Born Into Brothels, By Zana Briski And Susan Sontag 's On The Pain Of Others

Born Into Brothels, By Zana Briski And Susan Sontag 's On The Pain Of Others

Length: 1072 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There are many ways to get a point across or tell a story, but the ones that are mainly used are photographs and narratives. The differences between these two are in the details because they both tell a story. When you tell a story with a photograph you tend to add filters. Sometimes you even choose to capture only a certain part of the story with absolutely no context surrounding it. However, with a narrative you are able to go into complete detail, be it personal or factual, as well as be able to describe all of the story by also giving stories and examples. We see examples of this in the film “Born into Brothels” by Zana Briski and Susan Sontag’s “Regarding the Pain of Others.” Narrative is more important than image because it’s been shown that photographs lose their shock value, but a well narrated story will keep producing an emotional response no matter how many times is been told.
In Sontag’s “Regarding the Pain of Others” she states that in Canada they would have horrendous pictures of smokers lungs on cigarette boxes, this would completely disgust the buyer. However she also mentioned that this shock and disgust would only last a while and they would eventually go back to smoking. (62) Actually, I have seen these images floating around on social media Sites and they are usually photo shopped with pastel colors and glitter with the word “kawaii” which means cute in Japanese on the box; it seems that our current generation of smokers has become completely apathetic about our health. Compared to the gore, horror, the fictional situations and real situations on TV, a picture of yellow and rotting teeth won’t affect people anymore. Seeing the ads in the train about a woman who had to get her fingers amputated shocks me at fi...


... middle of paper ...


...tates that the Japanese did during the retelling of the forty seven Ronin; this story touches people because it is part of their culture and history as well as the fact that the different ways of it being told is still able to produce tears and pain in people’s hearts. (62)
Photographs are able to give many points of view as well but by changing the lighting it could seem to have been shot at a different time of day; change the angle and it could look like a completely different thing. Although these two combined would make a great story, photographs alone aren’t always enough or reliable; they could be taken out of context and misinterpreted by the public. Because the fact that photographs are easier and have many ways of being manipulated, they don’t really apply to the ethos, pathos and logos of a narrative, which is why a narrative is more important to a story.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Born into Brothels a Documentary by Zana Briski

- ... Additionally, searching for political and economic solutions to the issues that force families into Sonagachi in the first place would help them build a foundation for change. For instance, providing social supports to farmers and agricultural workers may reduce urbanization, which can lead to prostitution when employment opportunities are limited. Solutions to such problems would limit the need for children to make economic contributions, which can give more children the opportunity to get an education....   [tags: children, zonagachi, child savings]

Better Essays
1192 words (3.4 pages)

Documentary Film Analysis: Born Into Brothels Directed by Zana Briski and Ross Kauffman

- This paper examines the criticisms on the highly acclaimed documentary Born Into Brothels directed by Zana Briski and Ross Kauffman. This film follows Briski’s attempt to save a group of children from Sonagachi by teaching photography and efforts of registering these children into boarding schools. This paper is divided in two major sections; the first portion discusses whether or not it is essential to remove these children from their homes in order to rescue them from their lives in the red light district in India....   [tags: cultures, criticism, Partha Banerjee]

Better Essays
1099 words (3.1 pages)

Pain - Merely A Response To A Painful Stimulus? Essay

- Critically evaluate the view that pain is merely a response to a painful stimulus.   Pain Essay: unit 3 There are various definitions of pain. The most commonly agreed upon seems to be “an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience arising from actual or potential tissue damage or described in terms of such damage” The most appropriate definition of pain within clinical practice was suggested by Margo McCaffrey in (1968). His definition was ‘whatever the experiencing person says it is, existing whenever he says it does’ Pain is an abhorrent feeling that is transported to the brain by sensory neurons....   [tags: Pain]

Better Essays
2061 words (5.9 pages)

