Brave New World VS The Island Essay

821 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: How The Society Influences The Media

No matter how they are told or expressed, most dystopian stories have several similar assets. They are usually made to be unique, however there are usually numerous links between them. The book Brave New World and the film “The Island” are prime examples of this statement. A few similarities include the actions of hypnopaedia, forbidden love and affection, and un-natural births.
“No social stability without individual stability” (Huxley, 2007, p.26) is a quote cited from the book Brave New World which helps to identify why, in their society, they feel it is mandatory to brainwash the developing children. This is done by playing continuous recordings during a specific amount of time while the children are sleeping. This is called sleep learning. This method was introduced by accident when a Polish boy named Reuben Rabinovitch fell asleep with a radio receiver on and was later able to recite an entire broadcast in English. The boy was not able to comprehend what he had heard, however this form of hypnopaedia was soon seen as an effective way to help report suggestions about morality, such as to convince people to be content with their place in society.
Much like the book Brave New World, a form of brainwash is introduced and used in the film “The Island” as well. Clones receive memory implants and are exposed to video clips of real life experiences throughout the twelve months they are growing. These videos vary between twelve different generic life memories. After the twelve months are over, the clones come to believe that they are real human survivors who had been saved from a worldwide contamination. This process helps to convince them that they are real human beings, without having any thoughts that they could be clones. All i...

... middle of paper ...

...ile developing in a large plastic sac. Just like in Brave New World, they are ranked by castes such as Echo, Delta and others. However, the different castes depend on which generation they were fabricated in. These clones are used if the clients are in need of an organ transplant, a surrogate mother or for other purposes. Therefore, in both Brave New World and “The Island”, there are no natural births and each person in placed into a specific caste.
As one can clearly see, it is clear that the book Brave New World and the film “The Island” are very similar in more ways than one. They both use corresponding ways to ensure a perfect society. Hypnopaedia, forbidden love and affection, and un-natural births are a aspects used to identify the similarities. Considering the similarities and equalities, which of the two societies resemble the twenty first century the most?

Show More
Related

  • Brave New World Poem And Book Comparison

    304 Words  | 1 Pages

    Aldous Huxley and Robert William Service reveal though their works that people often become deceived, which makes them think falsely of reality. The novel communicates Bernard’s thoughts while on the drug soma on the helicopter ride: He “laughed; after two grammes of soma the joke seemed, for some reason, good” (Huxley 105). Huxley’s use of soma as a motif for artificial happiness in his quote reveals that Bernard only seems pleasant and easy to laugh because of a false source of his emotions that cause his “happiness.” Bernard only laughs at the electrocuted animals, the cruel joke by the pilot, because the soma influences his thoughts, words, and behaviors. His deceit, caused by drugs, results in

    Read More

  • Comparing Fahrenheit 451 And A Brave New World

    583 Words  | 2 Pages

    Perfect societies, which work flawlessly, could not be possible without some sort of government involvement such in communism. In these two novels, despotism caused by an authority or totalitarian regime brings about a society which conforms to these governments’ norms and doctrines. Their main purpose is to control people and restrict their freedom to execute certain acts. For example, the government controls relationships by creating an authoritarian atmosphere and removes the basic must for a relationship, which is love, between men and women. Also, there is hardly any proper family life which consists of solidarity and unity. In terms of totalitarian governments, A Brave New World and Fahrenheit 451 have a number of important differences. In the A Brave New World, the World State controls the society thoroughly even before the birth. Test tube babies and hypnopaedia (sleep learning) are utilized throughout the creation of the lives. In this

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Harrison Bergeron

    430 Words  | 1 Pages

    The two stories are most similar when it comes to plot. As well as the dystopian element

    Read More

  • Orwellian Juxtapositions Essay

    509 Words  | 2 Pages

    It is quite easy as a society to read a Dystopian novel such as 1984 and judge those peoples’ reality. In society today citizens may stand complacent to certain similarities due to their commonplace and possibly a skewed perception of reality. These similarities can range from contemporary surveillance and police to certain governments found in the modern world. Though people of the modern world may not immediately see such similarities, they are hidden in plain sight. For instance, Turkey has several similarities to Oceania, there is surveillance at every turn, and even modern police officers have a semblance to the Thought Police in 1984.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Fahrenheit 451 And The Truman Show

