Napoleon’s death has been attributed to many causes: stomach cancer, arsenic poisoning, improper medical treatment, hepatitis, and St. Helena’s climate. The purpose is to ascertain the likeliest cause, and if foul play was involved. With each possible cause, there are different implications, i.e., cancer frees everyone from blame, hepatitis incriminates the British, improper medical treatment the doctors, and poisoning implicates the suspected poisoner. The focus is on four causes - cancer, poisoning, improper treatment, and hepatitis - common explanations for Napoleon’s failing health, and evidence that supports or refutes each case.
B. Summary of Evidence
1. Napoleon’s Last Days:
On May 5th, 1821; Napoleon died after a lengthy sickness, joined by more than six doctors in 1821(Kauffmann 87). He was 51. His health had started to decline March 1821; Antommarchi, Napoleon’s lead physician, introduced a tartar emetic (antimony potassium tartrate, highly toxic) to Napoleon’s diet to help with his persisting ailments. In April, Napoleon was feeling no better, and Montholon, the alleged poisoner of Napoleon who came to St. Helena for Napoleon to dictate notes on his career, thought orgeat, an almond drink would help ease thirst - Antommarchi titled the orgeat ‘orange-flower water’ in his papers, not knowing the true nature of the drink, which contained hydrocyanic acid. Napoleon had toxic substances in his system which he couldn’t expel due to the emetic (Schom 784). Napoleon, unfortunately, looked to Dr. Archibald Arnott, who after seeing the fate of O’Meara and Stokoe (previous doctors who had been dismissed over their diagnoses of hepatitis), and knowing Hudson Lowe, St. Helena’s governor and warden of ...
... middle of paper ...
...icopathologic approach to staging, pathogenesis, and etiology." Nature Clinical Practice Gastroenterology & Hepatology 4.1 Jan. (2007): 52-57. Print.
Johnson, Paul. Napoleon. New York: Viking, 2002. Print.
Kauffmann, Jean. The black room at Longwood: Napoleon's exile on Saint Helena. New York: Four Walls
Eight Windows, 1997. Print.
McLynn, Frank. Napoleon: a biography. London: Pimlico, 1998. Print.
Schom, Alan. Napoleon Bonaparte . New York, NY: HarperCollins, 1997. Print.
Thompson, James Matthew. Napoleon Bonaparte, his rise and fall. . Oxford: B. Blackwell, 1952. Print.
Unwin, Brian. Terrible exile the last days of Napoleon on St Helena. London: I.B. Tauris, 2010. Print.
Weider, Ben, and David Hapgood. The murder of Napoleon . New York: Congdon & Lattes, 1982. Print.
Williams, David. The fall of Napoleon: the final betrayal. New York: Wiley, 1994. Print.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Napoleon Bonaparte Few individuals have come along that have captivated the imaginations of their contemporaries and of historians. Perhaps the most prolific of these characters is Napoleon Bonaparte. The part of his life often found most intriguing was his humble beginnings. Here, like some Hollywood movie is the tale of an exceptional man whose intelligence and rise from the bottom is eventually defeated by his flaws, which cause him to fall from power. He was born in Corsica just off the coast of Italy.... [tags: Biography Napoleon Bonaparte Essays]
1819 words (5.2 pages)
- Napoleon crossing the Alps is also is the title given to the five versions of oil on canvas equestrian portrait of Napoleon Bonaparte painted by the French artist Jacques-Louis David between 1801 and 1805. Initially commissioned by the Spanish Ambassador to France, the composition shows a strongly idealized view of the real crossing that Napoleon and his army made across the Alps through the Great St. Bernard Pass in May 1800. Napoleon comes across to me as a leader in many different of ways. Jacques- Louis David is the creator of this painting.... [tags: art, painting, european history]
785 words (2.2 pages)
- When observing our history, it is common to see in numerous cases, the outcomes of an upheaval do not match the motivations or reasonings behind it. Take in account the American Revolution, for an example. Though the patriots preached of equality for all, slavery still existed in America for nearly a century and women remained remarkably oppressed even to this day. In order to judge and determine the extent of which Napoleon represents the ideals of the French Revolution, we must understand the revolution itself, the meaning and causes of the revolution, Napoleon himself, and what he believed in.... [tags: oppression, france, democratic government]
