Dbq Essay # 1: The Voyage Of King Ferdinand

874 Words2 Pages

The most putrid part of Ferdinand's failure as a leader was his ship conditions. There were no beds or hammocks, so men slept on the hard floor boards. Sleep was still a luxury though because men had to keep watch in the night. Although these watchmen helped to avoid obstacles while sailing through the Magellan Strait, a lack of sleep was an unhealthy trade for success. Through all of the physical strain, the sailors could not even nourish their bodies, their primary food being hardtack. That mixture of flour and water supplied no nutrients but tricked the men into feeling full. In one account, Antonio Pigafetta describes the conditions of the voyage. He explains of a time in which the crew was in the Pacific Ocean for over three months with …show more content…

They also ate ox hide, wood shavings, and rats to fill their need for food. To top it all off they drank yellow, pungent water, but that was not the worst part. Pigafetta wrote, “...this misfortune i will mention is the worst, it was the upper and lower gums of most of our men grew [swelled] so much that they could not eat, and in this way so many suffered, that nineteen died…”(Document D). Many crew members were plagued with scurvy due to their poor diet, and Pigafetta went on in his journal about the other sicknesses that would claim many more lives. Contrastingly, Magellan never got the vitamin C deficiency like the other men or suffered in hunger. He selfishly ate his own delicacies, some of which included quince jelly to prevent scurvy (Document D). The men on board watched their friends die while Magellan had not care, leading to their plots of a mutiny. The eighteen men who survived until the end of the voyage had lived in these conditions for nearly three years. Many sailors became disgusted by the ship conditions, but the Ferdinand Magellan was despised more for the way he treated …show more content…

He had an important mission: find a way to the spice islands and bring back the riches, but most importantly bring the spices back with the five ships and 280 young men. Magellan was a great navigator but a harsh one. This can be good, until a leader refuses to listen to the ones he is leading. When Magellan stopped at the Port of St. Julian, he decided to put the crew on reduced rations (Document B). The change seems nearly unsurvivable compared to the conditions they were already struggling through, so they staged a mutiny. Three important leaders of the ships took the fall for this one. The treasurer of the whole fleet, Luis Mendoza was stabbed to death by the chief constable of the fleet, sent by Magellan (Document B). Gaspar de Quesada was ordered to be decapitated and quartered. Finally, Cartagena were abandoned on an island (Document B). Magellan was unwilling to reason with his crew members and instead removed what he saw was the problem. He issue was not the mutinous crew, but his own views. It did not take long for Magellan to anger more people. While crossing the Pacific, he added God to his list of things to sail for. On the island of Cebu, he converted about 2,200 people to Catholicism, but threatened those who did not convert (Document B). He burned down a village on Mactan, sparking a battle with the people ruled under the leader Lapu Lapu (Document B). In

Open Document