Compare And Contrast The Cask Of Amontillado And Tell Tale Heart

analytical Essay
796 words
796 words

Reading Edgar Allen Poe’s works such as “The Cask of Amontillado” and “Tell-Tale Heart” are both written around 1840’s and written in the gothic style. Poe displays his horror short stories, in which the reader can differentiate his signature style. Although many of Poe’s significant works may have a similar theme, the reader can distinguish the themes through the characters in “The Cask of Amontillado” and “Tell-Tale Heart.” The general setting of each novel depicts the theme of the story throughout the whole plot. In “Tell-Tale Heart,” the story was presumably taken place during a dark, dreary night. The dark night portrays the plot remains to be sinister, uncanny, and unpredictable till the conclusion. However, “The Cask of Amontillado” …show more content…

In this essay, the author

  • Explains that edgar allen poe's horror short stories, such as "the cask of amontillado" and "tell-tale heart," are written in the gothic style.
  • Analyzes how the general setting of each novel depicts the theme of the story throughout the whole plot. "tell-tale heart" was taken place during a dark, dreary night, while "the cask of amontillado" is taken during the carnival season.
  • Analyzes how "the cask of amontillado" and "tell-tale heart" differ from the reasoning behind the murder to the techniques each villain takes in role.
  • Compares montressor and fortunado in "the cask of amontillado" by comparing their personalities. in "tell-tale heart," the murderer's unstable mental health and guilty conscience lead him to bury the old man'
  • Compares poe's "the cask of amontillado" and "tell-tale heart" in terms of horror and suspense.

In the “The Cask of Amontillado,” Montresor believes Fortunado is his greatest enemy and in return for revenge he must kill him. He achieves his goal through a depraved plan, in which he manipulated Fortunado to drink until he lost his senses for the amontillado. In “Tell-Tale Heart,” Poe depicts the murderer has no valid reason to kill the old man. The murderer’s sanity comes into question many times when the story takes place. The first sentence in the story proves this statement: “TRUE! – NERVOUS – VERY, VERY DREADFUL nervous I had been and am; but why will you say I am mad?” (Charter 1127). The narrator himself questions the audience before telling the incident that has occurred. In this story, the murder plot is not planned and takes place all of the sudden when the insane man decides to kill the fragile old man who is on the alert …show more content…

In “The Cask of Amontillado,” Montressor was calm and collected. He is ruthless in achieving his only motive throughout the story, which is revenge for how Fortunado has offended him. Even after Montressor committed murder, he does not reveal this fact to anyone for over fifty years. This fact depicts Montressor does not feel guilty. On the other hand, In “Tell-Tale Heart,” the man’s personality is described as insane, constantly nervous, and paranoid. He rarely sleeps at all and portrays to be completely lonely. Once the man kills the old man, he instantly begins hearing a noise a heart pumping. The pumping of the old man’s heart, which is getting louder each moment, portrays the killer’s guilty conscience. However, in the the “Tell-Tale Heart, the murderer’s unstable mental health and guilty conscience lead him to bury the old man’s body under the floorboard in an extremely brutal manner. He also confesses to the authority, assuming they can all hear the noise of the heart

Get Access