1556 words (4.4 pages)
- Napoleon Bonaparte From the moment of his birth, something in the stars said that Napoleon Bonaparte would one day emerge as the leading power of the French. He was a man of many talents. His distinctive personality was a clear indicator of his glory and fame to come. He tended to appeal to other's senses in order to gain for himself. " His rule was to mark the close of the revolution, a return to order and stability, a rejoining of the history of France with the first stage of the Revolution, but only the first stage " 1.... [tags: Papers]
2215 words (6.3 pages)
- Napoleon Bonaparte Napoleon Bonaparte was born at Ajaccio, in Corsica, on August 15, 1769, of a good family in a well-established position. He had many brothers and sisters and these family relations played an important part in his later life. He was a soldier from his childhood, entered the military school at Brienne when he was 10, and obtained his lieutenant's commission when he was sixteen. He apparently began with some literary ambition and wrote various pamphlets. In these, as in all he ever wrote, there is a curious tendency to rhetoric, coupled with the power to drop such rhetoric completely and speak out with a native vigor and energy that burns and stings.... [tags: Papers]
757 words (2.2 pages)
- The nation of France underwent a crucial revolution from 1789 to 1799. Amidst this period, Republicans took control of the French government from the King and later on The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen was instituted to provide protection for its people. At the helm of these revolutions, Napoleon Bonaparte, a young general had began to win many foreign battles and was steadily rising in the army's ranks. It was through these battles that Napoleon was able to lead his armies to conquering most of Europe and many other nations of the world.... [tags: religion, liberation, freedom]
703 words (2 pages)
- French Revolution and Napoleon The French Revolution entered a radical stage in 1972 because of the dissatisfaction of the poor, dissatisfaction of the nobles and the clergy, economic crisis, a crisis in leadership, foreign invasion, international polarization, Jacobins gaining power of the national convention, the grow of a counter revolution and the the september massacres. However, accomplishments like purging france of any old order thinkers, turning france into a republic and allowing Bonaparte to come to power came out of such horrific events that is the radical stage.... [tags: French Revolution, Estates of the realm]
1413 words (4 pages)
- Napoleon: Swing between the Black and White The arguments about Napoleon Bonaparte have never stopped through hundreds of years after his death. Hero or Tyrant. The answer is just as complex as the question. Napoleon was still one of the most controversial historical figures today. The life of Napoleon was glorious, solemn and stirring. Some say that he is a shrewd politician; some say that he is a hero, who changed the history of Europe; some say that he is a sinner of war, a warmonger and a tyrant; some blame him for re-established the monarchy, which is the reverse of history.... [tags: French Revolution, Europe, History]
1410 words (4 pages)
- Napoleon Bonaparte was born on August 15, 1769, in his island homeland of Corsica. Napoleon was the second son of Carlo and Letizia. Corsica and France were at war. France had easily crushed the Corsican resistance, and taken over Corsica. So when Napoleon was born, he was considered a citizen of France. When Napoleon was nine years old and it was time for his schooling, he was sent to a school in Autun, France. At the school he was teased and tormented for being from Corsica, but he was determined, and he eventually learned enough French to attend the military academy Brienne.... [tags: Napoleon Bonaparte Biography France]
1518 words (4.3 pages)
- Napoleon Bonaparte One of the most brilliant individuals in history, Napoleon Bonaparte was a masterful soldier, and a superb administrator. He was also utterly ruthless, a dictator and, later in his career, thought he could do no wrong. Not a Frenchman by birth, Napoleon Bonaparte was born at Ajaccio on Corsica only just sold to France by the Italian state of Genoa on August 15, 1769.He attended French at the school of Autun and later the military academy at Brienne. He never fully mastered French and his spelling left a lot to be desired.... [tags: Biography Napoleon Bonaparte France]
1923 words (5.5 pages)