Essay on When You Are Born a Hermaphrodite

- ... Scientist insist on giving every condition a terminology which creates the separation amongst individuals. The ignorance of scientist is the reason why these individuals feel as if they are excluded from the normal world. Scientist cannot fix or even try to manipulate the sexual preference of a human body. Inter-sex individuals do not need from any surgical fixing, what they need is a little bit of comprehension from society to accept natures mysterious ways, and respect the decision of inter-sex individuals of choosing whatever gender they want to become....   [tags: being born with both sex organs]

Better Essays
1303 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Pain Assessment And Treatment Of Pain

- The most common reason that people seek medical care is pain, and pain is the leading cause of disability (Peterson & Bredow, 2013, p. 51; National Institute of Health, 2010). Pain is such an important topic in healthcare that the United States congress “identified 2000 to 2010 as the Decade of Pain Control and Research” (Brunner L. S., et al., 2010, p. 231). Unfortunatelly, patients are reporting a small increase in satisfaction with the pain management while in the hospital (Bernhofer, 2011)....   [tags: Pain, Suffering, Pain management, Perception]

Better Essays
1646 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Jane Woolf And Susan Sontag

- There has always been women who have defied the social gender norms. Throughout the years outspoken women have used their platforms to communicate their points of view. Sontag first starts off by stating that Greeks value the beauty of a woman and that it is a virtue. Sontag continues to mention how Greeks distinguished a person 's inner beauty to their outer beauty. It is directly associated with how today 's society will perceive outer beauty more than the inner kind. History has taught us that women have struggled for centuries, and that their intelligence was always overshadowed by their appearance....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Woman, Transgender]

Better Essays
888 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on The Pain Of Others By Susan Sontang

- Regarding the Pain of Others It was not until the 19th century that a very powerful tool was examine in depth by different viewers, photographic images. In the depression years, war was not seen by others as what war really is, and or what war can do. Some perceived war as an act of heroic action, and were not really aware of the pain that war brought to others remotely. Photographs were and continue to be visual representations of current and history events. In Regarding the Pain of Others, written by Susan Sontang....   [tags: Gender, Male, Female, Sex]

Better Essays
752 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Pain And Emotional State Of Pain

- Pain therapy Pain is an unpleasant experience, a signal that something is wrong and a demand for immediate change. According to recent updates of the medical model, pain is rather created by the brain than passively perceived as specific information about pain that arrives from the body. The process of perception of pain and emotions has a similar neurological path and activates similar brain regions. The pain is perceived as a feeling by the emotional brain, and the outcome is conjointly negotiated and decided with the cognitive brain, a similar process as for the emotions....   [tags: Pain, Suffering, Mind, Psychology]

Better Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

Pain, Suffering, And Pain Essays

- When I hear the word “Pain,” I believe that someone is hurting. Pain can be physical or emotional. Pain is defined in Merriam Webster’s dictionary as “the physical feeling caused by disease, injury, or something that hurts the body, mental or emotional suffering or sadness resulting from some emotional or psychological problem, someone or something that causes trouble or makes someone feel annoyed or angry.” The word pain originates in the late 13th century from Old French peine meaning “difficulty, woe, suffering, punishment,” from Latin poena means “punishment, penalty, retribution,” and from Greek poine “retribution, penalty” (Pain, n.d)....   [tags: Pain, Suffering, Emotion, Patient]

Better Essays
801 words (2.3 pages)

Jim Morrison and Susan Sontag Essay

- Jim Morrison and Susan Sontag Jim Morrison is the lead singer of the classic rock and roll band "The Doors". Jim Morrison not only was the lead vocalist in the famous sixties band, he was also the writer of most but not all of The Doors songs and the author of many poems. Susan Sontag is an accomplished author. Some of Susan Sontag's works include essays, reviews, editing, novels and short stories. Although at first Jim Morrison and Susan Sontag appear to have nothing or very little in common, both because of Jim Morrison's main influence coming from author Friedrich Nietzsche, who believed in existentialism (a body of ethical thought centering about the uniqueness and isolation of individ...   [tags: History]

Free Essays
1610 words (4.6 pages)