The Debate Of Nature Versus Nurture Essay

The Debate Of Nature Versus Nurture Essay

Length: 1403 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The debate of nature versus nurture has been argued for a long period time. The concept of tabula rasa was popularized by John Locke; it stated that babies are born into this world without innate knowledge. Knowledge and personality are developed through experiences and environment, emphasising the nurture in the nature-nurture split. At first blush, Frankenstein avidly supports the theory but in some other parts it does not.
The novel’s support of tabula rasa is easiest to see through the creature’s emotional development. The creature himself is of the opinion that he became who he is through his relations with his surroundings. His development also has many parallels to a child’s; after being created, he “could distinguish nothing; but, feeling pain invade me on all sides…’’ (Shelley 68). This stimuli overload is similar to what a newborn experiences, when it can’t see or hear as precisely as an adult can. It takes time for the brain to develop and for neurons to develop connections that allow for proper sensation and perception. Also akin to a child, the creature didn’t know how to speak immediately; the only things that he could utter were “uncouth and inarticulate sounds” (69). A big step in the emotional development of the creature is seeing the cottagers; these are the first humans that he develops a bond with, even though it is one-sided. Before, humans are something to be feared, with the creature being “still more [miserable] from the barbarity of man” (Shelley 71). Even, at first sight, the cottagers evoke a very positive response from him; he states that “the silver hair and benevolent countenance, won my reverence; while the gentle manners of the girl enticed my love” (Shelley 72). Though the creature doesn’t yet sho...

... middle of paper ...

... skill to taunt Frankenstein into chasing him, writing “My reign is not yet over…” (142). All things to be taken for granted from a genius mastermind, but made impressive by not only the creature’s origins but also the quality of his early developmental period. Though his emotional state is something that is very obviously affected by the events surrounding him, his level of intelligence is a triumph in spite of it.
Despite modern research revising its extremism, tabula rasa remains both an important historical concept and certainly at least a partial truth; a child’s self-esteem, emotional health, and intelligence can be all affected positively and negatively by the surroundings it grows up in. Frankenstein shows full support of the idea when it comes to one’s emotional development, but perhaps less so when it comes to the level of intelligence that one possesses.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Debate Over Nature Versus Nurture Essay

- ... Anais and Sam were separated at birth and shared a lot of similarities, but like I said it 's very rare for that to happen.The fact is that my personality has changed a little while I have gotten older, but that is because of my surroundings and environment. It can 't be argued that some mental disorders are linked to DNA, but good parenting can help kids overcome them. Studies show that ADHD is something that you are born with but, you can take medicine for that. Plus Schizophrenia is also something that is passed down by genetics, but you can get rid of it....   [tags: Nature versus nurture, The Nurture Assumption]

Strong Essays
716 words (2 pages)

The Debate Between Nature Versus Nurture Essay

- ... However, while it can certainly be agreed that there is an instinct reaction for self-defense and self preservation, it would only make sense to use this to explain one on one violence. There is no instinctive programing to tell us to stand up for our values and the pursuit of justice, as our concepts of values, justice, and what is “worth fighting for” are not innate, but learned through socialization. Margaret Mead’s 1940 study, Warfare Is Only an Invention – Not a Biological Necessity that follow the example of the Eskimo people, who have knowledge of and outbreaks of personal violence among themselves, have never known war....   [tags: Violence, Aggression, War, Ethology]

Strong Essays
999 words (2.9 pages)

The Nature Versus Nurture Debate, Sociocultural And Biological Factors Essay

- The Nature Versus Nurture Debate, Sociocultural and Biological factors Contributing to Youth Criminal Behaviour Youth criminal behaviour is a complex and multifaceted issue that’s becoming an increasing problem. Richards (2011) has conducted various research on Australian adolescents and found that 21 percent of all offenders processed by Victoria Police were juveniles and that crimes peaked at ages 16-20 for violent and non-violent crimes, thus making it a concerning issue. A topic that therefore continues to spark debates in various scientific fields is genetics and environmental social factors that influence youth’s criminal behaviour....   [tags: Nature versus nurture, Genetics, Aggression, Crime]

