A Summary Of Thomas More And Poma De Ayala

1605 Words4 Pages

The final reason that conversion did not mean that they had left their old religion behind is that their pagan religion was polytheistic, worshiped dead bodies of emperors, and cannibalistic offerings. Though priests and other Christians of that time would disagree, Christianity, though monotheistic, is technically the worshipping of the body and spirit of the leader of a large number of people, and eating and drinking of the body of said leader (Eucharist). Therefore, the Indians like the Guaranis mentioned in Montoya’s account may not have converted to a different religion but simply added another god to their collection of gods. This would also account for the switching between religions that many of the “converted” Christians would do (Montoya). The reason this is not a simple cultural difference is …show more content…

Two such intellectual that attempted to this are Thomas More and Guaman Poma de Ayala. More and Ayala were both extremely religious intellectuals that had a career in the field of law and had worked with the church as a page in some aspect or the other (Hare, 9/1/16; Austin 9/13/16). They were also similar in the way that they both wrote books that spoke about an ideal society. In More’s Utopia, he envisioned a land called Utopia where men lived without pursuing wealth, were educated to a certain degree (at least), and worked hard in order to reap the rewards in the afterlife (Hare, 9/1/16). Though More never directly had contact with the Americas, he was writing his book Utopia during a time of great intellectual debate over the Americans as well as their societies, and was familiar with them. Therefore, he was inspired by reading these accounts of the Inkans and other civilization and has certain aspects of those civilizations when imagining and writing his idea of an ideal

Open Document