Boot Camps: A Good Way to Deter Youth Offenders in Queensland? Essay

Boot Camps: A Good Way to Deter Youth Offenders in Queensland? Essay

Length: 1283 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In recent years, the Queensland Government along with other states in Australia have discarded the idea of using court-referred conferencing, instead choosing to follow other avenues for the rehabilitation of youth offenders. One of these avenues is the controversial use of boot camps. Within Queensland specifically, there has been a strong wave of both media and public support for the use of these camps, with much research being conducted to examine whether they are a useful avenue to follow. The use of boot camps has been controversial in many countries around the world, such as the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom and this paper will examine whether these controversial camps would be a good way to deter youth offenders within Queensland. With the introduction of the Youth Justice (Boot Camp Orders) 2012 Amendment bill it was hoped that the youth would have a real chance at rehabilitation and develop the skills to make good life choices (Carrington, Dwyer, Hutchinson & Richards, 2012). By using social control theory, it can be seen that if a youth offender is released from a boot camp, they will have to be entering back into a society where they will have four specific social bonds, attachment, commitment, involvement and belief that will keep them from reoffending (Agnew, 1985).
Boot camps first came about in the 1980’s as an alternative way to rehabilitate people with a mixture of both military and non-military aspects without incarcerating them in prison (Muscar, 2008). There are many promising non-military aspects of boot camps that help to rehabilitate a person and mentally prepare them for going back into their situations before the boot camp, such as the close relationships formed between the staff and inmat...

... middle of paper ...

Harry, J. (1999). PENNSYLVANIA BOOT CAMP PROVES SUCCESSFUL. Corrections Today, 61(6), 12.
Kempinen, C., & Kurlychek, M. (2003). An outcome evaluation of Pennsylvania's boot camp: Does rehabilitative programming within a disciplinary setting reduce recidivism?. Crime \& Delinquency, 49(4), 581--602.
Muscar, J. (2008). Advocating the End of Juvenile Boot Camps: Why the Military Model Does Not Belong in the Juvenile Justice System. UC Davis J. Juv. L. \& Pol'y, 12, 1.
Parent, D. (2003). Correctional Boot Camps: Lessons From a Decade of Research Series: Research for Practice.
REID-MacNEVIN, S. (1997). Boot Camps for Young Offenders A Politically Acceptable Punishment.Journal Of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 13(2), 155--171.
Steiner, B., & Giacomazzi, A. (2007). Juvenile waiver, boot camp, and recidivism in a northwestern state. The Prison Journal, 87(2), 227--240.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Should Prison Be Boot Camp Programs More Effective At Reduce Recidivism Rates Of Offenders?

- ... These institutions do not share the same success rate nor are conducted in the same manner. In the 90s boot camp programs rolled out all across the nation Stinchcomb and Terry (2001). This was widely viewed by the corrections department as an alternative way to house the masses that were being incarcerated. High incarceration rates at these times were due to getting “tough on crime laws” and “mandatory minimums”. The tax payers were very interested in this alternative option of serving time Stinchcomb and Terry (2001)....   [tags: Prison, Recidivism, Penology, Corrections]

Strong Essays
1281 words (3.7 pages)

The Affects of Boot Camps on Juveniles Essay

- In 2005, 14-year-old Martin Lee Anderson from was sentenced to probation after taking a joy ride with his stolen grandmothers car. Later that year, he violated his probation after trespassing on school grounds. His parents were given two options, either sending him to a juvenile detention center or boot camp. They chose boot camp as the better rehabilitation program, in hoping to change their son. Anderson lasted three hours at the Florida's Bay County Sheriff's Boot Camp before collapsing and being sent to the hospital, where he was declared dead the next morning....   [tags: Juvenile Boot Camps]

Strong Essays
1452 words (4.1 pages)

Juvenile Boot Camps Do Not Reduce Juvenile Delinquency Essay

- Introduction Juvenile delinquency is a relatively new phenomenon. For this reason, society’s reactions and solutions to the problem of delinquency are also modern developments. The United States developed the first youth court in 1899 and is now home to many new and formerly untested methods of juvenile rehabilitation and correction. One of many unique programs within the Juvenile Justice system, boot camps are institutions designed to keep delinquent juveniles out of traditional incarceration facilities and still provide a structured method of punishment and rehabilitation....   [tags: Boot Camps Do Not Reduce Recidivism]

