Deterrence, Rational and Restorative Justice Theories Essay

Deterrence, Rational and Restorative Justice Theories Essay

Length: 1896 words (5.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

This paper will illustrate three theories; deterrence theory, rational choice theory, and restorative justice theory. It will outline in detail the policies, and the connections between theory, research, and policy.
Deterrence theory can be outlined as “principles of certainty, severity, and celerity of punishment, proportionality, specific and general deterrence” (Burke, 2009). In order for the punishment to be effective it has to be certain, swift, severe. Certainty is more important than the severity in deterring crime. Deterrence theory confirms that if the punishment contains these three elements people will rationally calculate that there is more to be lost than there is to be gained from crime (Gordon, 2010). Deterrence functions in two ways. General deterrence is the punishment of the offender to be set as an example for others in the society and specific deterrence focuses on repeat offenders to refraining them from the act (Burke, 2009). The purpose of general deterrence is to abstain others considering committing the crime. It was argued that when the certainty, severity, and celerity of criminal sanctions are high in a population, criminal behaviour will be low. Studies suggest that capital punishment has been ineffective, other studies show that more homicides occurred when the death penalty was publicized (Pacotti, 2005). Then a comparative research shows that 5 countries with the highest homicide rate do impose the death penalty average 41.6% murders for every 100, 000 people, whereas the five countries that don’t impose death penalty is 21.6% for every 100, 000 (Gordon, 2010). Deterrence also has little affect on domestic cases, drunk driving, and shoplifting. Deterrence is well said in a theory but in reality ...

... middle of paper ...

...ender in certain circumstances of a situation. Restorative justice has been used widely, and has some success rate, for those to be held accountable without being sanctioned; by repairing the harm or paying restitution will restore harmony within the victim and community to some extent. The program is inconsistent that it will repair harm done to the victim, but many victims are being left emotionally, psychological, and physical strained which will lead to another conflict during victim-offender mediation.
Overall, it concludes the idea that some programs can effective and has ties to its theory; others can ineffective in deterring, repairing, and restoring crime, as well as low success rate. Furthermore, offenders in many cases don’t think rationally before committing the act and crime can’t be deterred it doesn’t matter if the punishment is harsh or lenient.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Deterrence Theorists and Capital Punishment Essay

- Deterrence theorists view murder as rational behavior, and assume that in calculating the gains and losses from killing, potential offenders are aware of the death penalty and regard it as a more severe sanction than imprisonment. Because the threat of one's own death presumably outweighs the rewards gained from killing another, murder is not an option for most people and always discouraged. In addition, some noted proponents assert that capital punishment provides an important educative function in society by validating the sanctity of human life (Berns, 1979; van den Haag, 1975; van den Haag & Conrad, 1983)....   [tags: Death, Murder, Justice]

Strong Essays
909 words (2.6 pages)

The Correctional Theory Of My Choice Is Deterrence Essay

- The correctional theory of my choice is deterrence. The reason I believe this theory to be the most accurate is because it works on the justice aspect of the crime, but also plans on deterring crime. Out of all the theories I have learned about in class, deterrence is one of the only ones that pays attention two both of these perspectives. There is two different forms of deterrence. The first one is called general deterrence which has the goal of scaring society into not committing crime. This is the part of the theory that helps deter crime....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Criminal law, Sentence]

Strong Essays
1846 words (5.3 pages)

The Theories Of Criminal Justice Essay

- For this paper I will critique several theories of criminal justice. This will include a brief overview of each theory by also including its strengths and weaknesses in order to show why each theory is necessary to explain crime. I will then share my thoughts on which theory I believe to be the strongest of the group. In criminal Justice, there are dozens of theories that have been created to explain why certain crimes occur. As a criminal justice major, we can begin to look at criminology from the early perspective known as the classical theory....   [tags: Criminology, Crime, Juvenile delinquency]

Strong Essays
1457 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on How Hotspot Policing And Other Forms Of Deterrence Can Have On Crime

