Sin and Satire: D.H. Lawrence's Critique of The Scarlet Letter

757 Words2 Pages

The Epitome of Sin In D.H. Lawrence’s essay, “On The Scarlet Letter,” he criticizes Nathaniel Hawthorne’s wrongful idolization of Hester Prynne. Throughout The Scarlet Letter, Hester is treated as a victim rather than the criminal Lawrence believes her to be. In Lawrence’s essay, he analyzes Hester’s sin and mocks the book for becoming a farce. He focuses on the causes of Hester's sin, rather than the consequences. In analyzing Hester Prynne, Lawrence is effective in achieving his purpose due to his satirical tone, choppy syntax, and use of biblical allusions. Lawrence uses a satirical tone to negatively emphasize Hawthorne’s portrayal of Hester Prynne. Throughout the Scarlet Letter, Hawthorne depicts Hester in a way in which the reader develops a sympathetic attitude towards …show more content…

Lawrence is very strategic in how he places his words when describing Hester. Rather than using long, stuffy sentences, his choppy arrangement of words allows for the reader to fully understand each phrase and their purpose towards describing Hester Prynne. Lawrence insults Hester saying “She tickled [Dimmesdale] in the right place, and he fell. Flop. Flop goes spiritual love. But keep up the game. Keep up appearances. Pure are the pure” (Lawrence). By keeping his phrases choppy and reiterating the word “flop” he essentially aims bullets at Hester Prynne. Not only in committing her sin did she seduce a pure man, but knew she was going to cause another’s downfall. In another instance, Lawrence fires “bullets” when he states “Adulteress. Alpha. Abel. Adam. A. America. The Scarlet Letter” (Lawrence). This rapid fire of words fully emphasizes Lawrence’s opinion on Hester. Each word is used to shoot down Hester’s character. This choppy syntax effectively portrays Lawrence’s purpose due to the fact that it takes direct hits at Hester and displays her as a sinner rather than a

Open Document