Controversial Subjects And Debates Within The Field Of Paleoanthropology

Controversial Subjects And Debates Within The Field Of Paleoanthropology

Length: 1542 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A plethora of controversial subjects and debates emerges in the field of paleoanthropology. The subject of what constitutes a new human species materializes tension within the field. The debates that arise from paleoanthropologist tend to be personal. This results from ambition and lifelong quests for recognition, funding, and fame, can make it difficult for paleoanthropologists to admit when they are wrong (Luskins). Therefore, research released by paleoanthropologist can cause conflict for students, teachers, and fellow specialist. Paleoanthropologist is to expect strife from counterparts, geography, and complication in the analysis of remains as a result of publicizing their data of unknown hominin species.
Disagreements surface in regard to the publishing of a paleoanthropologist’s discoveries of new hominid species. According to Luskins, “paleoanthropology is rife with dissent and with few universally accepted theories among its practitioners.” A large quantity of the controversies within paleoanthropology arises from fellow paleoanthropologist. In the midst of the field, each expert has his or her own idea of what constitutes a new species and how to adequately research the data to prove their find. Insufficient evidence originates from the lack of an appropriate amount of remains or inconclusive data. Fragmentation of the data, combined with the desire of confident assertion from paleoanthropologist sparks sharp disagreements within the field (Luskin). On the other hand, the criticisms that follow publications of new hominid species are a result of fellow practitioners discovering flaws in the initial data. The reviewing of a counterpart 's published inquisition is a part of a paleoanthropologist’s job. That is the reason ...


... middle of paper ...


...attempt to establish morphology. Wong’s article states, “The extreme mosaicism evident in A. sediba. Berger says, should be a lesson to paleoanthropologists. Had he found any number of its bones in isolation, he would have classified them differently.” In order to acquire valid assumptions about A. sediba, Berger spent years analyzing, excavating, revising his work before he published the research on A. sediba.
Overall, the establishment of a new human species is a very controversial topic. The geography and process of dating ancient remains cause strife when paleoanthropologist try to fit their discoveries within the fossil record. Fellow researcher’s criticisms are beneficial and harmful for the discipline of paleoanthropology. As more specimens are uncovered, the disputes and challenging of the fossil record will only increase in the field of Paleoanthropology.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Use of human subjects in research Essay

- The use of human subjects in research is very controversial in today’s society. However, there is a certain push to do certain experiments on humans, such as clinical trials for new medications or surgical procedures and social experiments on humans. It is believed that those results are more reliable than if those studies were carried out on other ‘model’ organisms in these fields. I have picked two cases from Shamoo and Resnik (2009) that relate to different aspects of the issue of human subjects in research....   [tags: Human Subjects, Society, Controversy]

Better Essays
1565 words (4.5 pages)

Essay about Between vs. Within-subjects Designs

- In simplest terms, an experiment that uses only between-subjects factors is said to use a between-subjects design, and an experiment that uses only within-subjects factors is called a within-subjects design. The fundamental hallmark of a between-subjects design is that each participant is assigned to one and only one level of each factor. For instance, participants might be randomly assigned to either receive negative feedback or positive feedback. Feedback is the independent variable, and it has two levels: positive or negative....   [tags: fatigue, experimental method,practice]

Better Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

The Common Consensus Within The Business Field Essay

- ... As other researchers point out, some schools claim to teach ethics as part of other generalized subjects. (Breaux, et al.) Outside of school, kids are often taught to save and make as much money as possible, but few parents teach their children to go about this in an ethical manner. An article by the Clergy Journal titled “Teaching Children Financial Ethics" talks about teaching a child who makes a little over $400 dollars in one year that he or she must report that income and pay self-employment tax on it....   [tags: Business ethics, Ethics, Business, Applied ethics]

Better Essays
1227 words (3.5 pages)

The Diverse Nature of Psychology Essay

- ... Clinical psychologist must be vigilant when assessing patients that fit into the new American family mold (Plante, 2011) Industrial–Organizational Psychology Industrial/Organizational psychology is derived from industrial psychology and organizational psychology. The industrial side of the field strives for efficiency within a company by taking on a managerial perspective to ensure that human resources are being utilized (Spector, 2012). The organizational side of the field strives to ensure that employee morale is where it needs to be and the employees are properly taken care of (Spector, 2012)....   [tags: divisions within the field]

