Bullwhip Effect In Supply Chain Networks

Bullwhip Effect In Supply Chain Networks

Length: 1163 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The objective of supply chain management is to provide a high velocity flow of high quality, relevant information that will enable suppliers to provide an uninterrupted and precisely timed flow of materials to customers. However, unplanned demand oscillations, including those caused by stockouts, in the supply chain execution process create distortions which can wreck havoc up and down the supply chain. There are numerous causes, often in combination, that will cause these supply chain distortions to start what has become known as the Bullwhip Effect.
While the devil is usually buried in the details, as is the case here, the most common general drivers of these demand distortions are:
• Customers
• Promotions
• Sales
• Manufacturing
• Policies
• Processes
• Systems
• Suppliers

This unplanned for demand results in a disturbance or “lump of demand”, which may be a minor blip for any one customer, oscillates back through the supply chain often resulting in huge and costly disturbances at the supplier end of the chain. Often, these demand oscillations will launch a “mad scramble” in manufacturing with the need to acquire and expedite more raw materials and reschedule production.
The “Bullwhip Effect” has in the past been accepted as normal, and in fact, thought to be an inevitable part of the order-to-delivery cycle. Yet, the negative effect on business
performance is often found in excess inventories, quality problems, higher raw material
costs, overtime expenses and shipping costs. In the worst-case scenario, customer service
goes down, lead times lengthen, sales are lost, costs go up and capacity is adjusted. An
important element to operating a smooth flowing supply chain is to mitigate and preferably eliminate the “Bullwhip Effect”.

Lee et al. (1997) discussed four possible causes of the bullwhip effect: demand forecast updating, order batching, price fluctuation, and rationing and shortage gaming. Demand forecast updating suggests that demand amplification occurs due to the safety stock and long lead time. As orders are forecasted and transmitted along the supply chain, the safety stocks are built up, and thus the bullwhip effect occurs.
Material requirements planning or economics of transportation require companies to order goods at certain times. This periodic batching causes surges in demand at a particular time period, followed by the periods of time with no or little orders, and other
time periods with huge demands. Price fluctuation, which usually results from price
discount or promotion, also distorts buying pattern and creates bigger variability of
demand and demand lumpiness. Finally, when demand significantly exceeds supply,
manufacturers often ration products to their customers based on what they order.
Recognizing this rationing policy, the customers place orders larger and more frequently than what they really need with a hope of getting more products.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Bullwhip Effect In Supply Chain Networks." 123HelpMe.com. 06 Apr 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Designing An Efficient Supply Chain Network Essay

- Designing an efficient supply chain network ( SCN ) has always been a challenge for researchers . The importance of supply chain network design ( SCND ) was recognized already in the early 1970s [ ] . The goal of the most supply chain optimization problems is to minimize the total cost of the whole supply chain ( SC ) . However , industries are now subject to legislative and societal pressures to improve the environmental performance of their activities . The growing awareness of supply chain environmental aspects is now greatly recognized by academic and industrial communities [ ] ....   [tags: Supply chain management, Supply chain, Management]

Research Papers
861 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about The International Supply Chain Management

- 4.782 International Supply Chain Management Group Assignment Zhou, Chi 20141533 Wang, Anqi 20142345 Word Count: 1. The theories of the game include supply chain management (Simchi-Levi, D. and Y. Zhao, 2003), supply network (Nigel Slack, Stuart Chambers, Robert Johnston, 2010), inventory management, reorder points (Wright, 2015), and Bullwhip effect (Wright, 2015). The game has 4 levels of supply chain: factory, distribution, wholesaler and retailer. The products could not be supplied over level....   [tags: Supply chain management, Inventory, Supply chain]

Research Papers
923 words (2.6 pages)

Supply Chain And Its Effect On Inventory Management Essay

- Results Inventory serves a useful purpose in the supply chain. That said, firms can help minimize the need for inventory by carefully managing those factors that drive inventory levels up.Inventory items can be divided into two main types: Independent demand and dependent demand items. The systems for managing these two types if inventory differ significantly.The two classic systems for managing independent demand inventory are periodic review and perpetual review systems. In this research the framework was applied to current companies, however the framework can be applied to other industries as well, because at other organisations the same main basic processes take place within inventory ma...   [tags: Inventory, Supply chain management, Supply chain]

