Cultural Materialism

Cultural Materialism

Length: 1063 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The notion that environment can and does determine the way in which people navigate through the ecosystem in which they pursuing optimization of survival by adapting to the specifics of the environment in which they live is the principle thought of cultural materialism. Leading anthropologist Marvin Harris believing that theses actions are then turned into cultural thought, the thought is then solidified by attaching a religious ideology. Culture is the way in which humans adapt to an environment. Harris (1966) argues that cultural acts such as the “prohibition of killing cattle should be understood in relation to the role that cattle play in the production of food crops, fuel and fertilizer” (Mcgee, 2003;285). The large brained individual has the ability to formulate complex thought that has proven to be the ultimate environmentally adapted defense mechanism, culture. Such cultural adaptations give great purpose to ways of living, for example, the Turkana of Kenya and the pastoral relationship with cattle. Because milk is their primary source of nutrition, Turkana rarely slaughter cattle, they also apply rules to when and who can consume a cow.
Marvin Harris explains the Hindu ideology as a form of cultural materialism. Due to the multifaceted purposes the Indian sacred cattle are forbidden from slaughter. The purpose of cattle in Hindu India according to Harris is outside of the realm of the Hindu ideology. Purposes include dung as fuel and manure, milk, traction, beef and hide. The secondary benefits are therefore similar to that of pastoral Turkana and their animal culture and treatment. Harris’ point would be that secondary products create a dependence of cyclical relationship in which religion acts as the glue that bins the law to the people and the product. Cultural materialism therefore indicates that there is a utilization of the benefits of the ecosystem in order to sustain life by cultural group that inhabits that ecosystem. An example would be the notion of “unclean” in Judaic and Muslim pig taboos.
Judaic and Muslim pig consumption law stems from the ecological cost analysis. The once presumable beneficial animal became a burden once the ecology the near east diverged from its original landscape. Toward the end of the last ice age, the emergence of agriculture led to forest reduction and grassland expansion, equivocal to the reduction of the natural pig habitat. Swine, monogastrics like humans, became competition in the rapidly changed environment that could barely provide enough sustenance for the human population, this led to the stigmatization of swine as unclean.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Cultural Materialism." 10 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Cultural Materialism Essay example

- When it comes to anthropological theory the combination of several established ways of thought often result in a completely new and independent way of thinking. Cultural Materialism is one of these children theories that resulted from a coming together of social evolutionary theory, cultural ecology and Marxist materialism (Barfield). The goal of cultural materialism is to explain politics, economics, ideology and symbolic aspects of a culture with relation to the needs of that society. From a cultural materialist point of view society is indisputably shaped by the factors of production and reproduction....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
631 words (1.8 pages)

Essay about Postmodern Materialism And Subsemantic Cultural Theory

- Postmodern materialism and subsemantic cultural theory 1. Structuralist rationalism and the subcapitalist paradigm of reality In the works of Gibson, a predominant concept is the concept of patriarchialist truth. The primary theme of the works of Gibson is not narrative, but neonarrative. But the closing/opening distinction prevalent in Gibson's Neuromancer is also evident in Idoru, although in a more mythopoetical sense. Lyotard's model of subdialectic Marxism suggests that the significance of the poet is significant form....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
569 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Materialism and Greed

- Materialism: Can it make you Happy. Can Greed and Materialism lead to true happiness. “Greed is good. Greed is right. Greed works and greed will save the USA.” (Wall Street) “Cause we are living in a material world and I am a material girl” a theme in one of Madonna’s most famous songs. Greed and materialism stand in apposition to any manifestation of true happiness. People are under a false perception that money will solve all of their problems and as a result bring them their utmost joy and happiness....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
656 words (1.9 pages)

