Bowl Of Istanbul

787 Words2 Pages

Most of the time there is no need to experience the whole culture of a place, but by experiencing one part of it, we can learn enough of a culture, as we can perceive in the essays “Vietnam’s Bowl of Secrets” by David Farley with a dish and “The Wild Dogs of Istanbul” by Bernd Brunner on how they treat the wild dogs. The essay “Vietnam’s Bowl of Secrets” focuses mainly on the tradition for generation of a dish called “cao lau”. Through the discovering of this mystical dish, we can see how Farley shows a fuller “sense of the entire place” of Hoi An and its culture in addition to the mysterious way a family in this place has managed to keep the secret of the recipe of “cao lau” for over 100 years. Moreover, this essay shows one of its essence, …show more content…

While the main focus of this essay is the wild dogs we can notice a cultural conflict in the town, because of religion or tradition. This essay describes the town of Istanbul as having “a hundred thousand” dogs throughout the city, and how that the city is filled with trash. In addition to the above description, Brunner tells us some people are more sensitive to dogs and they feed and care for them, but do not allow them in the houses because “Quran, strict Muslin consider dogs—especially their drool—to be unclean”(89). We can relate the above statement with the passage when Brunner says that “[i]t sounds like the dogs, not the authorities, set the tone. In popular shadow-puppet plays, dogs were compared to the poor” (91). Mostly this essay, by focusing on dogs, is addressing a big conflict that Istanbul is experiencing with poor people. They cannot eliminate the dogs as they cannot get rid of people because that would be an act of “barbarism”. The essence of this essay is to show that the culture of this city is trying to deal with the unclean, both dogs and poor people, in a way that does not seem cruel. This essay reflects the above with all the attempts they have made to eliminate the dogs, meaning that they would like to get rid of them but they cannot because they just cannot eliminate a living creature just because its nature. Therefore, they most find some alternative to live with them, as most rich people

Open Document