Research Papers
912 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Supply Structure Of A Supply Chain Network

- A supply chain network is the sequence of processes that are entailed in the production and distribution of goods. In the modern business environment, companies are relying on their strategic supply networks to deliver their products to the potential clients’ place of convenience. Before organizations focus on supply chain management, the business leaders have one main task of determining what the entire chain encompasses. A clear definition of the required supply mechanisms enables companies to have their goods delivered to the customers in good time, and in good shape....   [tags: Supply chain management, Management, Supply chain]

Research Papers
2345 words (6.7 pages)

Essay on How Supply Chain Management Is Important For The Survival

- Supply Chain Management is important for the survival as well as growth of an Industry. SCM helps in eradication of the communication barrier there is and allows the information to flow in an organized way. It also helps reduce the prolixity by coordinating, monitoring & controlling processes. As a Process, SCM covers the point of origin to point of consumption which means that SCM will take care of the production to sales to make sure the demands of the customer are met and the customer is satisfied....   [tags: Supply chain management, Supply chain, Management]

Research Papers
1200 words (3.4 pages)

What Is Supply Chain Management? Essay

- What is Supply Chain Management. This essay is about defining “what is supply chain management.” We will look into the different areas of a supply chain and the way they are managed. We will also study the way supply chains work on an international level. A supply chain is defined as the process that encompasses production from the raw materials all the way to the end customer. Supply chain management focuses on the overall flow and integrates the supply and demand management across the companies whom are involved in the specific supply chain, in order to deliver customer value at the lowest cost (Blanchard, 2010)....   [tags: Management, Supply chain management]

Research Papers
956 words (2.7 pages)


- The conclusion from the research of this paper indicates that social networks sites are here to stay. Social network sites need to convey a sense of responsibility. Based on the increasing level of social sites engaging in ecommerce, communication and socialization, the need of privacy protection is passed on to individuals. What this research paper has demonstrated is that there are implications users need to be aware of before signing up and placing their profile on these social network sites....   [tags: Social Networks]

Research Papers
837 words (2.4 pages)

Introduction Of Supply Chain Management Essay

- Introduction Supply chain management has been defined as that process that involves the management of information, materials, and all the finances that are handled within and across the entire supply chain process (Christopher, 2016). The management is usually done through out the entire supply chain management from that moment when the suppliers are involved through all the manufacturing activities, different distribution activities, and the way that the products are served to the final product consumer (Turban, et al., 2002)....   [tags: Supply chain management, Management]

Research Papers
925 words (2.6 pages)

Essay Complex Supply Chain Networks And Supply Chain Drivers

- Complex Supply Chain Networks and Supply Chain Drivers: Abstract The analyst in the Distribution, Engineering, Maintenance, and Productions Management Group of the Central Engineering Department for Canbide Corporation is in charge of analyzing various operations at all of Canbide’s facilities. The purpose of our group is to analyze operations, report our findings, and make recommendations for continued improvements and implementations of Operations Management (OM) tools. The remainder of this report summarizes our findings and recommendations on three of our electronics facilities located in Oregon....   [tags: Operations Management]

Free Essays
1713 words (4.9 pages)

Unco-Ordinated Supply Chain Essay

- Over the past years, supply chain and social network analysis have been handled as two independent fields within different organizations. Supply chain refers to the collaborated decision making among vertical and horizontal stakeholders in subsequent value addition of products. Study on supply and value chains proposes the need for efficient information exchange and resource allocation among different tiers of the network. On the other hand, social network analysis gives the feasible connections, physical as well as virtual, between various organizations involved in the chain....   [tags: network, chain, resources, modeling]

Research Papers
1382 words (3.9 pages)

This tendency is similar to excessive ordering without fully considering the orders that have been placed before but not yet received, resulting in distorted demand information. The arguments of Lee et al. are different from those of the two previous researchers in that they no longer blame the irrational behavior of decision makers for the bullwhip effect.

