Disadvantages Of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy

1120 Words3 Pages

Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) was developed by Elis and Beck (1965) and is based on the cognitive/behavioural models of abnormality. It is a treatment delivered by therapists to help those who suffer from various mental health problems. According to Beck’s cognitive model of depression, problems can develop in early stages of a patients life as a result of a neglectful, harsh environment. Such adversity may lead to the formation of negative schemas about the self. Cognitive biases, automatic thoughts and a persistent negative mood follow as a consequence of this and entail lowering the quality of one’s life. Ultimately, those who proceed through therapy correctly should have learned alternative ways of thinking and behaving. (Meichenbaum …show more content…

Firstly, patients seeking help for a variety of mental health problems will be administered the same treatment by the NHS, from obsessive completive disorders to irritable bowel syndrome. Therefore, though the broad range of applications for CBT can be considered an advantage, one cannot rely on therapy alone to cure their specific problem. There is a need for variation of CBT therapies applied to specific problems. CBT has proven less successful in treating some mental conditions in comparison with others. For example, though it is proved effective with treating anxiety and depression, its effectiveness in treating schizophrenia is most doubted. Meta-analysis shows that treatment of schizophrenia with CBT needs to be further researched as other methods, or a combination of methods prove more helpful (Pilling 2002) However, its effectiveness is significant when treatment is given in combination with other support. For example, studies have shown that community psychiatric nurses, specialising in treating the early stages of schizophrenia are effective, especially with medication and normal care/ monitoring alongside the treatment (Turkington et al …show more content…

Rational Emotive Behavioural therapy (REBT) being one of them. This treatment was initially developed by Ellis in 1952. It is based on the idea that ones persistent self-defeating thoughts are irrational . In simple terms, ellis explains that irrational beliefs can be identified when we find ourselves thinking we ‘should’ or ‘must’ have or do things which are subjectively important. For example, ‘I must be the best’ or ‘I should be liked by everyone’ or similar statements are irrational thoughts and lead to self-defeating beliefs, such as ‘I am unintelligent’ or ‘I don’t deserve the good things I have’. These beliefs are counter productive when it comes to making proactive decisions that improve our lives. It is therefore an advantage for those who have suicidal thoughts in order to get better. Research in this area has also pinpointed perfectionism as a source of suicidal thinking and a target for REBT patients(Blatt et

Open Document