The ' The Rez Sisters ' Influenced By Materialism And White Society Beliefs

- The women in The Rez Sisters are highly influenced by materialism and White society beliefs. This influence is apparent when one looks at the goals of the sisters, which are acculturated and reflect the attitudes of White society rather than Native society. In Act 1, the women’s aspirations are perverted and extremely acquisitive. Annie wants to “buy a huge record player, the biggest one in the whole world”, Marie-Adele wants to “buy [herself] an island...the most beautiful island in the world” with a “real neat picket fence, real high, long and very, very, very white”, Philomena wants a “toilet......   [tags: Culture, Native Americans in the United States]

Research Papers
1915 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on Class Classification in Arnold Wesker’s Roots

- Arnold Wesker, an English playwright, a writer of international reputation, was born in Stephney (London) on 24 May,1932.He is the author of about Forty two plays mainly for the stage, four books of short stories, two collections of essays, a book for young people, three more of non-fiction and an autobiography. His works depict various themes, ideas, an obvious expression of deep sympathy, dreams, hopes and the humanism. Wesker is a dramatist with distinct social leanings. Roots is the second play of Wesker Triology which begins with Chicken soup with Barley and ends with I’m talking about Jerusalem....   [tags: english playwright, short stories, materialism]

Research Papers
1657 words (4.7 pages)

The Concept of Cultural Relativism Essays

- Miner stated that “looking from far and above, from our high places of safety in the developed civilization, it is easy to see all the crudity and irrelevance of magic. But without its power and guidance early man could not have mastered his practical difficulties as he has done, nor could man have advanced to higher stages of civilization” (1956, p.507). This tells us that if we can see and understands everything that happens around us then we can move up but if we don’t then we can never advance in our life....   [tags: developed civilization, safety]

Research Papers
698 words (2 pages)

Cultural Movement: The Hippie Movement Essay

- By the early 1960’s, America experienced a cultural movement of seismic proportions; primarily within it’s youth. Appropriately deemed the counterculture, this social metamorphosis was based upon a transition from strict long-held American values to a widespread antiestablishment attitude. The hippie movement, as it was commonly called, began as a youth movement in 1960’s America. College-aged men and women throughout the United States adopted an entirely new belief system and way of life; this cultural phenomenon would soon become known as the hippie movement....   [tags: mainstream society, sexual promiscuity]

Research Papers
1476 words (4.2 pages)

An Analysis of the Article, Two Cheers for Consumerism by James Twitchell.

- ... He stated that “Consumption have become production,” (367 Twitchell) that the consumer demands for product gives the sense of what they want or need leading to the producer to satisfy this urge. He also claims that commercialism is to the consumers “the water they swim in, the air they breathe, the sunlight and shade,” (366 Twitchell) for instant the essential means of life. Twitchell wants the reader to see consumers see commercialism and how it incorporates in their everyday life. In this statement that he used from Thomas Hobbes is states, “As in other things, so in men, not the seller but the buyer determines the price.” Furthermore the consumer makes the chose it makes and allows th...   [tags: materialism, commercialism, capitalism]

Research Papers
603 words (1.7 pages)

Dominate Cultural Patterns of Switzerland Essays

- Interpersonal Relations/Communications Dominant Cultural Patterns in the United States as Compared and Contrasted to Dominant Cultural Patterns in Switzerland Switzerland is one of the most mountainous countries in Europe. The Alps cover more than half of the country. It is a small country of 15,942 square miles. The country can be geographically divided into 3 areas: the Alps, the Mittleland (plateau), and the Jura mountains. The population of Switzerland is about 7.3 million, with the majority of the population living in the Mittleland area....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Research Papers
891 words (2.5 pages)

Cultural Fusions Essay example

- "I felt expansion, as if the world was branching out in shoots. I felt smallness, how the Earth divided into bits and kept dividing" writes Louise Erdrich in "Love Medicine." This seemingly paradoxical epiphany, as experienced by Lipsha Morrissey, captures the emotional traumas faced by those who are on the quest for self-identity. During our lifetimes, we all undergo spiritual discovery and development that shape our beliefs and values. Erdrich reveals the burden of this daunting task on multiethnic individuals, such as the Chippewa people who are "heavily mixed with French and Cree" (Coltelli)....   [tags: American Literature]

