"That government is best which governs least." Or is it? Should the American people be free to rebel against laws they consider unjust? Henry David Thoreau addresses these issues in his essay, Civil Disobedience. Thoreau wholeheartedly accepts the declaration that the government is best which governs least, and would like to see it acted upon. One day, he hopes, we will be able to carry it out to the point where men can have a government that does not govern at all. Government "never of itself furthered any enterprise". He claims that the character of the American people, rather than the government, has kept the country free, settled the west and educated the people. If the government had not interfered, the people would have accomplished even more. Thoreau goes on to claim that we should not decide what is 'right' by majority, but rather by individual conscience. If an individual believes a law to be unjust, he should not obey the law. Thoreau had some good, high-sounding ideas, but it appears he did not understand the reasoning behind some of what the government does. His views do not match up to the views found in the Constitution and the Bible.
Thoreau claims that we should not decide right by majority, but by conscience. The majority are not necessarily right; they are only in power because they are the strongest group of people. Any government in which the majority rules in all cases cannot be based on justice. Thoreau asks why there cannot be "a government in which majorities do not virtually decide right and wrong, but conscience? ... Must the citizen... resign his conscience to the legislator? Why has every man a conscience, then? I think that we should be men first, and subjects afterwards." One should cultivate a res...
... middle of paper ...
... what is right and wrong morally will have complete power, which can easily lead to a tyrannical ruler.
Thoreau says we should not obey unjust laws - yet, if everyone did this, people would begin to call 'unjust' laws that they did not particularly like or that were hard to follow. In addition, this exhortation is completely against Biblical teaching. We are to obey governing authorities unless their laws go against God's law. Minorities can influence the government, but not in the way that Thoreau advises. We should instead be an influence as Peter counsels us to be an influence,
"For it is God’s will that by doing good you should silence the ignorant talk of foolish men. Live as free men, but do not use your freedom as a cover-up for evil; live as servants of God. Show proper respect to everyone: Love the brotherhood of believers, fear God, honor the king."
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- ... (Thoreau 272). Although, Thoreau theme concerned nature, life, and solitude, this narrative continues to influence the reader to desire more, as the reader takes a journey with the author. There is a possibility that the unique character’s in the narrative assist with maintaining a reader’s interest. In addition, the narrative is witty and, the author performs as a good listener, and a relaxed host. As of today, the narrative may be used as a bedtime story or a coffee table book. Meanwhile, during the Romantic era, “Rip Van Wrinkle” written by Washington Irving, is illustrated with simplicity, as it targets an unlimited audience, from the young, too those with youthful spirits.... [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Civil disobedience]
1038 words (3 pages)
- ... This is something that most do not agree with, but they go with it because the government says so. The government in Divergent is the antithesis of what Thoreau believes a government should be. In the movie, Beatrice rebels in an attempt to stop the hunt for Divergents, Thoreau would applaud Beatrice for her act of rebellion. Thoreau absolutely believes that rebellion is an appropriate reaction to disagreement with the government. This can be seen when he says,“All men recognize the right of revolution; that is, the right to refuse allegiance to, and to resist, the government, when its tyranny or its inefficiency is great and unendurable” (Thoreau 257).... [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Civil disobedience]
1024 words (2.9 pages)
- Henry David Thoreau starts Civil Disobedience with “I heartily accept the motto— “That government is best which governs the least,” and I should like to see it acted up to more rapidly and systematically” (para. 1). The impression that I got when I read this first sentence is that he had some issues with how the government works. His statement, “That government is best which governs not at all,” somehow sent me an impression that he does not want a government when in fact he just does not want how the government is structured so he calls for its reformation.... [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Civil disobedience]
1224 words (3.5 pages)
- ... He suggests that the government itself has reached prosperity by losing its integrity, causing the citizens to start losing faith and questioning their actions. The metaphor that Thoreau says involves a “wooden gun” that has the representation of the people going to war with it as their choice of weapon; in other words it’s useless. The parallel structure that Thoreau uses that suggests the necessity of a better government is describing the government in “not doing anything while the citizens are doing everything.” Paragraphs five and six introduces the idea of ethics for the first in part one of Thoreau’s essay “Civil Disobedience.” He makes the distinction of which type of men serve... [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Civil disobedience]
1122 words (3.2 pages)
- Henry David Thoreau was born in a time where the government is not progressing, because they do not respect the rights of all individuals. In "Civil Disobedience," Thoreau shows his readers how useless the government was at the time. In government where they demand obedience from its people, even allowing some individuals to enslave each other. Men that work for the State are unable to practice their moral beliefs in human law, because State laws prevent from doing what is right. Although, Thoreau does believe that one individual can effect a major social change.... [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Civil disobedience]
908 words (2.6 pages)
- When it comes to civil rights, there are two pieces of literature commonly discussed. One of these pieces is Henry David Thoreau’s persuasive lecture On the Duty of Civil Disobedience. In this work, Thoreau discusses how one must combat the government with disobedience of unjust laws and positive friction to create change. The second piece is the commonly known article Letter From a Birmingham Jail by Martin Luther King Jr. This letter covers the ways in which peaceful protest and standing up against injustice can lead to positive results.... [tags: Civil disobedience, Henry David Thoreau]
1261 words (3.6 pages)
- “Civil Disobedience” by Henry David Thoreau was a means of educating people on why they should not settle for a less than perfect government. Thoreau’s work is a reminder that it is our duty to throw off an unsatisfactory government, as stated by Thomas Jefferson in the “Declaration of Independence.” Civil Disobedience touches on the subject of why people choose to do nothing about a government they are unhappy with. People fear the consequences they might suffer if they do interfere with the current government.... [tags: Civil Disobedience Essays]
1167 words (3.3 pages)
- "That government is best which governs least." Or is it. Should the American people be free to rebel against laws they consider unjust. Henry David Thoreau addresses these issues in his essay, Civil Disobedience. Thoreau wholeheartedly accepts the declaration that the government is best which governs least, and would like to see it acted upon. One day, he hopes, we will be able to carry it out to the point where men can have a government that does not govern at all. Government "never of itself furthered any enterprise".... [tags: Henry David Thoreau, Constitution]
1158 words (3.3 pages)
- ... Besides the fact that Thoreau was one of the biggest transcendentalist writers, he was not the one that founded the movement. During the time of accent Greece, the philosopher Plato developed it as a philosophy in which a higher reality exist in the knowledge of people. As time went by and the world shifted, so did Transcendentalism. In the 19th century, the Transcendentalism was reborn to be a literary movement more than a philosophical movement. The new Transcendentalist movement celebrated the ideas of self-reflection and individualism.... [tags: Ralph Waldo Emerson, Henry David Thoreau]
1139 words (3.3 pages)
- Civil Disobedience by Henry David Thoreau Thoreau's essay entitled "Civil Disobedience" i was an excellent way of educating the public on why people should not settle for a less than perfect government. His belief in demanding a better government was a great reminder that Thomas Jefferson insisted that it was our "duty, to throw off"(2) an unsatisfactory government in the "Declaration of Independence" ii Thoreau's essay also explained why people choose not to do anything about it. Thoreau stated that people "cannot spare the protection of the existing government, and they dread the consequences to their property and families of disobedience to it" (25).... [tags: Civil Disobedience Essays]
2052 words (5.9 pages)