Bruce Chatwin's On the Black Hill

2751 Words6 Pages

Without change, something sleeps inside us, and seldom awakens. The sleeper must awaken (Frank Herbert, 1965). Bruce Chatwin's On the Black Hill, is a work of great dramatic intensity. Without change, something sleeps inside us, and seldom awakens. The sleeper must awaken" (Frank Herbert, 1965). Bruce Chatwin's On the Black Hill, is 'a work of great dramatic intensity'. The novel spans the majority of the twentieth century, a period of immense social, economic and political change, and clearly chronicles the conflict between modernisation and tradition that occurs during this period. Throughout the closely intertwined lives of Lewis and Benjamin Jones, this conflict is apparent, and a sense of the immensity of the changes which are taking place is conveyed. It is difficult to judge whether Chatwin endorses the traditional or modernising aspects of the world he presents in On the Black Hill. However, while evaluating Chatwin's stance on the subject of change, we must keep in mind that the twins live their life blocked off from the world, virtually unchanged, and as a result, something is always missing in their lives. Something inside them is always 'asleep' and they, especially Lewis, feel an emptiness to their life. In order to evaluate whether the novel is written in the interests of endorsing either modernisation or tradition, we must examine the degree to which Lewis and Benjamin's refusal to progress with the rest of the world affects their lives, as well as the various changes in social distinctions, gender discrimination, social practices and even technology that take place throughout the period that the novel spans. One of the most important social changes that occurred in the novel is the w... ... middle of paper ... ...ther than endorsing tradition or modernisation specifically, the novel On the Black Hill simply endorses change. Bruce Chatwin's message to the reader is conveyed through the lives of the twins, that 'without change, something sleeps inside us', and that in order to experience life fully, we must progress as the world around us progresses. However, although he approves of changes such as the dissipation of social and gender discrimination, Bruce Chatwin does not appear to support all forms of modernisation, and is sceptical about changing social practices and values, as well as society's violent solutions (such as war) to conflicts. The novel On the Black Hill teaches the reader that although we should not be trapped in the constraints of tradition as Lewis and Benjamin Jones were, we must be careful about the changes we make as well as their consequences.

Open Document