Comparison of Moi, un Noir and La Pyramide Humaine

1072 Words3 Pages

The comparison of Moi, un Noir and La Pyramide Humaine portrays a very different reality of Abidjah, Treuichville. The question of authority, who's version is more "true", to me, does not arise because in neither film were the subjects being filmed attempting to "speak for" the city. They speak for themselves, and their lives. In Moi, un Noir, they speak of the different cities based on class/economic difference and in La Pyramide humaine is all about exploring the different cities between what they call the European students and the African students.

Even though Moi, un Noir was released in 1958 and La Pyramide Humaine was released in 1961, I wonder if the filming of the two ever overlapped, if the films shared any footage such as footage of the La Goumbe social club or the footage of the water skiing in Moi, un Noir. If they were filmed serially and year/years apart (which I believe to be the case - the S. African event they discuss in the film sounds like the Sharpville massacre which happened in 1960), how much increased familiarity of Abidjah and the people of Abidjah affected Rouche - from longer immersion/greater participant observation to simple production ability to source things such as paperwork for permission to film at an airport/on a tarmac or find a plane for the aerial view at the end of La Pyramide Humaine, knowing increased technical awareness of what nighttime filming conditions of La Goumbe was to take better footage the second time around, finding a classroom for class scenes, possibly finding some of the later participants of La Pyramide Humaine from going to La Goumbe earlier or talking to the waterskiers, etc.

Then the lack of use comparatively "high touch" production in Moi un Noir and the use in La Py...

... middle of paper ...

...of control that echoed what the participants were portraying.

In all, the presentation of the multiple, different perceptions of the same reality by the participants of the film (eg, who has won Nadine's affection, one person, everyone, no one?) is a subtle version of Rashmon's explicit presentation of clashing multiple realities. This also fits in well with the different presentations of the Abidjah between Moi, un Noir and La Pyramide Humaine.

As an aside, I think the party music opened with the same piece played at the bar in the Battle of Algiers bombing scene. Battle of Algiers was made years later so it probably was a coincidental connection, both just played a popular dance song, but the sound of the music accompanied by a visual of young French people dancing in a colonial setting made me think immediatly that the party was going to end up no where good.

Open Document