Amanda Mote Essay

971 Words2 Pages

Writer Amanda Mote argues in her essay “Taking the ACT” that the ACT is not fulfilling its purpose as a knowledge standards test. She claims that the ACT is a taxing test that does not test students sufficiently over the knowledge they have built over their high school career. However, this evaluation of the ACT is inaccurate because it does not correctly assess the true purpose and approach of the ACT test. The ACT was created to assess a student’s “college readiness”. This test is not meant to determine the knowledgeability of a student. It is meant to test their ability to comprehend and solve a problem efficiently. The ACT is a taxing test for students, but it’s still manageable; several students even decide to retake the test multiple …show more content…

Within the allotted time, the ACT only offers a few tests over 4-5 core subjects: English, Mathematics, Science, Reading and occasionally Writing. Amanda Mote claims in her essay that for the ACT to be a satisfactory standardized test, it needs to cover more than just a few subject areas (3). However, it is difficult to create a test that covers more than the basics. It is impossible for the creators of the ACT to administer a fair test to every individual based on their own personal learning experience. Over four years, high school students are exposed to dozens of classes they can choose to take. Most of these cannot be used within the test format to assess problem solving. With classes such as foreign language, speech and health, it would be difficult to avoid asking discipline specific questions. It would also be difficult to compare the test scores of various students for tests that cover different subjects. One student could score very high in Farm Mechanics and another could perform well in Government. However, these scores cannot be compared to each other because they are two different subjects. Each test score would be relative to the individual student; it would not aide high schools or colleges in determining the standings of a

Open Document