Essay PreviewMore ↓
Capital punishment or the death penalty as it is commonly termed is of all the penal practices, the most controversial. This is not at all surprising, concerning the fact that it involves taking a human life. Because it is the most severe of all sentences, there have been countless efforts to abolish the death penalty, and these efforts have proved effective in most of the industrialized nations, with the exception of Japan and the United States of America. It is very important to know the issues surrounding capital punishment, because it occurs in the country we live in and affects us even if we are not on death row. Because capital punishment occurs in just about half of the world, it would be difficult to talk about all of the circumstances and issues of capital punishment in each country, and because of this, the focus of this analysis will be the United States of America.
It is difficult to describe the death penalty without discussing the methods used to carry out this punishment. In the past there have been various means to accomplishing it. For instance, crucifixion, drowning, burning, impaling, hangings and shootings have all been used as methods to inflicting a legal death upon an individual. However, most of these have been dubbed inhumane and therefore eliminated in most lands. So, in efforts to "civilize" executing a person, new techniques have been developed. For example, in France the guillotine was created as a quick and civilized means for meting out death as an alternative to beheading the criminals with a sword, which was sometimes too dull and required that the executer swing multiple times before the job was complete.
But today in the United States, capital punishment is typically met out by lethal gas, injection or electrocution. Three states execute by hanging, and another three do so by a firing squad. In the United States, there is a distribution of authority. On the federal level, the death penalty is provided for over forty crimes including premeditated murder, drug-trafficking and treason. But the federal government allows for the individual states to define crimes and choose their own penalties for crimes committed. Twelve of these fifty states have abolished the death penalty entirely.
Currently, in the US there are about 3,500 people on death row. California heads the list with 603 offenders awaiting their deaths and it is possible that by the end of the year another man, Scott Peterson, may join these ranks.
How to Cite this Page
"Capital Punishment in America." 123HelpMe.com. 14 Aug 2018
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Use of Capital Punishment in America The use of capital punishment in the U.S. is a growing concern for most American citizens. According to statistics, seventy percent of Americans are in support of the death penalty, while only thirty percent are against it. These statistics show that few people are against capital punishment (“Fact” 1). With the use of the death penalty growing the controversy is becoming more heated. With only twelve states left not enforcing it the resistance is becoming futile (“Fact” 4).... [tags: Capital Punishment Justice Death Penalty Essays]
1429 words (4.1 pages)
- Capital Punishment in America Capital punishment is the execution of a perpetrator for committing a heinous crime (homicide), and it is a hotly debated topic in our society. The basic issue is whether capital punishment should be allowed as it is today, or abolished in part or in whole. My argument is that: 1) Capital punishment is not an effective deterrent for heinous crimes. 2) Life imprisonment can be worse of a punishment than death, not as costly as execution, and better for rehabilitation.... [tags: Capital Punishment Death Penalty Essays]
1170 words (3.3 pages)
- Capital Punishment in America In recent news there has been a highly controversial issue regarding the use of capital punishment. Studies have shown that the newest form of punishment to those on death row may not be as beneficial and painless as once thought. Lethal injection could in fact be excruciatingly painful to the inmates that are put through it. This form of punishment took the place of the electric chair back in the 1970’s as the best form of execution. Those against capital punishment are still criticizing the use of lethal injection today along with any other form of execution.... [tags: Capital Punishment Essays]
1293 words (3.7 pages)
- Capital punishment in America is a controversial subject. Some people support the elimination of dangerous criminals from society, seeing it as a way to keep undesirable criminals from being released back among law abiding citizens; while others abhor the idea of taking the life of a convicted felon, preferring instead to keep these dangerous criminals under lock and key for their whole lives (also known as LWOP or Life With Out Parole). Debates rage amongst Democrats and Republicans, blacks and whites, and most politicians, over a solution to this slippery issue.... [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]
699 words (2 pages)
- The death penalty in America has been a controversial topic for many years. There are many organizations both fighting for and against capital punishment. No matter what type of research or actions are taken toward capital punishment there have always been disagreements. There are many factors that are incorporated in whether or not someone believes the death penalty should be used. These factors for both sides can be the chance of innocence, cruel and unusual punishment, effectiveness of deterrence, and cost.... [tags: the death penalty, controversial topics]
2171 words (6.2 pages)
- Prior to the nineteenth century, if a criminal was convicted of an offense that was deemed punishable by death, the execution was held publicly in hopes to deter other citizens from committing crimes. Today executions are announced to the public but not viewed. The research provided in this document will show evidence to suggest whether capital punishment is or should be used as a method of preventing or lowering homicide rates in the United States. Do states with a death penalty have lower homicide rates.... [tags: death penalty, crimes]
881 words (2.5 pages)
- THE ULTIMATE PRICE: A Look into Capital Punishment in America Many Americans claim that capital punishment is a cruel and unusual punishment and goes against a persons constitutional rights. On the other hand, many Americans support it and claim it is against ther constitutional right not to carry out the death penalty. How are we to know what is right. In all honesty, facts, papers, journals, etc. can not decide how I am truly going to feel about a subject that is very much a macro-argument.... [tags: essays research papers]
986 words (2.8 pages)
