Compare And Contrast Araby And A & P

520 Words2 Pages

Compare if you will both short stories of "Araby" and "A&P", the unnamed boy and Sammy are young males expressing a sort of love or lust towards a particular female. In "Araby", we were never told the young woman's name and she was referred to as Mangan’s sister. Also, in "A&P" the female interest was given the moniker of Queenie. In both cases, the boys of each story attempted to impress their love interest by presenting something they perceived would win them over. Sammy endeavored to defend the supposed infringement of the girls’ dignity with an ill-timed outburst, after they were chastised about their state of dress; in "Araby", the unnamed boy promised to return with a gift from the bazaar for Mangan’s sister. Both failed miserably in …show more content…

When read, it evoked a feeling of brightness, sunshine, and of exposed skin of the girls in the supermarket. All the words used portrayed the physical attributes of the girls’ sexuality. Sammy, was enthralled by the uncommon amount of skin exhibited in the supermarket. “The women generally put on a shirt or shorts or something before they get out of the car into the street. And anyway these are usually women with six children and varicose veins mapping their legs and nobody, including them, could care less (Updike J, 1961)”. In contrast, "Araby" portrayed a darker more gloomier setting. The imageries are heavier and referred to death and vacant structures. Much of the story happens within the night and evening. Correspondingly the unnamed boy’s attraction to Mangan’s sister conveyed more of a suffering of sentiment than it did the lightness of love. Paradoxically the attraction to the girl expressed by the boy is not sexual in nature, but a sensual one. There was no nudity and a remark of the convent she attended. The descriptions of her read as dark, unattainable sensuality, "She was waiting...her figure defined by the light. Her dress swung as she moved her body, and the soft rope of her hair tossed from side to side (Joyce J,

Show More
Related

  • Comparing Araby And A & P

    995 Words  | 2 Pages

    A person’s life is often a journey of study and learning from errors and mistakes made in the past. In both James Joyce’s Araby and John Updike’s A&P, the main characters, subjected to the events of their respective stories, are forced to reflect upon their actions which failed to accomplish their original goal in impressing another character. Evidently, there is a similar thematic element that emerges from incidents in both short stories, which show maturity as an arduous process of learning from failures and a loss of innocence. By analyzing the consequences of the interaction of each main character; the Narrator in Araby and Sammy in A&P; and their persons of infatuation, Mangan’s sister

    Read More

  • Unrealisticism In A & P By John Updike And Araby

    1154 Words  | 3 Pages

    The protagonist of Araby is a young boy who is infatuated with his friend Mangan 's sister. The setting, and the introduction of the this woman is nearly identical to that in A&P. Joyce 's narrator spends his time “lay[ing] on the floor in the front parlour watching [Magnan 's sister 's] door” (Joyce 182). Immediately from the outset of the story, Joyce has rendered the narrator as someone who frivolously awaits his female interest with no other motivation. The main character then finally encounters Magnan 's sister personally, where she tells him about a bazaar near town called Araby. Joyce 's protagonist is shocked when Magnan 's sister “addresse[s] the first words to [him]” (Joyce 183) as he has spent a plethora of time yearning for an interaction with her. Joyce has implemented the idea into Araby that males are inherently reliant on females. Interestingly, Joyce has incorporated another male character in his story that is presented as inferior to his female counterpart. The purpose of the narrator 's uncle in the story is to slow the main character from going to Araby. The Uncle comes home much later than expected, and is chastised my his wife: “Can 't you give him the money and let him go? You 'v kept him late enough as it

    Read More

  • The Narrative Voice in Araby, Livvie and The Yellow Wallpaper

    961 Words  | 2 Pages

    In "Araby" the story is told from the point of view of a man remembering a childhood experience. The story is told in the first person. The reader has access to the thoughts of the narrator as he relives his experience of what we assume is his first crush. We do not know how the girl feels about him. The narrator's youth and inexperience influence his perspective. His love for her is deep and innocent. As an adult, the narrator recollects his emotions for the girl with fondness, but the reader also detects a hint of regret as well. The narrator tells us that their first communication takes place when he goes to the back drawing room where the priest had died. There, in that sacred place, he spoke with the girl and made a promise that he would get her a gift if he was able to go to Araby. Soon after, "as a creature driven by vanity", he fails to retrieve a gift for her and is humiliated. I wonder if the narrator is implying that his true devotion to her was somehow blessed in the room where the priest died and when he allowed his sinful vanity to penetrate that love, he lost her.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Araby And A & P

    545 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this essay I will discuss the short stories A&P by John Updike and Araby by James Joyce which share several similarities as well as distinct differences between the themes and the main characters. I will compare or contrast two or more significant literary elements from each of the stories and discuss how those elements contribute to each story’s theme.