Research methodology
The research methodology used in this study involves computer simulation and statistical
analyses. While the purpose of computer simulation is to obtain data for the order quantities placed by each of the echelons in a supply chain, the statistical technique is to
analyze the obtained data and present findings related to the research objectives.
Simulation using computer software, simulation models for the beer distribution game is used represent supply chains.
The beer distribution game, which was developed by the Systems Dynamics Group at the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology in the 1960s, demonstrates the bullwhip effect by
simulating a make-to-stock supply chain with four tiers. Participants of the beer distribution game take the role of either the retailer, the wholesaler, the distributor or the factory(Figure 1).
An end customers places orders at the retailer of the supply chain. His demand pattern is
given, but unknown to the participants. The retailer is asked for four units during the first five and for eight units during the following periods of the simulation. The co-makers up the supply chain receive orders from their customers and decide – based on their current stock situation, the products in transport, which will reach their stock within the next periods, and the orders they received – how much to order from their supplier for replenishment. This way, information on the end customer demand is passed on up the supply chain with a delay of one period of time at each tier.
Material is forwarded in the other direction – down the supply chain. The material flow is
delayed as well: Material has to be transported and it has to pass materials receiving. Therefore it takes two periods until material received from a supplier can be delivered to a customer from stock at each co-maker.
The goal is to minimise the over-all logistics costs of the simulated supply chain. A product on stock costs $1 per period. If a co-maker cannot deliver, this causes costs of $2 per product per period. Thus co-makers have to take into account a trade-off between minimizing the cost of capital employed in stocks on the one hand and avoiding of out-of-stock situations, on the other hand.
Figure 1


Values of the variables representing each of the causes of the Bullwhip Effect.


Level of order magnification in the Supply Chain
A demand amplification factor, a ratio of the maximum change in factory output to the maximum change in end-customer demand, was chosen to measure the level of order amplification. For instance, suppose that peak order quantities at the factory and the end-customer are 32 and 8, respectively, and that the initial order quantities for both factory and end-customer are four each.
In this case, the amplification factor is (32 - 4)/(8 - 4) = 7.


Lee, L. H.; Padmanabhan, V.; Whang, S.: The Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chains, Sloan
Management Review, Spring 1997

Simchi-Levi, D.; Kaminsky, P.; Simchi-Levi, E: Designing and Managing the Supply
Chain. Concepts, Strategies, and Case Studies, Irwin McGraw-Hill, 2000

Sterman, J.D.: Teaching takes off : Flight simulators for management education.
OR/MS Today, 1992, 19(5) 40-44

Forrester, J. :Industrial Dynamics: A major breakthrough for decision makers.
Harvard Business Review. 1958. 36 37-66

Rachel Croson; Karen Donohue: Behavioral Causes of the Bullwhip Effect and the Observed Value of Inventory. Management Science; Mar 2006 pg. 323

Seung-Kuk Paik; Analysis of the Causes of Bullwhip Effect in a Supply Chain: A Simulation Approach. Dissertation - George Washington University, 2003.

Seung-Kuk Paik, Prabir K. Bagchi : Understanding the causes of the bullwhip effect in a Supply Chain. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, Vol. 35, No. 4, 2007. 308-324
R. Michael Donovan : Supply Chain Management: Cracking The Bullwhip Effect

Kefeng Xu; Yan Dong : Information Gaming in Demand Collaboration and Supply Chain Performance.
Journal of Business Logistics; 2004; 25, 1; ABI/INFORM Global

Buchmeister, B.: Investigation of the Bullwhip Effect using Spreadsheet Simulation.

F. Robert Jacobs: Playing the Beer Distribution Game over the Internet.
Production and Operations Management, Vol. 9, No. 1, 2000.

Jörg Nienhaus: What is the Bullwhip Effect Caused By ? – Study based on the Beer Distribution Game.
Supply Chain World Europe, 2002.
Return to 123HelpMe.com