- Introduction The intent of this paper is to inform readers of the positive impact hotspot policing and other forms of deterrence can have on crime. The paper will discuss prior research into hotspot policing and broken windows theories, tactics, and policies, and will conclude with a research consensus and advice for policy makers. The potential of deterrence policing, particularly hot spot policing should be on the radar of all those who influence the development and sustainment of public safety and criminal justice policy....   [tags: Crime, Police, Criminology, Criminal justice]

Strong Essays
1186 words (3.4 pages)

The Aspects of Criminal Justice Essay

- The Aspects of Criminal Justice There are many different aspects of criminal justice policy. One in particular is the different theories of crime and how they affect the criminal justice system. The Classical School of criminology is a theory about evolving from a capital punishment type of view to more humane ways of punishing people. Positivist criminology is maintaining the control of human behavior and criminal behavior. They did this through three different categories of Biological studies, which are five methodologies of crime that were mainly focused on biological theories, Psychological theories, which contains four separate theories, and the Sociological theories, which also inclu...   [tags: Crime Justice Criminals Essays]

Free Essays
1525 words (4.4 pages)

Criminal Justice System: Classical School Theory Essay

- In this paper I will discuss a major theory that has helped shape our criminal justice system today and how it came about. There are multiple major theories that made the criminal justice system what it is today, but I will only be discussing one theory and the theory that I will be covering in this paper is the classical school theory. I chose this theory because I believe that people have a choice to decide what they do. That also plays a part in the criminal activities that they participate in as well....   [tags: social contract, penalties, free will]

Strong Essays
1496 words (4.3 pages)

The Deterrence Effect and Criminal Justice Essay

- Over the years a theory known as the deterrence effect has been proposed to the world of capital punishment. People believe that if you do something wrong, in this case, kill someone, then you will be put to death therefore preventing you from committing that wrong act again. This theory also states that by viewing or hearing about your punishment then others around you will not follow in your footsteps which will decrease the number of criminal acts committed. Econometric studies have started a panel data in order to view the validity of this theory....   [tags: Deterrence, Criminal Justice, ]

Strong Essays
662 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Rational Choice and Deterrence Theories

- All beings with a sense of understanding learn how to make choices, even in its smallest measurement, they also learn of consequences to those choices. Children, for example, have been told countless times to stop a certain behavior because they may hurt themselves. Some children heed their parent’s warming’s while others continue down a path that usually ends with a painful lesson but the originating act is usually not repeated. Why can this not be the same for adults. Generally it is understood that a person will make a choice or take an action based on the possible outcomes or consequences....   [tags: punishment, crime, police]

Strong Essays
833 words (2.4 pages)

Deterrence And Rational Choice Theories Essay

- Akers, Ronald L. "Deterrence and Rational Choice Theories." Criminology Theories Introduction and Evaluation. 2nd ed. New York: Roxbury, 1999. Print. Akers tells of how punishment and the deterrent of crime are related. He states that all individuals have the free will to choose whether or not they are going to commit a crime, some of the things keeping them from committing those crimes are the legal penalties and the likelihood of one being caught. He continues to explain how some punishments for crimes are too severe and are simply unjust, they do nothing to deter crime, as well as punishments that are not severe enough....   [tags: Capital punishment, Prison, Penology, Crime]

Strong Essays
1503 words (4.3 pages)

Theories of Crime and Criminal Activity Essay

- Theories of Crime and Criminal Activity Every theory of crime has at least 2-3 meta-theoretical levels above it. The fundamental issues are usually addressed at the approach level, and are often called the assumptions, or starting points, of a theory, although the term "assumptions" more strictly refers to the background or domain boundaries one can draw generalizations about. Above the approach level is the Perspective level, the largest unit of agreement within a scientific community, and in fact, the names for the scientific disciplines....   [tags: Crime Psychology ]

Strong Essays
1492 words (4.3 pages)