Essay on The Centralia No. 5 Mine Explosion: A Failure in Public Administration

Essay on The Centralia No. 5 Mine Explosion: A Failure in Public Administration

Length: 1468 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Description
Centralia Coal Company was owned by Bell & Zoller Coal & Mining Company. Herbert E. Bell was the Chairman and William P. Young was the Vice President. Illinois ranked third in coal production. Four agencies had authority over coal mining at the time; the state of Illinois, the United States Government, Centralia Coal Company and the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA). The explosion in Centralia No. 5 occurred on March 25, 1947. Beginning with his appointment in 1941, State Mine Inspector Driscoll O. Scanlan sent inspection reports to the Department of Mines and Minerals (DMM) Director Robert M. Medill. The U.S. Bureau of Mines inspected Centralia No. 5 the first time in September 1942. Findings and recommendations were the same in all reports. Scanlan requested maintenance related to safety issues. The U.S. Bureau of Mines report supported his findings. In all this time nothing was done.
Diagnosis
Inspector Scanlan sent reports every three months from 1942 – 1944 repeating recommendations and adding new ones. He considered Centralia No. 5 the worst mine in his district. Coal dust and gas are explosion hazards. Steps can be taken to minimize these concerns. Rock dusting is a method used to localize an explosion. Illinois law requires rock dusting in a seriously dusty mine. Mr. Scanlan was the first line for the miners. He had the authority to close the mine and did not do it. He later mentioned being afraid of losing his job. It was his responsibility as a public administrator to take action.
As part of his campaign for Governor, Dwight Green had promised to enforce mining laws. In 1941 Governor Green appointed Robert Medill as Director of the Department of Mines and Minerals. The Mining Board makes the p...


... middle of paper ...


...plete report. Before this was done the mine blew up. In the end, the news story that broke was focused on union campaign contributions and not on mine safety.
All levels of protection for the miners failed them. Every agency that was entrusted with their safety had other concerns as priority. Mr. Scanlan submitted true and honest reports of violations over a long period of time but never went that extra step to enforce the law. State authorities should have acted when the initial reports were made. The Union membership was at risk and yet the Union never represented Local 52 nor gave it support when it tried on its own to get state assistance with their grievances. Politics and profit motivated elected officials appointees and the coal company.



Works Cited

Stillman, R.J., (2010), Public Administration Concepts and Cases, Boston, Wadsworth Cengage Learning.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Protecting Against Terrorist Attacks in Urban Environments: Explosion Protection for Buildings

- Introduction Blast protection, until recently, has only needed to be considered when constructing underground shelters and military bunkers. Currently, however, there is a need for urban buildings and similar structures used consistently by the general public to withstand forces from nearby explosions. This need is due to the recent climb in terrorist attacks in urban or crowded environments. These attacks have used the lack of blast resistance in these buildings as a means for creating widespread havoc through detonating an improvised explosive device (IED)....   [tags: Blast Protection]

Powerful Essays
1926 words (5.5 pages)

The Blast at Centralia No. 5: A Mine Disaster No One Stopped Essay

- a. Topic Statement The case study The Blast in Centralia no. 5: A mine Disaster No One Stopped is a useful lens through which to identify potential pitfalls for national security organizations. The most powerful lessons that ought to be learned by the case study are twofold. First, political interference in the work of governmental organizations can lead to dysfunction and mission failure. Second, the failure to conduct independent oversight over a governmental organization—especially when its performance has been openly questioned—permits that dysfunction to continue unabated....   [tags: political intervention, mission failure]

Powerful Essays
1870 words (5.3 pages)

Essay about Mine in Chile Suffered a Cave-In on August 2010

- On August 5, 2010 the San José mine, a small copper operation in northern Chile owned by Minera San Esteban Primera, suffered a cave-in leaving 33 workers trapped underground at a depth of 300 meters. The following Saturday a second cave-in forced rescuers to suspend works for several hours. Some brief background on the accident. It was revealed that accidents in major mines are rare, but local organizations, such as the federation of Chilean mining workers (FMC) and the confederation of copper workers (CTC) questioned Minera San Esteban's safety record, where several fatal accidents were previously reported at the small company....   [tags: copper mine,rescue,FMC]

Powerful Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Ammonia Explosion and The West Fertilizer Company Essay