Better Essays
1076 words (3.1 pages)

Psychology, But Within What Field? Essay

- I’m majoring in psychology, but within what field. A career in psychology is one that offers a wide variety of paths in which you can pursuit it. When one decides that they want to accomplish a degree in psychology, the next step is to decide what specific path you are willing to take. In the beginning we might feel overwhelmed, unsure and scared by having all these choices, and not knowing which one to turn to, or if were even making the right choice. Exploring the different paths in the career can help us narrow down the alternatives that we are exposed to....   [tags: Psychology, Psychiatry]

Better Essays
1174 words (3.4 pages)

Gender Inequality Within The Field Essay

- Another issue the U.S. economy fails to resolve is gender inequality within the field, which impacts females more negatively than the males. In terms of negative impact, Lucy argued, “It’s a double-edged sword. For one thing, there’s the wage gap. And it’s also difficult for getting into higher positions.” Nonetheless, though anxious about the future, Lucy looks forward to it based on “little hope” from the knowledge of activists fighting towards gender equality policies. Hence, although the inclusive economy theoretically provides a leveling-of-the-field for equal participation opportunities, gender standards limit the depth or height of participation, or the range of opportunities availabl...   [tags: Family, Gender, Working class, Gender equality]

Better Essays
961 words (2.7 pages)

Ethical Issues Within The Field Of Social Work Essay

- Moreover, ethical issues are ubiquitous within the field of social work. As such, social workers employed in all facets of the profession, whether it is substance abuse, mental health, among many others encounter ethical issues common and specific to each area. According to the article “Ethical Issues in Addiction Counseling” by Cynthia G. Scott (2000), prominent ethical situations specific to the field of substance abuse include, “confidentiality and privileged communication” (p. 213). In her article Scott (2000) discuss the blurred boundaries of confidentiality with regards to group counseling....   [tags: Ethics, Sociology, Social justice, Social work]

Better Essays
884 words (2.5 pages)

Deviant Burial Practices Within The Field Of Archaeology Essay

- ... One common interpretation of deviant burials could be that the person must have been a criminal or social deviant in life. However, this interpretation could be entirely incorrect, which is why the term deviant burial can be misleading. Therefore, it is essential that archaeologists tread carefully when presenting data and interpretations dealing with deviant burial so as to not unintentionally misrepresent the archaeological record. These negative connotations may have to do with the word deviant itself, or as Edeltraud Aspöck (2008) suggests, it may be caused due to the traditions and way in which the subject has been approached in the past....   [tags: Burial, Cremation, Cemetery, Michel Foucault]

Better Essays
2433 words (7 pages)

Essay about Biblical Wisdom On The Subjects Of Diligence And Laziness

- ... The Bible is very clear about this concept in the New Testament book of 2 Thessalonians, has Paul is addressing the believers at Thessalonica: “For even when we were with you, we used to give you order: if anyone is not willing to work, then he not to eat either (2 Thessalonians 3:10). Paul goes on further to say, do not grow weary of doing well and do not associate with people with a slothful kind of character. We have created a generation that feels it is okay to just to “float” through life, hard work and work ethics are not talk about nor taught....   [tags: Bible, God, Work ethic, New Testament]

Better Essays
1225 words (3.5 pages)

Field of Dreams - The Innocence in History Essay

- Field of Dreams - The Innocence in History [1] Baseball is America’s favorite pastime. When people hear the word "America," they think of apple pie, meat and potatoes, July 4th, and inevitably the everlasting love of this country, baseball. The credit is given to a man named Alexander J. Cartwright, who drew up a set of rules for a game played with a bat, a round ball, and a glove. Along with the rules came a sketching of a diamond-shaped field on which the game was to be played. The rules that Cartwright wrote up in 1845 may have very well changed somewhat, but the game of baseball has remained remarkably constant throughout history into today....   [tags: Field of Dreams Essays]

Free Essays
3903 words (11.2 pages)