    Read More

  • The Reality of World in Araby and Boys and Girls

    1184 Words  | 3 Pages

    In “Araby” and “Boys and Girls” the plots illustrate that both of the adolescents experience the common phase of growing up. They learn the universal lesson of how different the world is, compared to how they would like to see. The young boy in “Araby” grows into a young man and the girl in “Boys and Girls” accepts the reality that she is a girl. Freeing the horse was like freeing herself. The protagonists in both stories go through learning experience that we all go through, but the way in which these learning experience occur differs with each of us.

    Read More

  • James Joyce's Araby - Loss of Innocence in Araby

    874 Words  | 2 Pages

    In her story, "Araby," James Joyce concentrates on character rather than on plot to reveal the ironies inherent in self-deception. On one level "Araby" is a story of initiation, of a boy’s quest for the ideal. The quest ends in failure but results in an inner awareness and a first step into manhood. On another level the story consists of a grown man's remembered experience, for the story is told in retrospect by a man who looks back to a particular moment of intense meaning and insight. As such, the boy's experience is not restricted to youth's encounter with first love. Rather, it is a portrayal of a continuing problem all through life: the incompatibility of the ideal, of the dream as one wishes it to be, with the bleakness of reality. This double focus-the boy who first experiences, and the man who has not forgotten-provides for the dramatic rendering of a story of first love told by a narrator who, with his wider, adult vision, can employ the sophisticated use of irony and symbolic imagery necessary to reveal the story's meaning.

    Read More

  • The Decline of Chivalry Explored in Araby and A&P

    1205 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Araby” tells the story of a young boy who romanticizes over his friend’s older sister. He spends a lot of time admiring the girl from a distance. When the girl finally talks to him, she reveals she cannot go to the bazaar taking place that weekend, he sees it as a chance to impress her. He tells her that he is going and will buy her something. The boy becomes overwhelmed by the opportunity to perform this chivalrous act for her, surely allowing him to win the affections of the girl. The night of the bazaar, he is forced to wait for his drunken uncle to return home to give him money to go. Unfortunately, this causes the boy to arrive at the bazaar as it is closing. Of the stalls that remained open, he visited one where the owner, and English woman, “seemed to have spoken to me out of a sense of duty” (Joyce 89) and he knows he will not be able to buy anything for her. He decides to just go home, realizing he is “a creature driven and derided with vanity” (Joyce 90). He is angry with himself and embarrassed as he...

    Read More

  • Ugliness in Araby, by James Joyce

    686 Words  | 2 Pages

    "Araby", a short story by James Joyce, is a despondent memory of adolescence narrated by a now grown man. The narrator recalls his first love, the older sister of his friend Mangan. He relates to us how he waited for her to leave her house for school before he would leave his house, trailing behind her until their ways parted, then passing her and going on his way. They had not had a conversation, until one day she asked him if he was going to Araby. Araby was the name of a bazaar that took place in Dublin in May 1894 (Beatty et al. 397). The narrator then, due to Mangan's sister's insistence that it would be "splendid" and that she would love to go (Joyce 397), decided to go to Araby, and to get her something there, because she could not attend. Once the idea was in his head, the narrator could think of nothing else, and the syllables of the word Araby grow to envelop the narrator and "cast an Eastern enchantment over [him]" (Joyce 397). The Saturday night of the Bazaar, the narrator's uncle, with whom he lived, returned home late. He was still allowed to go to the bazaar; however, he arrived shortly before it closed, and, as a result was unable to buy anything before it became dark. The setting in "Araby" is described in detail, and is important to the story: it sets the tone, and it helps us understand the characters.

    Read More

  • Araby And A & P Compare And Contrast

    608 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the story “ A&P”. The protagonist , Sammy. lives in a tedious town north of Boston, where he works as a cashier in a grocery shop. Doing the same work in the same sterile environment, Sammy is excited to see girls wearing bikinis to come in. For Sammy, girls symbolize the opportunity to change. Also, Sammy speaks of people in the town saying” the customer had been showing up with their carts but, you know, sheep, seeing a scene, they had all bunched up on Staksie”. From his point of view, the boring town has changed citizens into mindless sheep. He shows condescesion through his later action. Just like Sammy, the Irish boy in “Araby” lives in a strictly religious and gloomy surrounding where he seek chances to escape reality. Megan’s sister is the light in the dark