- West, Texas is a town located in McLennan County in the central part of Texas. It has a population of around 2,800 people. During the evening of Wednesday the 17th April of 2013 a massive explosion occurred in the small town. The West Fertilizer Company; which is owned by Adair Grain Inc. which had stockpiles of anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate amongst other agricultural items; was the center and cause of the blast. It is not the first time that an explosion such as this has happened in the state of Texas; in 1947 in Texas city, Texas an explosion that caused nearly 600 deaths had ammonia as a key part in the blast (Jonsson, 2013)....   [tags: Anhydrous Ammonia, Texas, Explosions]

Powerful Essays
975 words (2.8 pages)

Market Failure Of Corporate Buybacks Essay

- Market Failure in Corporate Buybacks In recent years, American CEOs at S&P 500 corporations have taken up a particular practice—with startling consistency. Through the use of “corporate buybacks”, or purchasing outstanding shares of a company’s own stock, CEOs and their board members have artificially boosted share prices. This increases the value of the stock for shareholders, and particularly for those who conduct the practice, who often receive a large portion of their compensation in company stock....   [tags: Externality, Market failure, Economics]

Powerful Essays
1891 words (5.4 pages)

The West Fertilizer Plant Explosion Essay

- The West Fertilizer Plant Explosion On April 17, 2013, the community of West, Texas, suffered a devastating and heartbreaking event in the evening hours. After a fire broke out inside the West Fertilizer plant, a massive explosion leveled the facility, caused millions of dollars in damage to surrounding buildings, and took the lives of over a dozen people. Sadly, the majority of those killed were volunteer firefighters who had responded to the fire and were unable to retreat to a safe distance before the explosion....   [tags: massive explotion, aftermath, texas]

Powerful Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Chernobyl Nuclear Reactor Explosion

- "Chernobyl" is a nuclear reactor accident occurred in the Chernobyl nuclear power plant in Ukraine. The accident was by far the most serious nuclear disaster. It pollutes the many areas around and increases the incidence of cancer around the inhabitants. Since the Chernobyl accident, the Soviet Union suffered a heavy blow disaster, while enhancing the worldwide nuclear power industry for safety concerns, and slowed the progress of a series of nuclear power engineering. Disaster occurs mainly due to the failure of the reactor design, and employee carelessness and violation of the rules....   [tags: Chernobyl disaster, Nuclear power, Nuclear safety]

Powerful Essays
1509 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Failure And Failure Of Failure

- People usually afraid of failure because they tried to do something and failed, or took a risk and it didn’t pay off, or made a decision and it turned out to be the wrong one. That fear of failure create the stress and anxiety when people want to do something hard or try something new. Just because you tried something two or three time and failing does not mean the entire idea is a mistake. Do you expect to get a Blackjack on every game that you played. That would be an impossible thing to do. There is no success that comes without failure, where failure is experiences and lessons that help you to perfect your works....   [tags: Failure, Success, Basketball]

Powerful Essays
772 words (2.2 pages)

Failure : Failure And Failure Essay

- Failure. No one wants to talk about failure. It’s the nasty blemish people hide under excuses and funny anecdotes. Although usually seen as a hindrance, failure helps shape character and deliver wisdom from the experience it provides. While undesirable, helps build an armor and teaches its victims to fight like knights for the cause they believe in. When I was a junior in high school, I had a personal experience with failure that shaped the way I approached life and helped me mature and grow. Though it was hard, and I still am feeling the shock waves of consequences, I’m glad to be stronger and wiser through my faults....   [tags: Failure, Education, Reliability engineering]

Powerful Essays
719 words (2.1 pages)

Bebe Moore Campbell’s You’re Blues Ain’t Like Mine Essay

- In Bebe Moore Campbell’s, You’re Blues Ain’t Like Mine, I was able to view the novel from the three main sociological perspectives: the structural-functionalist approach, the social-conflict approach, and the symbolic-interaction approach. From the structural-functionalist point of view, I analyzed the Honorable Men of Hopewell as the power elite. I viewed Mamie Cox’s understanding of social class from the social-conflict perspective, and Doreen and Lily Cox differences were easily seen through the symbolic-interaction approach....   [tags: Analysis Bebe Campbell Blues Mine]

Free Essays
1402 words (4 pages)