Eichengreen and Temin’s Explanation of the Cause of the Great Depression

Eichengreen and Temin’s Explanation of the Cause of the Great Depression

Length: 2383 words (6.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Eight decades has elapsed since the outbreak of the Great Depression, but the continuing mystery of its cause keep provoking academic debates among scholars from various fields. Eichengreen and Temin joint the debates by linking the gold-standard ideology with the cause of the Great Depression. They content that because of this ideology monetary and fiscal authorities implemented deflationary policies when the hindsight shows clearly that expansionary policies were needed. And these contractionary policies consequently pushed the stumbling world economy into the Great Depression. Eichengreen and Temin put heavy weight on analyzing why the prewar gold standard could be a force for international financial stability while interwar gold standard was the force that led the world into economic catastrophe. Their compelling arguments are important contributions to the understanding of the cause. However, by looking into the details of their explanation loopholes can also be found.

My analysis of Eichengreen and Temin’s argument falls into three parts. In the first part, I elaborate their explanation of the cause of the Great Depression and why interwar gold standard failed while its predecessor succeeded. In the second part, I highlight two aspects of the strengths of their explanation. And in the last part, the weaknesses of their studies will be examined

The cause
Eichengreen and Temin attribute the cause of the Great Depression to the mentality amongst central bankers and political leaders that the restoration of pre-WWI gold standard was essential for restoring the healthy international order and economic prosperity. They admit that the initial economic decline may begin from the Wall Street Crash of 1929 in the United Stat...

... middle of paper ...

...redibility of individual national commitments to gold and the disputed issues of German reparations and war debts increased the distrust between countries which made international cooperation unlikely. Without credibility and cooperation the gold standard was not sustainable. Eichengreen and Temin successfully demonstrate that the success of prewar gold standard was because of the international cooperation rather than the existence of a hegemonic stabilizer. And they also employed compelling evidence to show that gold standard could not be a source of stability in the interwar period. However, there are loose ends in their explanation. First, they didn’t explain the different domestic politics of breaking with gold standard. Second, they also overstated the influence of gold-standard mentality and its power to change economic history through a small group of elites.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Basic Cause Of The Great Depression

- Basic Causes of the Great Depression The Great Depression was the longest American slump in the economy to ever occur. The Great Depression lasted for about a decade between 1929 and 1939, the dates of the Stock Market Crash of 1929 and the starting of World War II. A number of factors actually caused the Great Depression. One commonly known factor said to have caused the Great Depression is the Stock Market Crash of 1929, although this is not directly correct. The market crash was only a symptom of, as well as a transition into, the Great Depression....   [tags: Wall Street Crash of 1929, Great Depression]

Powerful Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Cause Of The Great Depression

- The Causes of The Great Depression America has been through a lot of tough spots but we are still a strong nation. We had been through so many events like the Revolutionary War, World War II, the Vietnam War, and the Cold War. But there is this one event that hit our country the most and it’s called “The Great Depression”. There are many things that caused the Great Depression. However, there are three main things that caused the Great Depression, as in. the Stock Market Failure, Bank Failure, and Poverty....   [tags: Wall Street Crash of 1929, Great Depression]

Powerful Essays
896 words (2.6 pages)

The Cause of Depression: Cognitve-Behavior Versus Biological-Behavior Essay

- The cause of depression:Cognitive-behavior versus Biological: Cognitive Depression is an illness that has many causes. Some feel that biology is the leading cause of the onset of depression, but if it was not for the cognition of the brain and learned behaviors depression may not exist at all. Things such as Gender ideals,enviornment and evolutionary predispositions are cogntive-behavioral aspects that lead to depression. Gender Ideals and Depression Every culture has its own gender schemas; these stereotypes can lead to opression and eventually depression of those who do not fit in with these....   [tags: gender ideals, depression, oppression]

Powerful Essays
924 words (2.6 pages)

