, cfddi-china federation of defending diaoyu islands, which aims to retrieve the island. their main priorities are to counterattack the right-wing forces and government of japan who distort history
- Explains that cfddi has found many evidence to show that the islands belongs to china, based on ancient chinese documentation dating back to the ming dynasty.
- Opines that china was invaded by japan and suffered atrocities by japanese imperial forces. relations with japan have been a complex and sensitive issue in china's foreign policy.
- Opines that they would like to settle the dispute in a peaceful way. they argue that japan should accept the right-wing japan youth society's plan to build beacons on the diaoyu islands
- Analyzes how each player tried to gain their own profit, and forming allies with potential groups.
- Opines that the us government would prefer to help japan government, based on the japan us san francisco peace treaty signed in 1960. china highlights the cairo declaration signed by china, united states and the united kingdom
- Opines that the japanese community in the simulation was keeping saying that diaoyu island belongs to japan. they show a stand that they would not want both governments to back to the negotiation table.
- Opines that beijing's foreign policy has gradually shifted from a position of "keeping low profile and hiding its brightness" to an assertive stance, in both diplomacy and military matters.
- Explains that china increased the air defense identification zone to force japan back to the negotiation table, which gives them a direct support in the simulation.
- Explains that the simulation made the state actors back to the negotiation table again. the diaoyu dispute is a complex issue in the international relationship.
- Analyzes how the simulation shows the sovereignty game between the two main state actors which are japan and china.
- Explains that the right wing force in japan increases their affect to the policy. if the japanese government stands straight in the dispute, it could satisfy the request from the left
- Analyzes how japan's stand towards diaoyu islands tends to be hardened, which causes the chinese community which is us to stand up.
- Explains that china's passive action in the simulation may due to the fact that she is still in development. any conflict to china would make her in a bad situation, especially wars.
- Analyzes how the us government showed an ambiguous stance towards the dispute stating that would support neither china nor japan.
- Explains that the diaoyu island dispute has been worsened due to the strategic importance in terms of security and economic as well as political implications.
1499 wordsRead More - Senkaku Islands Case Studyanalytical essayOver the past decades, Japan and China have been arguing over the Senkaku Islands or the Diaoyu Islands. These islands are known to be close to many shipping lines and near potential oil reserves (BBC 2014). The dispute however, goes beyond the "rightful" ownership of a few islands, it is about the principles. To the two countries, it seems as if whomever “wins” rightful ownership means that they are more powerful. By China claiming these islands, they express their dominance over Japan. By Japan claiming these islands, they stand their ground on the islands that they have inhabited for years. Although the two countries have not declared war yet, I believe they are acting under a realism approach. The Chinese government has no legal records of reserving the rights to these islands; nonetheless, China presumes they are superior in the
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how japan and china have been arguing over the senkaku islands or the diaoyu islands, which are close to shipping lines and potential oil reserves.
- Explains that china is under the assumption that they were and currently remain the owner of the diaoyu islands.
- Argues that japan's willingness to surrender the senkaku islands would mean deportation or paying a fee to the chinese government — they believe in and are willing to fight back in war.
- Explains that china and japan have their personal views on who has the proper rights to these islands, but no third party has stepped in to support either side. the us will likely not interfere with this situation since this island debate is between the two countries without any proper documentation to reference back to.
- Opines that both countries are willing to strike back in combat in order to maintain their status.
858 wordsRead More - Islands Conflict Within China and Japanopinion essay“An eye for an eye will only make the whole world blind.” quoted by Mahatma Gandhi. Japan and China have disputed over the islands located in the East China Sea known as Senkaku islands in Japanese or Diaoyu islands in Chinese. The islands itself don’t have any valuable resources since it’s only a small rocky island. But then, the country will expand the territory or maybe as the symbol of power.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that japan and china have disputed over the islands located in the east china sea known as senkaku islands in japanese or diaoyu islands in chinese.
- Explains that china has developed significantly in the past few decades, with its greatest power of both economy and army. japan was the 2nd place before but now rank down to the 3rd place.
- Analyzes how the two major theories in international relation, realism and liberalism, have confronted a different position.
- Opines that the u.s. is a key factor in the island conflict between japan and korea.
- Opines that the ideal solution is a non-zero sum game, which can exchange cultures, expand business into china, or add more student exchange program between universities.
624 wordsRead More - The Relationship between the US and Chinaanalytical essayFrom the beginning of their establishment, the bilateral relations between the United States of America and China have changed throughout the time. The bilateral relations of the two countries emerged from 1970’s with the ‘Ping-Pong’ diplomacy and there have been many pauses in their mutual relations. The US and China enjoyed cooperation in economic and military spheres and the mutual relations grew massively during until the end of 1990’s. The heads of the two states began visiting each other’s countries and the economic ties were tightening year by year. However, the issues of human rights and free speech declined mutual Sino-American relations. The American principle of democracy promotion and human rights protection minimized the Sino- American relations after the Tiananmen Square events in 1989, the US Presidents-George Bush and Bill Clinton- playing a key role in determining the further American foreign policy towards China.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the first decade of american-chinese relations started in 1971 with 'ping-pong diplomacy', when mao zedong invited american table tennis team to visit china.
- Analyzes how the events of tiananmen square had a negative impact on the relations between the us and china.
- Explains that the president of the united states formulates american foreign policy and plays an important role in the conflict situations. the case of tiananmen massacre became a topic for debate in both domestic and international politics.
- Analyzes how the issue of human rights in china and the tiananmen incident negatively influenced the diplomatic relations between america and china.
- Explains that the relations between the united states of america and china have always been unstable. the two countries developed mutual relations from the end of world war ii until the 1970s.
- Cites bosworth, barry, "conflicts in the u.s.-china economic relationship: opposite sides of the same coin?", the brookings institution.
- Cites dong, wang, the asia-pacific journal, vol. 11, issue 24, no. 4, june 17, 2013.
- Cites lawrence, susan v., "u.s.-china relations: an overview of policy issues", accessed october 19, 2013.
- Explains that china through a lens is a lens of china-us relations, accessed october 19, 2013.
- Opines that china's foreign relations after tiananmen: challenges for the u.s.
- Explains turner, oliver, "sino-us relations then and now: discourse, images, policy", political perspectives 2011, vol.
- Cites yuan, jing-dong, "sino-us military relations since tiananmen: restoration, progress, and pitfalls".
- Cites yan, xuetong, "the instability of china–us relations", the chinese journal of international politics 3, no. 3 (2010): 263-292.
- Explains that the bilateral relations between the united states of america and china have changed since the 1970s with the 'ping-pong' diplomacy.
- Explains that the 1980s were the decade of different types of reforms and growth in the american-chinese transfer of goods, values, ideas and technology.
1491 wordsRead More