    882 Words  | 2 Pages

    Dystopias in literature and other media serve as impactful warnings about the state of our current life and the possible future. Two examples of this are in the book Fahrenheit 451 and the movie The Truman Show. Both works show the harmful effects of advancing technology and the antisocial tendencies of a growing society. The protagonists of these stories are very similar also. Guy Montag and Truman Burbank are the only observant people in societies where it is the norm to turn a blind eye to the evils surrounding them. Fahrenheit 451 and The Truman Show present like messages in very unlike universes while giving a thought-provoking glimpse into the future of humanity.

    Read More

  • Individuality Vs. Social Stability

    1330 Words  | 3 Pages

    Social restriction robs individuals of their creative personalities by preventing freedom of thought, behavior, and expression; but is vital to the World State for maintaining complete control over the society. Social restriction’s purpose is to enforce obedience conformity and compliance out of people. The World State achieves this through two methods; hypnopaedia and shock therapy. Hypnopaedia is sleep-teaching where morals are taught on on repeat during the infant years of children while they are asleep, these messages become permanently embedded in their mind and become their permanent, new, artificial personality. This is proven in the quote “... drops of liquid sealing wax, drops that adhere, incrust and inc...

    Read More

  • Free Will In Brave New World

    1251 Words  | 3 Pages

    A novel titled the “brave new world” touches on a continuous theme of no free will, technology, control, routine lifestyle, and hopelessness. Brave new world leaves a that one should always fight for freedom, choose to live the way that one wants to, and highlights that one can easily get manipulated by a higher knowing source. A movie called the island has an ongoing theme that one should never settle and always fight for one's freedom. this movie relates to this novel due to the similar themes. These two have close connections and differences, these two stories relate due to the fact that they both have the theme of no free will, they differ due to the fact brave new world is more fictional written meanwhile the island is meant to show real

    Read More

  • Brave New World by Aldous Huxley

    1024 Words  | 3 Pages

    Brave New World, a novel written by Aldous Huxley, can be compared and contrasted with an episode of The Twilight Zone, a fantasy, science-fiction television series, called “Number 12 Looks Just Like You.” Brave New World is a highly regarded and renowned work of literature as The Twilight Zone is considered one of the greatest television series of all time. Brave New World and The Twilight Zone’s episode “Number 12 Looks Just Like You” can be compared and contrasted on the basis of science, youth, and the government.

    Read More

  • Comparing the Philosophies of Brave New World and Anthem

    1185 Words  | 3 Pages

    Before launching into the implications of these two novels, I believe a summary of the general human experience in each of the two societies is necessary. Brave New World illustrates a society in which science has been elevated to a god-like position. In this novel, human thoughts and actions are controlled by conditioning, which in turn is controlled by a select few members of the dominant caste. Depending on the caste they are bred for, individuals in Brave New World are developed differently. All humans are created in a laboratory and higher caste individuals are allowed to develop relatively free from any mutation. Lower caste citizens, however, are created in mass quantity and are conditioned even as fetuses to enjoy hard labor. After being born, a process referred to in the novel as decanting, children are raised in group homes. From infancy through adolescence, children are conditioned into their society's worldview: "Everyone belongs to everyone else."  They are carefully conditioned to accept and reject things based on the society's best interests. While citizens in this world believe they have complete freedom, they are in reality unable to behave in any way other than how they have been conditioned. They date, but monogamy is out of the question. To grow...

    Read More

  • Dehumanization in Never Let Me Go vs. Gattaca

    828 Words  | 2 Pages

    Living in a world where they have successfully created human clones for organ donations, is not a great achievement to mankind in any way, shape, or form.  It makes you wonder, where exactly do you draw the line between the advancement of technology and the dehumanization that occurs because of it?"  Never Let Me Go is a Novel based in the main character Kathy’s memories of her experience in Hailsham and after she left. Hailsham is a boarding school for children who have been cloned from people considered as low life’s or unsuccessful, the only purpose given too these children are for them to develop into adults and donate as many of their mature organs as they can till they die, or as the students and guardians refer to it “complete”. The author focuses on the sick ways of our current society and warns us about the possible future that may be introduced and excepted, Kazuo Ishiguro writes with the intent of teaching and affecting the reader on an emotional level at the same time.