- Capital Punishment in America Capital punishment or the death penalty as it is commonly termed is of all the penal practices, the most controversial. This is not at all surprising, concerning the fact that it involves taking a human life. Because it is the most severe of all sentences, there have been countless efforts to abolish the death penalty, and these efforts have proved effective in most of the industrialized nations, with the exception of Japan and the United States of America. It is very important to know the issues surrounding capital punishment, because it occurs in the country we live in and affects us even if we are not on death row.... [tags: Death Penalty Debate]
1478 words (4.2 pages)
- Capital Punishment in America In America, we no longer feel that crime should go without harsh punishment. Tim Robbins’ film, “Dead Man Walking” is a movie about a man named Matthew Poncelet (Sean Penn) who is on death row, and the different things he goes through as he counts down his final days until execution. The movie is based on a true story. Through the movie, I was able to see the different the steps that a death row inmate goes through leading up to execution. I cannot really say that the movie was pro or anti death penalty because I think it covered both sides well.... [tags: Papers]
1324 words (3.8 pages)
- The Racial Bias of Capital Punishment in America Throughout history, minorities have been ill-represented in the criminal justice system, particularly in cases where the possible outcome is death. In early America, blacks were lynched for the slightest violation of informal laws and many of these killings occured without any type of due process. As the judicial system has matured, minorities have found better representation but it is not completely unbiased. In the past twenty years strict controls have been implemented but the system still has symptoms of racial bias. This racial bias was first recognized by the Supreme Court in Fruman v.... [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]
1192 words (3.4 pages)
Also it is extremely expensive to put criminals to death. Proponents of the abolishment of death penalty argue that it costs way more money to execute a criminal than to keep them in prisons for life. On average it costs about $3.3 million dollars to execute a convict while it cost only $805,000 to keep an inmate in prison for fifty years. So it would be extremely costly to put all the convicts to death at once.
As I have mentioned previously, the first noteworthy movements towards the eradication of the death penalty were in the 1700's during the Age of Enlightenment. During this time, men such as Voltaire, Beccaria, Adam Smith and Thomas Paine wrote books and essays describing the injustices of capital punishment. However, these men did not get the responses they wanted and some even died because of expressing their opinions. In more recent times, there have also been efforts to change the law. For example, in 1972 Furman v. Georgia was a major case that changed the death penalty laws in the US forever. This was a case where three men claimed their 8th and 14th amendment rights were violated when they were condemned to death by the states of Georgia and Texas. The Supreme Court with a 5-4 vote declared that capital punishment was unconstitutional at that time. This forced the states to rewrite their death penalty laws to guard against discrimination and bias. In 1977 the new laws were completed and into effect when Gary Gilmore was executed by firing squad in Utah.
As aforementioned, there has been an ongoing debate over the death penalty in America. The chief argument for death sentences is that it can be used as a deterrent. Deterrence is the idea that executing murderers will decrease the rates of homicide by discouraging future murderers for fear
that they themselves will suffer the penalty of death. This is what is called "general deterrence". The second type of deterrence is called "specific deterrence" because if that murderer is killed, he will no longer be able to kill again. According to USA Snapshots, who conducted a study in 1984 this is correct. However, researchers now say that it may actually increase homicide rates. The term for this is "brutalization theory" meaning that by suggesting or legitimizing killing, it actually increases murder.
People in opposition to capital punishment think that a better solution is to make the murderer sit in a prison cell for life, with no possibility for parole. These persons feel the killer should have to suffer in their cell, for the rest of the life thinking about the crime they have committed, instead of taking the easy way out. People for the death penalty say that this is unjust for the convict to be allowed to live after they have taken away another life. This brings us into another argument for the death penalty: retribution. Some people feel that the victim's family deserves to know that the person that killed their loved one, suffers death also. The argument opposite this is that retribution is only for revenge. Revenge is a feeling, and death should not be taken lightly, especially because someone's feelings.
Then there is always the possibility that a person could be wrongly convicted. According to the Bureau of Justice, from 1976-2003 there have been 885 executions. There are new statistics showing that out of every 7 convictions, there is 1 wrong conviction. That is a staggering fourteen percent. One hundred and nine people have been exonerated on DNA evidence alone according to Barry Sheck, an attorney opposed to capital punishment. Advocates for maintaining the death penalty say that the number is small and it is more important to execute the other 86% of people who have committed the crimes, in order to preserve the lives of others at risk of becoming one of their victims.
I personally do not know exactly where I stand on this issue. I do believe that people who commit heinous crimes such as murder should have to pay for their crimes, but I think in most cases it is more of a punishment for them to have to spend their life in a six-by-nine jail cell, reflecting on the fact that they have killed someone else, denying them the right to life. But then for those who have killed several people without any remorse and who are likely to kill other inmates in prison, I feel that they should not have the right to live. Although I am not completely sure how I feel about capital punishment, I do however think that it should be reexamined, and used only in cases where it is likely the convict will kill other inmates in prison.
As you can see, the death penalty is a highly controversial issue that probably will not be resolved for a while. But it is a good idea to know the facts of the death penalty, including the circumstances in which it is administered, the methods of which it is met out by, the costs of this extreme punishment, and the arguments in the debate over it, because your opinion only matters if your knowledge is accurate, and so knowledge is power.
"Capital Punishment." Encarta , 2003. CD-ROM.
Capital Punishment Statistics. 14 Nov. 2004. U.S. Dept. of Justice. 28
Nov. 2004 .
The Economics of Captial Punishment. 1998. 28 Nov. 2004