Essay on Curriculum Comparisons

Essay on Curriculum Comparisons

Length: 1293 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Curriculum Comparisons
One of the foremost developers of modern curriculum was Ralph W. Tyler. Tyler had a passion to teach, and to do it well. In his early years in education, both as a student and as an educator, Tyler witnessed many deficiencies in the American Education system. This paper will discuss Tyler's understanding of the nature and structure of knowledge and the needs of the learner. It will also compare two approaches to curriculum development, product and process models. It will discuss their impact on curriculum development in relation to Tyler's interlocking system.
Nature and structure of knowledge and needs of the learner
Tyler's extensive travels and educational experiences, helped to influence his writings on the nature and structure of knowledge. For example, during his doctorate work at the University of Chicago, Tyler assumed the same position as his mentor Dr. Judd, that "students can learn how to generalize while acquiring facts" (Kral, 2008). Kral, in his article, goes on to point out that Tyler's research also brought him in contact with some of the newest and radical theories in education to date. From the works of Dewey, Counts, and others, Tyler too, believed that children learned best by doing (2008). Active learning, previously, had never been heard off, nor utilized in the scholastic arena. Tyler was quickly becoming an advocate of change in the area of teaching and education.
One such area was testing (Kral, 2008). Tyler believed that testing, at the present, only served to evaluate what pupils had memorized. Actual learning in the majority of American schools was failing to occur. Tyler felt that testing should be utilized to determine if understanding was taking place ...

... middle of paper ...

...lum Development, Advisory Role. Retrieved January 28, 2012, from
Kral, E. (2008). Ralph Winfred Tyler: Curriculum, instruction, and evaluation reformer ranked among world's fifty modern thinkers on education. Retrieved January 28, 2012, from
Mednick, F. (2006, March 13). Cirriculum Theories. Retrieved January 27, 2012, from
Sheehan, J. (1986, January 17). Curriculum models: product versus process. Retrieved January 27, 2012, from Journal od Advance Nursing: product_versus_process.pdf
Smith, M. (1996, 2000). curriculum theory and practice. Retrieved January 27, 2012, from

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Traditional Curriculum And Cultural Literacy

- Curriculum Traditions The American society have had several experimentation on the different kind of education systems and each one has had positive and negative sides. The decision to relook at the education system in place comes from observers who believe that there an identity that speaks of the past and the lesson along the way. This means that the stakeholders in the education system need a fact-finding and evaluation of the values in the current system before recommending a switch to previous system....   [tags: Education, Learning, Curriculum, Teacher]

Better Essays
838 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about Curriculum Analysis : Sensorial Education

- Introduction to Sensorial Education Sensorial Education involves refining the senses of the child to better observe the environment. The main purpose of Sensorial work is for the child to acquire clear, conscious information and be able to then make classifications in his environment. Children have many sensory experiences in their daily lives and learn just by interacting with their world; for example: they learn colors, the relative size of objects, the geometric shapes. My daughter who is 2 years old can recite the rainbow poem and can sometimes identify the color ‘red’....   [tags: Maria Montessori, Sensitive periods]

Better Essays
2215 words (6.3 pages)

Mathematics Curriculum Research for K-6 Students Essay

- Mathematics Curriculum Research for K-6 Students An effective curriculum uses essential mathematical ideas in a way that students can understand how new concepts build on existing knowledge of concepts to learn to solve problems. Students must be taught a variety of concepts that are important to success in future grades without wasting their time. Curriculum issues discussed in this paper are (a) influence on mathematics content in the past 25 years, (b) development of mathematics curriculum, (c) mathematics that should be taught, and (d) problems with U.S....   [tags: Math Education, math]

Better Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

The Grade Language Arts At Buffett Is A Pilot School For Trying New Books For Curriculum

- Eighth grade Language Arts at Buffett is a pilot school for trying new books for curriculum. Currently, there are three different English Language Arts classes trying out three different works or books. In Mrs. Willmott’s ELA classes that I co-teach in, we are using the book Collections, by Houghton, Mifflin, and Harcourt. Our classes were assigned the Culture and Belonging chapters of the collection. The collection is based off of common core standards, which is surprising since Nebraska is not a common core state....   [tags: Writing, Editing, Writing process, Pilcrow]

Better Essays
713 words (2 pages)

Teaching Students Social Values And Good Morals Essay

- An Introduction of the Topic Character education involves teaching students social values and good morals as part of the curriculum and is embedded within the delivery of instruction and performance tasks. Out of all the topics that we have discussed throughout this course, character education appears to me to be a critical aspect of teaching. To be able to help guide students along in the process of making choices such as taking turns, showing tolerance for different ideas, and being gracious, are behaviors not only good for the individual but for society....   [tags: Education, Teacher, School, Curriculum]

Better Essays
1485 words (4.2 pages)

High Schools Should Change Current Curriculum to Better Prepare Students for College

- Imagine walking down the hall of a crowded high school. Most of the students there do not envision how well school prepares them for college. Teenagers have few cares in the world. A vast majority takes the bare minimum amount of courses needed to fulfill school requirements. These graduation prerequisites usually do not come close to adequate, and rarely exceed sufficiency. Should high schools change current curriculum to better prepare students for college. The answer is simply, "yes." Consideration of why and how holds the key to solving America's problem....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
940 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Study Curriculum Theory And The Diversity

- Purpose – Clean up this area. Anything that repeats pull to the conclusion. Do to the increasing need to identify the reason for the variance in students’ academic performance (Ellis, 2004); the need to hold educational practitioners accountable leads educational practitioners primarily concern with actions and results, (Johnson,1967). As such, Johnson argues that “educational researchers have traditionally been more concerned with improving education rather than understanding it,” (p. 127). For this reason, the purpose of this literature review is to study curriculum theory and the diversity in curricula (i.e....   [tags: Education, Curriculum, High school, College]

Better Essays
1137 words (3.2 pages)

Curriculum Is The Curriculum As Experience Essay

- Understanding curriculum experiences The curriculum as experience What is curriculum. The term curriculum if often misunderstood for “the curriculum”. A formal document stipulating what learning outcomes students ought to achieve. In hindsight, the term curriculum is considerably broad and complex. Blaise and Nuttall (2011) highlight five key concepts in relation to curriculum theory and practise. Firstly, the intended curriculum, what teachers want students to experience (Blaise and Nuttall, 2011, P....   [tags: Education, Teacher, School, Curriculum]

Better Essays
1910 words (5.5 pages)

Curriculum Leadership Essay

- To define curriculum leadership, one should first have a working definition of curriculum. According to Marsh and Willis (2007), curriculum is usually regarded to mean a program of instruction at a school including both the planned and unplanned events in the classroom (pp.16, 375). Curriculum has three basic focal points: the nature of the individual, the nature society, and the nature of a subject (P. Brown, CIED 5053 lecture notes, August 28, 2006). Looking at these definitions, one could come up with several different meanings for curriculum leadership....   [tags: Curriculum ]

Better Essays
1993 words (5.7 pages)

Essay Comparisons

- Comparisons Gerard David and Mary Cassatt both are remarkable artists who has influenced artists today. Gerard David was born in 1455 in the Netherlands (Oudewater). Mary Cassatt was born in 1861 in Pennsylvania. Even though they were born at different times, their paintings show the relationship between mother and child. David painted Virgin and Child With Four Angels in 1510. The type of canvas used was wood with oil paint. The wood has a rectangular shape. The Virgin and Child characters that were reproduced from a painting by Jan van Eyck, who influenced David when he settled in Bruges in 1484....   [tags: essays papers]

Free Essays
742 words (2.1 pages)