    Read More

  • Araby By James Joyce Literary Analysis

    660 Words  | 2 Pages

    In his short story “Araby”, James Joyce tells a story of a young boy’s infatuation with his friend’s sister, Mangan, and the issues that arise which ultimately extinguish his love for her. In his first struggle, the narrator admires Mangan’s outer beauty, however, “her name was like a summons to all his blood,” which made him embarrassed to talk with her (Joyce 318). Every day he would look under a curtain in the room and wait for her to walk outside so he could follow her to school, but then he would simply walk quickly by and never say anything to her (Joyce 318). In addition to his inability to share his feelings with Mangan, the boy allows difficulties to get in the way of his feelings for her. After struggling to get his uncle’s permission

    Read More

  • Araby: A Lesson in Adolescence

    1166 Words  | 3 Pages

    In his brief but complex story "Araby," James Joyce concentrates on character rather than on plot to reveal the ironies within self-deception. On one level "Araby" is a story of initiation, of a boy's quest for the ideal. The quest ends in failure but results in an inner awareness and a first step into manhood. On another level the story consists of a grown man's remembered experience, for a man who looks back to a particular moment of intense meaning and insight tells the story in retrospect. As such, the boy's experience is not restricted to youth's encounter with first love. Rather, it is a portrayal of a continuing problem all through life: the incompatibility of the ideal, of the dream as one wishes it to be, with the bleakness of reality. This double focus-the boy who first experiences, and the man who has not forgotten provides for the rendering of a story of first love told by a narrator who, with his wider, adult vision, can employ the sophisticated use of irony and symbolic imagery necessary to reveal the story's meaning. The story opens with a description of North Richmond Street, a "blind," "cold ... .. silent" (275)street where the houses "gazed at one an-other with brown imperturbable faces.".(275) The former tenant, a priest, died in the back room of the house, and his legacy-several old yellowed books, which the boy enjoys leafing through because they are old, and a bicycle pump rusting in the back yard-become symbols of the intellectual and religious vitality of the past. Every morning before school the boy lies on the floor in the front parlor peeking out through a crack in the blind of the door, watching and waiting for the girl next door to emerge from her house and walk to school. He is shy and still boyish.

    Read More

  • The Motivation for Anguish

    872 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...om Joyce’s childhood. The young boy may have felt anguish, but the adult that looks back at himself sees someone who desires romance and happiness. Joyce explains “Araby” as the life of a young boy who has dreams and high expectations of the world, but instead the young boy gets a bitter taste of reality.

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis Of Epiphany In Araby By James Joyce

    1298 Words  | 3 Pages

    The visual and emblematic details established throughout the story are highly concentrated, with Araby culminating, largely, in the epiphany of the young unnamed narrator. To Joyce, an epiphany occurs at the instant when the essence of a character is revealed, when all the forces that endure and influence his life converge, and when we can, in that moment, comprehend and appreciate him. As follows, Araby is a story of an epiphany that is centered on a principal deception or failure, a fundamental imperfection that results in an ultimate realization of life, spirit, and disillusionment. The significance is exposed in the boy’s intellectual and emotional journey from first love to first dejection,

    Read More

  • A Journey into Self-Discovery in Araby by James Joyce and Katherine Mansfield’s, The Garden Party

    1267 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout “Araby”, the main character experiences a dynamic character shift as he recognizes that his idealized vision of his love, as well as the bazaar Araby, is not as grandiose as he once thought. The main character is infatuated with the sister of his friend Mangan; as “every morning [he] lay on the floor in the front parlour watching her door…when she came on the doorstep [his] heart leaped” (Joyce 108). Although the main character had never spoken to her before, “her name was like a summons to all [his] foolish blood” (Joyce 108). In a sense, the image of Mangan’s sister was the light to his fantasy. She seemed to serve as a person who would lift him up out of the darkness of the life that he lived. This infatuation knew no bounds as “her image accompanied [him] even in places the most hostile to romance…her name sprang to [his] lips at moments in strange prayers and praises which [he] did not understand” (Joyce 109). The first encounter the narrator ex...

    Read More

  • James Joyce's Araby - An Analysis of Araby

    528 Words  | 2 Pages

    Araby is about escaping into the world of fantasy. The narrator is infatuated with his friend's sister; he hides in the shadows, peering secluded from a distance trying to spy her "brown figure"(Joyce 38). She is the light in his fantasy, someone who will lift him out of darkness. I see many parallels to my life as a boy growing up in the inner city of Jersey City. We looked for escape also, a trip uptown to Lincoln Park, or take a train ride to New York City where we would gaze at the beauties on 7th Ave.

    Read More

More about Compare And Contrast Araby And A & P

Open Document