Essay on The Doctrine Of Supremacy Of The Eu Law

Essay on The Doctrine Of Supremacy Of The Eu Law

Length: 1337 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The doctrine of Supremacy of the EU Law has been adopted from the European Court of Justice, in which the doctrine covers all aspects of law in member states. The supremacy is evidently implied in the Treaty on European Union Article 4(3) and Treaty of the functioning of the European Union Article 18 , which emphasises the prohibitions against discrimination. This is then supported by Article 288 TFEU whereby the regulations are binding upon each member state. Furthermore, Article 344 TFEU ensures resolution between member states. This assignment will discuss to what extent the acceptance of the supremacy of the EU law has been problematic in regards to parliamentary sovereignty.
Parliamentary sovereignty is a vital principle in the U.K constitution, which demonstrates that there are no legal limitations for parliament when creating/ending any legislation. The extent of impact Parliamentary sovereignty has is that nothing can override the legislation of parliament and it is impossible to bind future parliaments. However, these principles put forward by a constitutional law theorist Dicey, arguably do present political limits to parliamentary sovereignty. When the European law was incorporated in the U.K, parliamentary sovereignty was abdicated to the EU which prioritised European law. Thus, parliament had abdicated its power to another body which is referred to as the transfer of powers. To overcome the issue of EU Supremacy and parliamentary sovereignty the European Communities Act 1972 was passed in order to avoid conflicting views.
The European Communities Act provides that s 2(1) has direct effect of EU law provisions which suggests EU law regulations are automatically binding upon parliament without the need of creating new ...

... middle of paper ...

...matters. To summarise, the EU act 2011 does not alter the situation but it does allow the UK citizens to vote on whether there should be any further transfer of powers to the EU. Alongside treaty amendments through a referendum.
In regards to the future of parliamentary sovereignty, the referendum in 2017 may alter the whole situation completely. The outcome of opting out of the EU would result in blocking EU legislation and parliament would achieve greater power. EU supremacy could also decrease significantly within a period of time as the UK supports a “red card” system which allows rights to member states to disregard unwanted directives. If the UK remains in the European Union, EU supremacy will always manage to override parliamentary sovereignty. The solution for this would suggest that the UK should not remain as a member of the EU in order gain full control.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Supremacy Of European Union Law Essay

- The main issue in the question concerns the supremacy of European Union Law (EU) and the constitutional difficulties of parliamentary sovereignty. The basic meaning of supremacy provides that in cases where EU law is relevant to a case before national courts, EU law is 'supreme ' over national law. Wherever there is a conflict between national law of a member state and EU law itself, it is EU law that prevails. The Court of Justice has developed reasons and logic for supremacy of EU law and this was affirmed in the case of Van Gend en Loos1 ....   [tags: European Union, Treaty of Lisbon]

Strong Essays
718 words (2.1 pages)

The Doctrine Of Parliamentary Supremacy Essay

- SUMMATIVE COURSEWORK - TERM I TOPIC QUESTION: It used to be thought that the doctrine of parliamentary supremacy means that Parliament cannot bind its successor. Is this still an accurate description of the position of Parliament under the UK Constitution. 'The real point is whether a government can, in law, make it difficult for a future Parliament to amend or repeal the legislation it has passed; in [the Committee 's] view it cannot. Our conclusion therefore is straightforward—that an Act of Parliament applies until it is repealed....   [tags: European Union, United Kingdom, Legislature]

Strong Essays
982 words (2.8 pages)

Law And The European Union Law Essay

- Societies need the help of rules to keep order and respect among its population. With the passing of years, the law, which was and is an indispensable tool to regulate peaceful coexistence within any country, has been changing for the purpose of adapting to the evolution of moral rules in the society. This fact enables all citizens of the same country to feel protected by same rules, most commonly known as laws. That is the reason why all people should be aware and understand how our society is regulated and what the rights and duties of ordinary citizens are....   [tags: Law, Common law, Court, High Court of Justice]

Strong Essays
1019 words (2.9 pages)

