The Birthmark And Girl By Jamaica Kincaid Essay

The Birthmark And Girl By Jamaica Kincaid Essay

Length: 1594 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A person’s beliefs and actions do not form by themselves, rather it is created and influenced by the people and society surrounding them, which is an issue presented in both The Birthmark by Nathaniel Hawthorne and Girl by Jamaica Kincaid. In both stories of The Birthmark and Girl, they share the same theme of how perfection does not equal happiness, which can be observed through the inescapable relationship, the final results to both stories and through the analysis of feminist criticism.
To begin with, both texts are situated with characters that deal with inescapable relationships, such as husband and wife or mother and daughter. Ironically, both stories share the similarity that it is their loved one, who pressures them to change. In The Birthmark, Aylmer, the husband is the one who pressures his wife, Georgiana, into removing the birthmark on her face, so that she can become truly beautiful. This is first brought up when he asks her if she has “ever considered that the mark on [her] cheek might be removed?” (Hawthorne 341) and with that, he consistently hints throughout the text, without directly saying to Georgiana, that she needs to remove the birthmark. He later goes on to explain himself by saying that the mark does not suit her face, and how “[she] came so nearly to perfection from the hand of Nature, that this slightest possible defect” is a sign of “earthly imperfection” (Hawthorne 341). By doing this, he persuades her in a cruel way to remove the birthmark, in reasons not only satisfy him, but to show her that the mark overpowers her beauty. Hence, even though the wife portrays herself as being content with her mark, by explaining how it “has so often been called a charm” (Hawthorne 341) to the point that she believes...


... middle of paper ...


...ich reflects greatly on the ending of both stories.
Overall, both literary texts imply that perfection is the centre of happiness, as The Birthmark aims to make Georgiana flawlessness, while in Girl, the mother strives to change her daughter to satisfy her ideal image of a respectable women. By analyzing both texts through the theme of perfection and how it is not equivalent to happiness, a person manages to get a closer view of the truth behind the idea of perfection, as it observes the type of relationship, the end result after achieving what they want and the impacts of society through a feminist approach. Therefore, both stories demonstrate the lesson that instead of trying to force another person into becoming someone they are not, a person should love who they are because attempting to become “perfect” does not always lead to a better and happier life.





Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Kate Chopin And The Girl By Jamaica Kincaid

- The Comparison “The Strom” By Kate Chopin and “The Girl by Jamaica Kincaid Throughout history writers have offered readers lessons through themes and often symbolized. In the story, “The Storm” by Kate Chopin is quite different from “The Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid; both have a different theme, symbol, throughout the stories. “The Storm” in Kate Chopin 's story can symbolize a number of different things: temporary, fleeting and quick action, and without consequences. Kate Chopin was born February 8, 1850 in St....   [tags: Symbol, Symbolism, Jamaica Kincaid, Emotion]

Strong Essays
801 words (2.3 pages)

The Poem Girl by Jamaica Kincaid Essay

- The poem "Girl" by author Jamaica Kincaid shows love and family togetherness by creating microcosmic images of the way mothers raise their children in order to survive. Upon closer examination, the reader sees that the text is a string of images in Westerner Caribbean family practices. Jamaica Kincaid has taken common advice that daughters are constantly hearing from their mothers and tied them into a series of commands that a mother uses to prevent her daughter from turning into "the slut that she is so bent on becoming" (380)....   [tags: Poetry, Poem, Jamaica Kincaid]

Strong Essays
816 words (2.3 pages)

Essay Comparing Girl by Jamaica Kincaid and A&P by John Updike

- Comparing Girl by Jamaica Kincaid and A&P by John Updike Within every story or poem, there is always an interpretation made by the reader, whether right or wrong. In doing so, one must thoughtfully analyze all aspects of the story in order to make the most accurate assessment based on the literary elements the author has used. Compared and contrasted within the two short stories, “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid, and John Updike’s “A&P,” the literary elements character and theme are made evident. These two elements are prominent in each of the differing stories yet similarities are found through each by studying the elements....   [tags: Girl Jamaica Kincaid A&P John Updike Essays]

Strong Essays
1222 words (3.5 pages)