Strong Essays
2996 words (8.6 pages)

Hope for Rehabilitation for Institutionalized Youth Offenders Essay

- “You do the crime, you pay the time,” is a common phrase uttered throughout our society in regard to juvenile delinquency. It has been suggested that a punitive response to the problem of youth violence in America is an effective means of solving the issue of youth crime, and would also deter future offenders. As a result, the existence of rehabilitation strategies within the system available to offenders is under threat. A harsh and punitive response to youth violence was, in part, brought about by a moral panic across America....   [tags: Essays Papers Juvenile Delinquency]

Strong Essays
4620 words (13.2 pages)

Boot Camps and Juvenile Crime Essay

- Boot Camps and Juvenile Crime Five years ago, responding to an increase in serious juvenile crime, the state of Maryland initiated one of the nation's largest boot camp programs for teenage criminals. The program, called the Leadership Challenge, quickly became the model for other states. But last week, after reviewing a task force report that documented instances of physical abuse at their camps, Maryland officials appeared on the verge of conceding that the current initiative was a failure. Military-style discipline may work as punishment at juvenile boot camps, but it has not been effective as rehabilitation....   [tags: Juvenile Crime Boot Camps Incarceration Essays]

Strong Essays
1134 words (3.2 pages)

Teenage Boot Camps - Not The Way To Achieve Discipline Essay

- Boot camps for teenagers have become a popular disciplinary option for parents with adolescent children. Often recommended by counselors or by state justice systems as an alternative to juvenile detention centers, the boot camps are rigid military environments. Some are wilderness camps that teach young people survival skills in a military-like setting, while others are held closer to home. Many are state-run in conjunction with the justice system but many are also privately owned and operated. The boot camps have come under intense scrutiny because of suspicions of abuse and because dozens of teenagers have died of preventable causes at the camps....   [tags: Behavior Modification, Teens]

Strong Essays
956 words (2.7 pages)

Boot Camps Essay

- Boot Camps The history and explanation of how these institutions are operated The increase in violent behavior amongst America's youth has prompted the implementation of more effective rehabilitation methods. With the percentage of non-violent offenders on the rise, prison incarceration or juvenile detention doesn't seem to be the right solution for rehabilitation. In December 1983 a new idea emerged in Giorgia. This new idea was shock incarceration or boot camp. These temporary institutions were the beginnings of a trend to try and help with the rehabilitation efforts of young offenders....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
957 words (2.7 pages)

Juvenile Boot Camps Essay example

- Juvenile Boot Camps Juvenile boot camps have been emerging more and more over the United States throughout the most recent years. At the rate they keep appearing, they seem as though they are here to stay. However, that might not be the truth quite yet. Several groups believe that they appear to be efficient and supportive to the youth at question. But the public foresees boot camps as senseless and inadequate....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
613 words (1.8 pages)

Essay on Boot Camp - Shock Incarceration Programs are Useful

- Boot Camp - Shock Incarceration Programs are Useful In the military, boot camp represents an abrupt, often shocking transition to a new way of life. Discipline is strict and there is an emphasis on hard work, physical training, and unquestioning obedience to authority. The new private is told when to sleep, when to get up and when to eat. He marches with his platoon everywhere he goes such as to meals and to training. Orders must be obeyed instantly and personal liberty is almost nonexistent. By the end of boot camp the new private has become a different person....   [tags: Offenders Alternative Jail Prison]

Free Essays
2293 words (6.6 pages)

Boot Camp Essay examples

- Boot Camp With the ever rising prison population in this country, something has to be done rehabilitate criminals rather than just lock them up. Many feel that the “new” prisons, boot camps are the answer (Champion 1990). I will give a brief overview of boot camp institutions, specifically, about the operation and structure of these, the cost involved with both juvenile and adult facilities, and how effective they really are with regard to recidivism. Boot camps or shock incarceration programs, as they are also called, vary greatly around the country....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1402 words (4 pages)