The Power of the Doctrine of Brititsh Parliament Sovereignty Essay

- The doctrine of parliament sovereignty has been identified as the core principle of the British’s uncodified constitution. This doctrine is mainly regarding the relationship of the Parliament and the courts. This doctrine states that Parliament has unlimited legal power to enact any law and that it cannot be overridden by any other body. The European Union, which was known originally as European Coal and Steel Community, was created during the times of the Second World War. In 1972 the European Communities Act, which incorporates Community law into the UK’s legal system, was enacted, bringing Britain into the European Union (EU)....   [tags: rights, legislation, courts]

Strong Essays
924 words (2.6 pages)

The Doctrine Of Parliamentary Sovereignty Essay

- The doctrine of Parliamentary sovereignty is one of the founding principles of the British legal system. A. V. Dicey states “Parliamentary sovereignty means … that Parliament … has the right to make or unmake any law of England as having a right to override or set aside the legislation of Parliament.” This means that Parliament’s power is unlimited, its validity cannot be questioned, and no one Parliament can bind its successor. It was stated in Madzimbamuto v Lardner-Burke [1969] by LJ Reid that there are no constitutional or legal mechanisms to prevent Parliament from acting morally or politically “highly improper .” In the case Costa v ENEL , the supremacy of EU law was established, and...   [tags: Human rights, Law, Common law, Council of Europe]

Strong Essays
1601 words (4.6 pages)

Seeking a Just Judiciary Essay

- In recent years, many people in the United States have acquired an oddly tilted concept of how the judicial branch of government should function. Modern consensus postulates that the Supreme Court is the final arbiter of the Constitution, and that its judgments cannot be challenged or changed except through its own decision (Vieira). Curiously, however, this idea of giving the power of final constitutional interpretation to the judiciary—known in law as “judicial supremacy”—finds no basis in the text of the Constitution itself or in historical opinion....   [tags: judicial supremacy]

Strong Essays
826 words (2.4 pages)

Rule Of Law Essay

- The rule of law does not have a precise definition. Often, the term operates as a catch-all for other conceptions of which the relevance to philosophical and political theory is hard to define. Yet at the same time, it is difficult to find out what the cash value of the concept is in helping to understand how best to fashion human relationships. It has been viewed in very diverse ways. One central clue to the meaning of the ‘rule of law’ is that it requires that there be some sort of rules. The rule of law in its most basic form is the principle that no individual is above the law and everyone must answer to it....   [tags: Law, Political philosophy, Constitution]

Strong Essays
975 words (2.8 pages)

Judges Must Make Law Essay

- INTRODUCTION: Parliament, the supreme law-making body, has an unrestricted legislative power, and the laws it passes cannot be set aside by the courts. The role of judges, in relation to laws enacted by Parliament, is to interpret and apply them, rather than to pass judgment on whether they are good or bad laws. However, evidence has shown that they have a tendency to deviate from their ‘real roles’ and instead formulate laws on their own terms. Thus the real role of a judge in any legal system continues to be a phenomenon questioned by many....   [tags: Judges Make Law]

Strong Essays
2340 words (6.7 pages)

Rule Of Law Essay

- Introduction Firstly in this report, I will be giving the different definitions of rule of law by different philosophers; secondly, I will be applying the rule of law to the English Legal system and thirdly I will be explaining separation of powers with a focus on the impartial judiciary. Finally, I will be using cases to support every detailed point given. Overview of the rule of law The rule of law has two common basic concepts which are that everyone is both equal and subjective to the law. The Oxford Dictionary of Law defines the rule of law as the supremacy of law....   [tags: Law, Human rights, Political philosophy]

Strong Essays
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Parliamentary Spvereighty Constitution in United Kingdom Essay

- Parliamentary Sovereignty is one of the most significant factors of the Constitution of the United Kingdom, and makes the Parliament the most powerful legal force, who dominates themselves. It involves the legal relationship between the courts and the Parliament, and has remained a traditional value for many centuries, and its doctrine is what makes their system different from other widely held states. However, although the parliament has its strength, it also has some lack of power to control and amend those Acts of the European Union, who tend to override them; such as the European Communities Act 1972, and the Human Rights Act 1998....   [tags: courts, parliament, doctrine, power, system]

Strong Essays
889 words (2.5 pages)