Exorbitant Privilege, by Barry Eichengreen Essay

- I. Introduction Today, the need to manage the world’s dependency on the dollar is an issue that has been recognized and frequently addressed on academic and political platforms globally.1 Ever since the global crisis of 2008, the worst financial crisis witnessed since the 1930s, there has and continues to be a considerable amount of debate amongst not just leading economists but also leading nations across the world, to look towards finding alternatives to the dollar. In the wake of the recent government shutdown, China too, called for a “de-Americanized” new world order.2 In his essay, titled ‘Reform the international monetary system’, Zhou Xiaochuan, the governor of the People’s Bank of...   [tags: Literary Analysis, China, Money]

Powerful Essays
1342 words (3.8 pages)

Recessions and Depressions Essay

- America has experienced several recessions and depressions in the past. Most recently, the housing crisis sparked a recession which has led to rising unemployment. The largest recession so far has been the Great Depression of the 1930s. A stock market crash in 1929 caused loss of savings which led to unemployment, lower wages, and a distrust of the banking system. The affects of it lasted into the 1940s. Franklin Roosevelt was elected president during this period; legislation he passed tried to alleviate the suffering of the public....   [tags: Economy, The Great Depression]

Powerful Essays
1661 words (4.7 pages)

Depression: The Leading Cause of Suicide Essay

- Depression is a wide spread condition that effects all types of people in Australia; regardless of age, gender or socio economic status (SANE & Gov. Vic 2013). However, studies have shown that the highest rates of incidence in Australia occur in the late teens (Hankin et al.) Whilst depression itself can be debilitating in many ways, the most serious outcome of depression is suicide (Headspace 2013). With Adolescents who battle depression facing the highest risk of suicide in Australia (Spirito 2006), there is an understandable cause for concern....   [tags: mental illness, treatment, australian youths]

Powerful Essays
1535 words (4.4 pages)

The Factors That Cause Depression And Anxiety Essay

- My patient is 14 years old and experiences an unplanned pregnancy. Her mother doesn’t want her to keep the baby because she is afraid it will make her life more difficult. Her boyfriend is supportive, but his family isn’t. My patient wants to raise the baby, and has taken a part time job. The psychosocial impact may cause depression and anxiety because the pregnancy wasn’t planned. This situation may cause family hostilities because she lives with her mother and probably feels guilty for letting her mother down....   [tags: Pregnancy, Family, Teenage pregnancy, Mother]

Powerful Essays
1058 words (3 pages)

Things that Cause Depression Essay

- Depression I chose this topic because I noticed something different about myself and I was always sad, so I wanted to learn about depression. Depression is being sad, blue, unhappy, and miserable or down in the dumps. Depression can be broken into two categories: Major and minor. There are many causes, signs and symptoms, and treatment for depression. There is not an actual cause for depression, but scientists have some assumptions on how depression is caused. Depression can be caused biological, environmental, genetically, and psychologically....   [tags: biological, biological, genetic]

Powerful Essays
1500 words (4.3 pages)

The Great Depression Essay

- Great Depression was one of the most severe economic situation the world had ever seen. It all started during late 1929 and lasted till 1939. Although, the origin of depression was United Sattes but with US Economy being highly correlated with global economy, the ill efffects were seen in the whole world with high unemployment, low production and deflation. Overall it was the most severe depression ever faced by western industrialized world. Stock Market Crashes, Bank Failures and a lot more, left the governments ineffective and this lead the global economy to what we call today- ‘’Great Depression’’.(Rockoff)....   [tags: The Great Depression ]

Free Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Cause of the Great Depression

- The Cause of the Great Depression The economic expansion of the 1920’s, with its increased production of goods and high profits, culminated in immense consumer speculation that collapsed with disastrous results in 1929 causing America’s Great Depression. There were a number or contributing factors to the depression, with the largest and most important one being a general loss of confidence in the American economy. The reason it escalated was a general misunderstanding of recessions by American policymakers of the time....   [tags: essays papers]

Powerful Essays
551 words (1.6 pages)