Comparison Between The Laboratory And Macbeth

1089 Words3 Pages

In this essay I will compare and contrast a poem written by Robert Browning ‘The Laboratory’ with Act 1 Scene 5 of ‘Macbeth’, a play written by William Shakespeare. It will look to address the relationships within each text and focus on the themes of madness and jealousy regarding the two female protagonists.
In both pieces of text we can identify similar characters with the same sinister intentions. Both writers express their character actions alike each other however there is a slight difference personality wise. In Macbeth, Lady Macbeth is portrayed as a dominant female that holds enough power to manipulate her husband into committing actions that would not have otherwise taken place if the choice were left to Macbeth. However, in ‘The Laboratory’ we are shown a troubled woman who is pushed to the brink of madness where she does not attempt to defeat her rivals openly and therefore takes a route of sinister stealth to win her battle.
Both Act 1 Scene 5 of ‘Macbeth’ and ‘The Laboratory’ consist of female characters that are mentally disturbed. Firstly, it is important to consider the root of their mental deterioration. Where, the speaker in the Laboratory appears to be on the verge of mentality with her deathly plot of killing her husband’s lover, it appears that Lady Macbeth ventures on a different route to give her husband a prosperous future. They both have killer motives for love and both share the same desire to reach an objective that seems to benefit them, in either power or self-confidence.
Macbeth’s letter explaining his encounter with the three weird sisters did in no way startle Lady Macbeth, not as a wife or women. Her reaction to the considerate letter straight away sets her in a mindset where she quickly grasps t...

... middle of paper ...

...s an ‘open relationship’ since the speaker clearly disapproves. This is the reason why an outlook of a jealous stalker as opposed to a cheated wife is a more reasonable approach to consider.
To conclude, William Shakespeare and Robert Browning portray the women in a powerful approach. Both characters in each piece of text resort to plotting murder in their love and affection for their other half. In ‘Macbeth’, Lady Macbeth uses power and personal gain as a motive to kill and in ‘The Laboratory’, the speaker’s passionate hatred and jealousy towards the mistress is a means of committing a grave offence as a result of her bitterness. Although each character has different motives, they both show glimpses of sheer insanity. These two texts evidently diverge away from what seemed to be depicted as the ‘norm’ in their era, where women were seen to be subordinate to men.

Open Document