Cardinal Altamirano in the Film The Mission

974 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Ethical dilemma case

In the movie The Mission, even though Cardinal Altamirano deeply regrets destroying the missions to the Indians, he believes it is the right thing to do. Altamirano is a wise man and tries his best to remain just. He makes a difficult decision that helps the Portuguese create the boundaries of Central America, and he is filled with sorrow at the knowledge that his influence and decisions will result in many deaths. The cardinal is not only misunderstood by the Jesuits, he is also easily overlooked. He is also quite worldly, as he is bathed in riches, he has his own personal servants, and all his decisions are fuelled by greed. He is not the film’s main character, but he is the character who stands out the most to me. He makes difficult decisions and has to carry that burden with him. Altamirano is not someone we should strive to be like, but I believe we should strive to analyze situations as thoroughly as he does. Cardinal Altamirano is a conscientious man, he is also worldly, and he is very tenacious.

When he made decisions, Cardinal Altamirano is conscious of every possible outcome. It is imperative that he chooses to do what is needed, instead of what is right. He is also conscious that by choosing to save the missions, he will lose not only his reputation but also his position to contain power over events like these. He craved power and success, and he is incredibly good at receiving the two. He is also conscious that he is basically causing a genocide, and in the Jesuit’s eyes, this is considered unforgivable. Since the cardinal lived in such a corrupted time, he also assumes that his decision will push him so far away from God that redemption will be out of his reach. He is aware of all the negative effects and positive...

... middle of paper ...

...e motives, but this is what I have observed from the film.

I like to think that the ending of every good essay is an exclamation point, finishing a sentence with an extravagant piece of punctuation. I have discussed three different traits of Cardinal Altamirano, I hope have dug deep into his mind, perhaps not deep enough or perhaps I have not dug at all and I am writing about what is on the surface. I hope I uncovered the conscientious man, the worldly man and the tenacious man. He is a man of many mysteries and questionable paths. Nonetheless he thinks everything through, extremely tactically, and takes everything into account. Sadly he did conform to this world, but he blames himself not the world. He is a tenacious man, and stands firm in the face of danger. I aspire to be half as wise as he is, and I hope he realizes the extent to God’s forgiveness.

Show More
Related

  • Joaquin ‘El Chapo’ Guzman

    1815 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hilton, Ronald. “MEXICO: The Murder of Cardinal Juan Jesus Posadas Ocampo (1993).” Webmaster. N.p., 6 June 2003. Web. 15 April 2014.

    Read More

  • Perspective Of Ruirt De Niro

    603 Words  | 2 Pages

    The first perspective to be noted would be that of Rodrigo Mendoza. His character is played by Robert De Niro. Rodrigo Mendoza ultimately decides to fight for the people. He believes this is the best way to accomplish God's purpose, by fighting with and for the people. In the beginning, Mendoza would capture the Guarani Indians and sell them into plantation slavery. After killing his brother Felipe, his penance is to work in the Jesuit missions in South America. He becomes a Jesuit priest. While working there, he befriends the Guarani people, the same people he once captured. Father Altamirano representing the Vatican was sent to South America to close down the missions. On learning this new information, Rodrigo Mendoza becomes angry and decides to renounce his vows as a priest to Father Gabriel. Father Gabriel encourages him that violence was not the answer but it was ultimately...

    Read More

  • Padre Antonio Vieira's Sermons about "slaveries"

    1171 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...ira's descriptions of the order in the New World are very disturbing, because he compares them to a living Hell by giving crucial examples from the Bible. His main goal remains to build a peaceful society between the settlers and the natives. He believes that the slaves are being mistreated and forced to sin by their masters. This complicated war between the settlers and the natives leads to idolization of the Devil and contradicts God and the Bible. Vieira, being a religious man, wants to fulfill his obligations as a man of God and change the order of the New World. He emphasize the idea that a more fair and human treatment of the slaves would benefit them immensely. Most importantly, Padre Antonio Vieira has a divine wisdom and knowledge of the theological virtue of God and wants to share it with the sinners of the New World, creating a more Christian lifestyle.

    Read More

  • Bartolome De Las Casas

    1517 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...tence it at least allowed him to educate the natives about Christianity and that their experiences before now with the Europeans were not of a Christian nature. Throughout the letter, Las Casas seems careful to be very consistent and never veers from ensuring that his audience knows of the atrocities of the people of their own land to the natives – fellow humans. God has a plan for everyone and this is not it.

    Read More

  • The Rebirth of Ignatius in The Confederacy of Dunces

    3037 Words  | 7 Pages

    In spite of the fear which propels him, there is finally hope for Ignatius. Waddling fearfully into the world, he can now learn to accept his common fate with the rest of humanity--his own humanness and inherent vulnerability in a world over which he has no control. In her frustration and resignation, Ignatius' little mother, an unusual Earth Mother at best, once sadly and plaintively tells her son, "You learnt everything, Ignatius, except how to be a human being" (375). Therein lies a lesson for us all.