`` Girl `` By Jamaica Kincaid Essays

- Always listen to mother. Mother knows everything. Mother is always right. In Jamaica Kincaid’s short story “Girl”, smothering motherly advice is present through Kincaid’s use of a stern tone and a “how-to” format, providing instructions from an overbearing mother to her daughter on how she should live and behave as a young woman. These instructions, along with the stern tone, highlight the mother’s experience as a repressed woman and her skewed knowledge of what it means to be a female in society....   [tags: Woman, Girl, Family, Female]

Strong Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Jamaica, By Jamaica. Jamaica Essay

- Jamaica Kincaid Jamaica Kincaid was born Elaine Potter Richardson on May 25, 1949 in St. John’s, Antigua (“Jamaica,” Caribbean). A Caribbean writer hailed, “A significant voice in contemporary literature,” (qtd. in “Jamaica,” Encyclopedia) she is well known for her personal and honest works of short fiction, novels and essays (“Jamaica,” Encyclopedia). In her work, Kincaid “explores the tenuous relationship between mother and daughter as well as themes of anti-colonialism,” (qtd. in “Jamaica,” Encyclopedia) and has been a contributor to the literary world for decades (“Jamaica,” Encyclopedia)....   [tags: Fiction, Short story, Jamaica Kincaid, Antigua]

Strong Essays
829 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The Story ' Girl ' By Jamaica Kincaid

- ... The mother wants the best for the girl and teaches her what is the proper way to act as a lady to be successful in her culture in this time period. “This is how…” (Kincaid 163) is repeated over and over throughout the story showing a regimented life. She explains how to do everything to minute detail. She gives orders on how to cook, how to clean, how to fix hems, how to talk to boys, how to treat her husband, what to do in case a baby is not wanted, what to do to bully a man and how to smile to others....   [tags: Fiction, Narrative, Short story, Sociology]

Strong Essays
1010 words (2.9 pages)

Analysis Of Jamaica Kincaid 's ' Girl ' Essay

- Girl by Jamaica Kincaid demonstrate how a mother cautions her daughter, in becoming a responsible woman in her society. Although the daughter hasn’t gotten into adolescence yet, the mother fears that her daughter’s current behavior, if continued, will tip to a life of promiscuity. The mother believes that a woman’s status or propriety determines the quality of her life in the community. Hence, gender roles, must be carefully guarded to maintain a respectable front. Her advice centers on how to uphold responsibility....   [tags: Gender role, Woman, Gender, Sociology]

Strong Essays
1705 words (4.9 pages)

Analysis Of The Story ' Girl ' By Jamaica Kincaid Essay

- ... They work together as a team to insure everything is cared for. On the other hand, you have families who function just as families did back in the 1900’s where the women takes care of all of the cleaning, laundry, cooking, and childcare needs. Not because that 's how the world works anymore, but because some women choose for that to be their role in society. Although men are taking on more rolls, there are still some rolls the majority of people still consider to be a women’s job. A few years back, I went to an interview for a nanny position, the family told me that, as many do, they were looking for a female candidate because they didn 't want a male watching over their children....   [tags: Woman, Family, Gender role, Gender]

Strong Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of The Story ' Girl ' By Jamaica Kincaid

- If you had told someone 100 years ago woman will have the write to vote, be world scholars, serve in the military, or even run for president they probably would of laughed in your face and told you women are good for one thing and one thing only, and that is to be a wife and a mother. Women were meant to be seen and not heard. They were to cook, clean, do laundry, be the perfect wife, and tend to all their husbands needs. In the story “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid, a mother is talking to her daughter about all of the things that a respectful lady does....   [tags: Woman, Family, Gender role, Gender]

Strong Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

Analysis Of The Story ' Girl ' By Jamaica Kincaid Essay examples

- Even though women are still the main homemakers, being the nurturer and the one in charge of keeping their family life running smoothly, men have started to take on some of the roles that were once only expected of women, making for a whole new dynamic in the average home. If you had told someone 100 years ago women would have the right to vote, or could be world scholars, serve in the military, or even run for president, they probably would have laughed in your face and told you women are good for one thing, and one thing only, and that is to be a wife and a mother....   [tags: Woman, Family, Man, Gender role]

Strong Essays
1314 words (3.8 pages)