Research Papers
1120 words (3.2 pages)

The Bible and Quran reinforce this cultural perspective. Roy Rappaport, a functionalist, describes a similar situation in which seasonal ritual pig killings take place as a cybernetic feedback system regulatory method. The rainy season of Papua New Guinea brings not only a surplus of greenery but also a multiplication of pig that can deplete resources in the forest. The pigs are then ritually killed to maintain equilibrium. These examples indicate that taboos are present to maintain populations.
Religion not only contends to be the foundation of specific taboos it is a Marxist perspective of a means for social control. However, it is the meaning behind the social control that can be debated by the contrasting theoretical perspective of ideation or interpretive anthropology. Ideational perspective addresses the taboos given to food as culturally relative, it is the way in which the people perceive ideas of clean and unclean that justify the rules given to consumption of certain products. Mary Douglas proclaimed that reality is culturally defined and they are learned through socialization and enculturation. It can be said that Douglas believed, “Shared symbols promote social solidarity and provide mechanisms for social control…religious ideas about purity and pollution symbolize beliefs about social order” (Mcgee, 2003;525-527). Unlike materialism, there is a reason for taboos, but observing each culture and separately identifying the meaning given to a certain aspect address that. It is important, as Geetz teaches to do a thick description of each observed culture due to the fact that as an outsider our Etic perspective can never be Emic. Harris, who openly states that his entire analysis is based on an etic perspective, generalizes the explanation food taboos.
Douglas believes that material conditions do not determine cultural norms, belief, taboos, etc (class notes Anth 466 2011). Judaic pork prohibition is a classification of reality, the classification drives the behavior, it is the emphasis--cultural meaning that drives the action. Classifiscations are set to regulate what is and what is not acceptable. Socially, some ideas are set and taken on as acceptable notions of what can and cannot be eaten, what is “unclean” or clean. It is these ideas which shape the rules, which if not followed is viewed as disgusting or wrong. Socialization and interactions help distributed this social thought. As opposed to materialism, pig prohibition is not due to the material sustainable world, but due to the particular cultural worldview on the cleanliness of pigs. Religion is first in and thought is first in the ideational perspective not the product as in cultural materialism. “Biblical texts classify all animals in Genesis (animals that soar in the sky; swim in the water; or jump, walk or hop or land), also specify that clean, edible animals ‘chew the cud’ and have ‘cloven hoofs’ (cattle, sheep and goats – clean, pigs – unclean) .”
Consumption, production and redistribution of food are determined by power. Power is generally given to and represent religious ideologies and the ability to control people, what better way to control a population than their means of survival, food. The paradigm perspectives of ideational and materialism theories address several ways in which this is done. The reasoning behind rules about food can be attributed to either theoretical perspective. However, in the modern world, the access to foods and the “open-market” foodways can make the functionalist perspective of materialism irrelevant. Still some commodities are more difficult to attain, hence why in the US certain products are much more expensive than others. In regards to the cultures mentioned in this paper by Mary Douglas, Marvin Harris and others it would seem that when comparing the two perspectives they are not as mutually exclusive as they would like to be. Environmental pressures, the ultimate cause, dictate resource availability, which effects operational components and requires adapting to that environment. Once certain components prove to be successful, rules are established to make those successes widespread knowledge that is to be taught from generation to generation in order to maximize fitness. Socialization, the proximate cause, occurs when the thought and meaning given to items as bad, unclean, polluted, or sacred is passed on and becomes social thought. Eventually, no one questions the notion of a when a plate is considered dirty; an understanding is developed and learned from and early age. The proximate cause is the rationalization of cultural thought and symbols resulting in laws and taboos, which then gain support through religious or socio-political authority and influence.

Return to