Direct Instruction And Discovery Learning Essay

Direct Instruction And Discovery Learning Essay

Length: 1306 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Direct instruction and discovery learning are two very different styles and their effectiveness has been argued extensively. This paper focuses mainly on elementary school students of science and math and the efficacy of each teaching method in those subjects. The paper investigates the effect each has on recall and retention paying attention to the cognitive load imposed upon the learner by each method when applying the concepts in later lessons (Kalyuga, 2011). The rote memorization of math facts like addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division shows an edge in effectiveness and efficiency for our youngest learners over discovery learning which seeks to allow students to create their own knowledge. The author looks at testing data and meta-analyses of large collections of studies on the subject of direct instruction as well as studies showing advantages to discovery learning. While there are benefits of using each method, the author finds that the most beneficial method of teaching our youngest learners would include elements of both methods with strong emphasis on direct instruction to ease cognitive load in young students while still creating the depth of knowledge aimed for with discovery learning (Fast & Hankes, 2010). These findings imply that the United States school system should shift to a curriculum with a mix of teaching methods heavy in direct instruction to provide its students with the best preparation for the courses in higher grades (Marzano, 2011).
Direct Instruction versus Discovery Learning in Elementary School Mathematics
The debate has been fierce over the best way to teach our nation’s youth. The topic is of extreme importance in a time when it seems there is school reform every few years. Cla...

... middle of paper ...

...e the problem presented. There may be more than one correct answer.
The teacher takes the role of a “guide on the side”, no explicit answers are given. In pure discovery learning, no input at all is given after the problem is presented. Students construct the solutions to the problems presented and discover the targeted concepts for themselves. This is thought to develop a much deeper understanding of the concepts taught this way.
Child development pioneer, Jean Piaget believes not only that people learn better if they discover knowledge for themselves, but that if a child is taught something directly that could have been learned on his or her own through discovery, he or she has lost the chance to completely understand it (Klahr & Nigam, 2004). It is argued that it is more important and more valuable to teach a student how to think rather than what to think.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Direct or Inquiry Instruction? Finding the Balance to Maximize Motivation and Learning

- The question of how students learn best has fueled a controversial debate within the field of educational psychology and instructional design. There is limited consensus as to which type of instructional technique best supports conceptual learning. Instructional techniques cover a wide spectrum of guidance that ranges from direct instruction, which often encompasses the use of lectures and worked examples, to pure discovery learning which includes little to no teacher guidance at its most extreme interpretation....   [tags: Education, teaching, teachers]

Better Essays
2414 words (6.9 pages)

The Inquiry Approach to Learning Essay

- Inquiry is an interactive way of learning. Students are actively engaged in their studies. Inquiry involves student-centered activities focusing on questioning, exploring, and posing explanations. The goal of inquiry is to introduce a new way of learning where students can learn about the world around them through active engagement in real-life examples. Inquiry based learning can be incorporated into all academic subjects throughout the curriculum. Science could possibly be the most effective subject to incorporate inquiry....   [tags: Education, teaching, learning styles]

Better Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)

How to Instill a Lifetime of Love for Learning in My Students Essay

- Through the classes I have taken at Bowie State University and my experiences in the classroom, I have developed a personal teaching philosophy that will be implemented into my future classrooms. I am continually being prepared for an inclusive classroom, and plan on consistently considering students’ individual needs in my instruction. It is my belief that each child is a unique individual, in need of a secure, caring and stimulating atmosphere in which to grow and mature emotionally, intellectually, physically, and socially....   [tags: individual, self-discovery, opportunity]

Better Essays
572 words (1.6 pages)

Instruction And Research Through Mediation Essay

- Instruction and research through mediation, which is my application in practice, utilizes every trick in the bag, much like an educator. The work of the educational psychologist is essentially that of a scientific investigator; in a word it is research. Day-to-day work, even individual cases, can be a form of research practice (Parker, 2013, p. 85). I am certain that it is beyond me to go as far as Cyril Burt, who lived for a time in one of Liverpool’s poorest districts, attempting to gain first-hand knowledge of families’ experiences....   [tags: Educational psychology, Education, Psychology]

Better Essays
1353 words (3.9 pages)

Teaching Mathematics through Guided Discovery Essays

- Teaching Mathematics through Guided Discovery As with every academic subject, there are a variety of strategies for teaching mathematics to school-aged students. Some strategies seem to be better than others, especially when tackling certain topics. There is the direct instruction approach where students are given the exact tools and formulas they need to solve a problem, sometimes without a clear explanation as to why. The student is told to do certain steps in a certain order and in turn expects to do them as such at all times....   [tags: Teachers School Education Essays]

Better Essays
1245 words (3.6 pages)

Uses Of Direct Instruction Strategy Essay

- Knowledge is very important to young children, especially in the aspect of how that knowledge is delivered. I believe it is crucial for children to discover knowledge, so they can retain it for later practices. Direct instruction is a strategy in which the teacher lectures and students acquire the knowledge by listening. Though many teachers today use the direct instruction strategy, it is important that we diversify the way instruction is given. One way teachers can achieve this goal is by using the indirect instruction strategy....   [tags: Teacher, Education, Learning, Pedagogy]

Better Essays
876 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Video On Direct Instruction For Students

- In this video on Direct Instruction, the teacher calls out a number and the students respond with the word answer that is associated with the number. The students do not answer however until the teacher give a signal like tapping on her pad, desk or board. The teachers also do an individual checkout where a student might read a particular passage while the teacher follows along and times it. The teacher then praises the student on their progress. This is considered a good program because children are not competing against others and they are more aware of what they are doing....   [tags: Education, Teacher, Learning, School]

Better Essays
1479 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on A Perfect World Discovery Based Instruction Learning

- Introduction In a perfect world discovery-based instruction learning would work for everyone. It would provide learners needs when they need it, and alter learning patterns to better understand content that would ultimately enhance their learning. However, what negates this idea; all learners have different learning styles. Therefore, taking the position of explicit instructional learning would be more beneficial for learners to explore with guided instruction. Nevertheless, this stance will be based on supporting measurable evidence that will help others understand why this guided practice is used....   [tags: Learning styles, Learning, Education]

Better Essays
1254 words (3.6 pages)

Teaching Strategies For Direct Instruction Essay

- Teaching Strategies for Direct Instruction When planning a lesson a teacher must choose the appropriate instructional strategy to reach the specific learning outcomes. The Direct Instruction model is appropriate for two types of learning outcomes. Type 1, facts, rules, and action sequences, represents the lower levels of learning of Bloom’s Taxonomy. Type 1 includes knowledge, comprehension, and application. Type 2, concept, patterns, and relationships, represents the higher levels of learning of Bloom’s Taxonomy....   [tags: Learning, Teacher, Education, Question]

Better Essays
1018 words (2.9 pages)

The Direct Instruction Approach Essay

- ... Throughout the weekly modules CSU Global often uses YouTube videos for students to watch and learn. This is effective with online learning because some approaches are not possible. For example, experimental approach may be more difficult or impossible. It would be almost impossible to role play online and have it be an effective learning technique. Through online learning students discern what the goals are and then they are assigned coursework that needs to be completed; this is part of the direct instruction approach (Education Purduecal, n.d.)....   [tags: teacher, talk, appropriate, learning]

Better Essays
693 words (2 pages)