A Comparison Of Holden And Huckleberry Finn

1522 Words4 Pages

The search for meaning and direction in one’s life is widely accepted as the hallmark of adolescence and a long and grueling trial for all who experience it. In attempting to construct meaningful lives, H.L. Mencken claims that “the average man does not want to be free. He simply wants to be safe.” The definitions of freedom and safety differ from person to person and are mostly derived from their personal experiences. Such experiences vary greatly between individuals, and there are many iconic characters that support this differentiation. American avatars Huckleberry Finn and Holden Caulfield both attempt to construct meaning from their turbulent lives, and both have different desires and methods. In contrast to Mencken’s claim, Huck gives …show more content…

For Holden, safety is everything staying the same and never changing, as he is emotionally stuck in the past and unable to cope with the future. Holden develops a special connection with the Museum of Natural History for this reason, because “you could go there a hundred thousand times, and that Eskimo would still be just finished catching those two fish, the birds would still be on their way south, the deers would still be drinking out of that water hole... “Nobody'd be different. The only thing that would be different would be you” (Salinger 121). Holden likes the museum because everything there never has to worry about death like he does. It never has to end, while the trauma caused by the death of his brother Allie tells Holden that he does. His obsession with escaping death is shown in his interrogation of a taxi driver about what happens to the ducks when the pond freezes over. It is also why he nearly cries while watching Phoebe “going around and around” on the carousel, as no matter how many times she goes around she is still his little sister (Salinger 213). Holden uses his hunting cap as a psychological shield to protect him from death. This is proven by the fact that he only wears the cap when confronted by something that reminds him of Allie or his own mortality. While Holden’s cap can temporarily relieve him of his troubles, it can’t help others. This is why …show more content…

He is desperate to connect with people, but believes that all people are phonies. That is the reason why he watches the football game at Pencey Prep from the top of a nearby hill, and it is the reason why he cannot think of anyone to call in the Penn Station phone booth. The reason he keeps running away is not because he yearns for freedom. Holden himself doesn’t even know why he runs, saying, “I guess I just felt like it” (Salinger 5). The real answer is revealed at the end of the book, when he warns the reader to “[n]ever tell anybody anything. If you do, you start missing everybody” (Salinger 214). Holden has held on to his feelings so long that there is no freedom for him from the troubles that have plagued him. They will trouble him forever and telling people about them only makes him feel the pain more. Opening up to someone would mean losing everything all over again. Holden doesn’t want to free himself from his pain. As long as he is safe from the phonies of the world, he will never have to open up and he can keep to himself; he believes it would be better that

Open Document