    Read More

  • Manipulation In Dr. Merrick's In The Island

    1566 Words  | 4 Pages

    Merrick, from The Island is a futurist manipulating puppeteer-like figure created by Bay to represent his similarities to Hitler. In the film, the clones are manipulated and lied to by Dr. Merrick, the owner of Biotech, the company that makes the clones or so-called “products.” As an example of manipulation, Merrick uses the fear of a world wide contamination that has wiped out the entire population to manipulate the clones in many ways. One way is that this fear allows the clones to view Merrick as their savior. They believe he actually saved them from dying, even though ironically he is instilling their near death. This allows Merrick to increase his ego and power because the clones view him as a God-like structure. Also, these clones are told that they will get to go to The Island, the only non-contaminated area of the Earth left. This is a deliberate falsehood told by Dr. Merrick, to get hold of a clone when it needs to be harvested for its owner, and to keep the rest of the clones under a virtually tyrannical control. Mental manipulation is used by Merrick through his lies about the individuality of each clone. Each clone is told by Merrick countless times, so it is brainwashed into them mentally, “You're special. You have a very special purpose in life” (The Island). This makes the clones feel humane and a sense of pride and individuality, even though ironically Merrick tells all of them this statement only to gain support and trust from them. Merrick views

    Read More

  • Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?

    1658 Words  | 4 Pages

    A person cannot be considered human if their thoughts are controlled by someone else. In Brave New World, children are conditioned to believe what the world state wants them to believe. A technological advancement, known as hypnopedia, can be used for moral teaching. During a child’s sleep, an incessant voice tells the child to follow behaviors that are beneficial to society. The hypnopedia, for example, can tell the world state motto, “Community, Identity, Stability” (Huxley 1). In Brave New World, a person no longer has free will because they are implanted with ideas on how to live. In Do androids Dream of Electri...

    Read More

  • Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World

    395 Words  | 1 Pages

    There were quite a few changes made from Aldous Huxley’s, Brave New World to turn it into a “made for TV” movie. The first major change most people noticed was Bernard Marx’s attitude. In the book he was very shy and timid toward the opposite sex, he was also very cynical about their utopian lifestyle. In the movie Bernard was a regular Casanova. He had no shyness towards anyone. A second major deviation the movie made form the book was when Bernard exposed the existing director of Hatcheries and Conditioning, Bernard himself was moved up to this position. In the book the author doesn’t even mention who takes over the position. The biggest change between the two was Lenina, Bernard’s girlfriend becomes pregnant and has the baby. The screenwriters must have made this up because the author doesn’t even mention it. The differences between the book and the movie both helped it and hurt it.

    Read More

  • Alienation In The Road Death

    1943 Words  | 4 Pages

    Dystopian novels can act as a mirror, reflecting our world and exaggerating aspects of it to create their horrific realities. However, dystopian fiction does not intend to simply add to the ugliness and cruelty present in the world. As a matter of fact its actual aim is entirely opposite- to warn against the grave “sin” Arthur Camus describes in his novel The Plague. By exploring a fictional universe, we are shown what could become of our own existence if these warnings are not heeded. The bleak desolation of Cormac McCarthy’s The Road and the utter horror of Richard Matheson’s

    Read More

  • The Use Of Cloning In Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go

    1346 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ever wondered what it would be like to have a clone? Or how they would live their lives? Would they have the same emotions everyone else obtains and expresses? In the novel Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro, clones are schooled and sheltered until they are ready to be carers progressing into organ donors. On that note, many questions have surfaced targeting whether or not cloning is considered ethical treatment or just an inhumane act from the human race. Kazuo Ishiguro stresses human rights and the ethical treatment of clone persons throughout his novel Never Let Me Go through his uses of narrative and literary devices in order to give the audience a feel for this subject.

    Read More

More about Brave New World VS The Island Essay

Open Document