    Read More

  • Death Comes For The Archbishop: A Narrative Analysis

    1647 Words  | 4 Pages

    While in Santa Fe, New Mexico, the highly-regarded American novelist Willa Sibert Cather was captivated by the story of Archbishop Jean Baptiste Lamy and his friend, Father Macheboeuf. She was so enchanted by these two men that she decided to write a novel based on the events of their lives serving as Roman Catholic clergy in New Mexico. Her 1927 novel, Death Comes for the Archbishop, tells the story of Bishop Jean Latour and his friend, Father Joseph Vaillant, as they travel to New Mexico in the mid-nineteenth century to strengthen the Catholic faith of the natives. In Death Comes for the Archbishop, the natives of New Mexico are devout, but their religion has been corrupted by superstition because there have been no priests to instruct them on their faith. “This country was evangelized in fifteen hundred, by the Franciscan Fathers. It has been

    Read More

  • Chapter Summary Of Francis Of Assisi

    1375 Words  | 3 Pages

    In chapter two, ‘Francis and His Companions,’ Cunningham exposes the considerable growth in Francis of Assisi’s influence, as he recounts his companions that joined him after deciding to live his life. The chapter is significant because it exposes how Francis of Assisi’s gospel is different from the orthodox Catholic practices, which recognized the pope, as the sole Vicar of Christ. (Cunningham 32). This chapter is important in my life because it reinforces my conviction God is the almighty and all-powerful, and all people regardless of the status of the needed to worship

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis On Pope Francis

    524 Words  | 2 Pages

    I would love to learn more about Pope Francis’s views on everything. He demonstrates what it is like to be a virtuous person and as Aristotle has said “The virtuous life is the best life.” By being as virtuous as Pope Francis, I believe that is what makes us, as humans, the most happiest.

    Read More

  • Ignatius Of Loyola Essay

    1552 Words  | 4 Pages

    With evaluating Ignatius of Loyola lacks having many strengths with the utmost good intentions for success and the greater good of the people around him. The start of is struggle for greatness is the flaw to want a “great name” (Ignatius, Autobiography I, 20) versus the want of greatness for the people around him. This stray can be demonstrated from the start in his military life as he sought the “enthralled by the vanities of the world” (Ignatius, Autobiography I, 20) and glory by risking the lives of others at the citadel of Pampeluna. When looking at hi...

    Read More

  • Finding Peace in Death Comes For The Archbishop

    1082 Words  | 3 Pages

    Although Father Latour may possess few worldly desires, one may argue he wants what others can benefit from as well as pleasing himself.  Along his journeys, Latour encounters various people, most associates of the Catholic Church like himself.  It seems as each time Latour detects a sense of deceit in a person, he progresses in his own mission of morality.  When one is trying so hard to embrace and follow the rules and restrictions of religion, as well as enjoy the worldly luxuries, a divided character is created within oneself.  It is not until true and total devotion is committed to ones religion that material things become irrelevant and one can be at peace.

    Read More

  • Saint Francis Of Assis

    855 Words  | 2 Pages

    Saint Francis of Assis wasn’t a good young boy, but after the voice of God speaking to him, he changed, and his actions show. Saint Francis was a saint from Assis who was known to help the poor and animals. Saint Francis wasn’t a good boy in his youth, but after his calling from God, he changed for the good of all people. Many pray the Saint Francis, so that he may relieve their stress on the poor and sick.

    Read More

  • The Meaning of Saint Franis´ Life

    1027 Words  | 3 Pages

    All human beings develop at different rates physically and mentally. Furthermore, there are some special characters that gain the ability to flourish in which they acquire a deeper understanding of life. This is usually as a result of one’s profound religious beliefs. Such as the disciples of Jesus Christ, they at some point of their life followed the teachings of Christ; subsequently, their beliefs allowed them to gain a deeper meaning of life. In this reading we will focus on the life of Francis, specifically on how he flourishes into Saint Frances. Saint Francis was an interesting character, which allows us to visualize how he matures from his self-indulging lifestyle into a humanitarian.

    Read More

  • St. Francis Of Assisi

    2952 Words  | 6 Pages

    St. Francis of Assisi was born in Umbria in the year 1182. He was a child every father hoped for, he was filled with life, a determined and courageous individual. He was gifted with rather good looks, qualities that attracted friends and a gift of leadership. His father was an extremely wealthy merchant in Assisi. But this son, his favourite, was the one who broke Peter Bernardone’s heart. The boy turned on his father, and in a vicious event that eventually resulted into a public scene. St. Francis of Assisi stepped away from his father, his business and left his father in a state of immense emotional suffering.

    Read More

  • St Francis Of Assisi

    367 Words  | 1 Pages

    Francis of Assisi lived about eight hundred years ago. He was born in the city of Assisi, Italy, in 1182. He was the son of Piero of Bernadone, who was a wealthy merchant. He received a education and seemed to follow his father's footsteps as a wealthy merchant. In 1201 he took part in an attack on Perugia, was taken hostage, and remained a captive there for a year. After his release, Francis joined the army but couldn't complete his time because he got sick. This period of time would change his life forever. During his sickness, Francis would spend hours meditating on the Lord in an old church, and he felt God drawing near to him. Some people come to Jesus with a memorable experience, but others come to Christ through a process. Francis' conversion wasn't an overnight experience, but it was definitely real.

    Read More

  • St. Ignatius Loyola

    1860 Words  | 4 Pages

    St Ignatius of Loyola is an inspiring person and has touched the lives of many people even now centuries after his death. Loyola has affected the lives of an uncountable number of people, either directly or indirectly. He started as an extremely brave and tough soldier and turned into the founder of a powerful religious order. He was born in 1491 in Spain and founded the Jesuits in 1540 at the age of 49.The Jesuits today are still a devoted religious order. Everything they do is in God’s name, hence their motto AD MAIOREM DEI GLORIAM this literally means “for the greater glory of God”. (Linten, Seven Things) Many Jesuits (and even non Jesuits like Pope John Paul II) sign their documents with amdg at the end to show that they do their work for God and not solely for themselves. (Linten, Seven Things) The Jesuits have survived multiple persecutions and yet have still remained a major influence in the church and in universities around the world. If it were not for an unfortunate cannonball shattering a soldier’s leg then none of this may have happened.

    Read More

More about Cardinal Altamirano in the Film The Mission

Open Document