Strong Essays
1364 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about The Nature Versus Nurture Debate

- People can get their blue, hazel, or brown eyes from one of their parents, and their freckles from the other. But where does their talent for singing, or knack for craftsmanship come from. In other words, what makes individuals who they are. Is it predetermined in their genes or was it taught to them by family or friends. My General Psychology instructor recently explained this contest of nature and nurture as won by neither side. “The nature versus nurture debate is one of the oldest issues in psychology....   [tags: learning, environment, biology]

Strong Essays
740 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The Nature Versus Nurture Debate

- The nature versus nurture debate is one that has continued for years arguing over whether children are effected more by their innate personality or their personal experiences. Ivan and Charles are examples that both are factors in a person’s disposition. In what ways were Ivan IV and Charles VI’s upbringing similar and did this have a comparable effect on their leadership and later mental diagnosis. Ivan IV and Charles VI had a similar upbringing in relation to their lineage and throne inheritance which led to their analogous leadership styles and mental illnesses....   [tags: Mental disorder, Psychiatry, Mental health]

Strong Essays
1390 words (4 pages)

Nature versus Nurture Debate Essay

- ... Altruism is also present in human infants. These infants have not been taught any social guidelines. They selflessly help other humans anyway, like with assisting in tasks like opening doors. This proves the experience theory wrong, since the infants have no experience of learning how to be selfless. Finally, scientists working in twin studies also found with their results that altruism is not learned, but genetic. Identical twins share 100% of genes, while fraternal twins share 50% of genes....   [tags: genetics versus environment]

Strong Essays
775 words (2.2 pages)

The Formula for Fruition: The Age Old Debate of Nature Versus Nurture by Kendra Cherry

- The Formula for Fruition: Nature vs. Nurture The Story of My Search Have you ever wondered what makes a person successful. Why is it that people who grow up in the same environment grow up to have such different qualities of life. As a child of two parents who would be considered “successful” by society, I’ve always wondered how differently I would perform in life had I been the child of different people or raised in a different environment. I’d heard plenty of stories about people coming from bad childhoods or being raised by unsupportive parents and still succeeding, but my question was, how common is this....   [tags: natural passion, gpa, manual]

Strong Essays
1497 words (4.3 pages)

Nature versus Nurture Debate in Violence, Environment and Other Aspects Essay

- Scientists and biologist have argued the Nature versus Nurture debate for decades. This debate is about the degree to which our environment and heredity, affects our behavior and developmental stages. According to this debate, nature can be described as, the behavior of a person is occurring because of their genetic makeup. Since the behavior of a person is due to their genetic makeup, then, it (nature) should also influence a person’s growth and development for the duration of their life. However, the nurture side of the debate says, the cause for an individual’s behavior is because of environmental factors....   [tags: Intelligence, Economics, Sports]

Strong Essays
640 words (1.8 pages)

Essay on The Debate Between Nature And Nurture

- The debate between nature and nurture seems like an ongoing process. The term nature in this case refers to the biological and family factors whereas nurture refers to the social and environmental factors. I think that our personality and development are influenced by both sides. It is almost impossible to differentiate between these two influences, there isn’t really a good way of telling how much we are influence genetically and how much we are influence environmentally. Certain physical characteristics, such as eye color, hair type, and diseases are biologically determined by genetic inheritance....   [tags: Psychology, Nature versus nurture, Biology]

Strong Essays
776 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Nature Vs. Nurture Debate

- Nature vs nurture debate is one of the oldest arguments in the history of psychology. It is the scientific cultural, and philosophical debate about whether human culture, behavior, and personality are caused primarily by nature or nurture. Nature and nurture are both equally important. They are the two are major influences that affect the person you grow to be and will determine what your children will be tomorrow. Nature refers to heredity, which are traits and features that are inherited from your parents and ancestors....   [tags: Nature versus nurture, Human nature]

Strong Essays
1522 words (4.3 pages)