The Appropriateness of the Victorian Renaming of the Play “Malvolio” Essay

The Appropriateness of the Victorian Renaming of the Play “Malvolio” Essay

Length: 1256 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When compared to Shakespeare’s other comedies, ‘Twelfth Night’ can be said to be the darkest. As the last of his comedies, it fits that ‘Twelfth Night’ would be progressively darker, ending not on a note of true happiness but rather one of melancholy that strives to emphasize that “that’s all one” and therefore insignificant. Though it fits comic tradition with slapstick humour, unrequited courtly love, confusion, potential for tragedy but ultimately a happy ending, ‘Twelfth Night’ is prevailingly dark, showing the flaws in a society living for pleasure and determined to indulge in ‘cakes and ale’. There is no middle ground; the puritan views of Malvolio are seen as ‘self love’ and the indulgence of Orsino as ‘high fantastical’. This would indicate that in the world of Illyria the only way for characters to maintain a semblance of self is in fantasy and imagination as reality is cruel. Continual references to ‘mad’ and ‘madness’ (mentioned more times in ‘Twelfth Night’ than any of Shakespeare’s other plays) enforces the idea that Illyria is not a pleasant place, and that the inhabitants are ‘mad’ and therein malicious in their attempts to become ‘that selfsame king’, ‘nothing can come between me and the full prospect of my hopes’.
‘Malvolio’, meaning ‘I wish evil’, describes perfectly the tensions in ‘Twelfth Night’, especially in the sub-plot involving Maria and Sir Toby. Though Malvolio brings their dislike of him on himself, ‘he is sick of self love’, the way in which Sir Toby and Maria ‘revenge’ themselves on Malvolio seems unnecessarily cruel, ‘I will fool him black and blue’. Rather than stopping at foolery, Sir Toby is determined to cause physical harm, as if driving Malvolio to the near end of sanity is not enough. This...

... middle of paper ... does not seem as if the characters will simply live happily without continuing the cycle of revenge. Shakespeare shows the intricacies of humanity and in ‘Twelfth Night’ the dominance of the ‘darker’ side, echoing Freud in his belief that human nature consists of good overpowering bad, yet containing bad all the same. Even for the ‘all licensed fool’ there is very little happiness to be found in the ‘corruption’ of Illyria and ‘it’s all the same’ is significant as it shows hopelessness on the part of Feste regarding the activities in Illyria. The Victorian renaming of ‘Twelfth Night’ is therefore appropriate in that although in appearance it is a well meaning comedy, Shakespeare concluded that ‘Nothing that is so, is so’ and in the case of ‘Twelfth Night’ where ‘high fantastical’ is seated alongside ‘sick… self love’, ‘Malvolio’ embodies the spirit of the play.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Analysis of Malvolio in the Twelfth Night by Shakespeare

- The character of Malvolio is treated too cruelly for Twelfth Night to be classed as a comedy. Malvolio is constantly humiliated and has some of the major elements of a tragic character. The revenge served to him is extremist and is not an equal reaction to his behavior. Malvolio's puritan nature and extreme unwillingness to be social with his peers upsets certain characters more than others. Sir Toby and Maria show carelessness for his person as he has a strict adherence to rules, contrasting with their blatant disregard for rules and discipline this is conveyed through the line “Dost thou think, because thou art virtuous, there shall be no more cakes and ale?” Sir Toby mocks Malvolio's pur...   [tags: play, revenge, behavior, irony]

Strong Essays
1148 words (3.3 pages)

Malvolio in William Shakespeare's Twelfth Night Essay

- Malvolio in William Shakespeare's Twelfth Night The problem involving Malvolio in Twelfth Night has been known for a long time but still very difficult. The gist of it is this. A lot of modern readers or spectators feel that the way in which Malvolio is treated is extremely bad. We expect him to become the centre of humour; we know that in the business of comedy, a very puritanical and rather joyless figure is likely to receive comedic humiliation; but in this case the humiliation that Malvolio gets, seems protracted and harsh....   [tags: Malvolio William Shakespeare Twelfth Night Essays]

Strong Essays
576 words (1.6 pages)

Essay about The Punishment of Malvolio

- In Shakespeare’s play, Twelfth Night, the characters endure the fruits of their foolishness at the end of the play, but Malvolio endures a greater suffering and greater embarrassment than the rest of the characters. This is not simply by chance or whimsy: but this is Shakespeare’s stratification of the vices that a person may take upon him or herself. With this stratification, Shakespeare allocates Malvolio’s vices of pride, usurping the social order, and dour temperament as the worst of character flaws, and that is why Malvolio receives the harshest punishment....   [tags: Shakespearean Literature]

Strong Essays
1241 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Life of Malvolio in the Twelfth Night Play- Original Writing

- Life of Malvolio in the Twelfth Night Play- Original Writing Twelfth night is a comedy which means that the audience’s expectations are for a light hearted, humorous funny play. Usually in a comedy there is bawdy, lewd language and romantic liaisons. In the play there are also a lot of ridiculous and improbable coincidences which the audience only believe because of willing suspension of disbelief. The title Twelfth Night refers to the Christian feast of epiphany which occurs twelve nights after Christmas....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
978 words (2.8 pages)

William Shakespeare 's ' Malvolio ' Essay

- Malvolio spells out cut which was slang for the female genitalia, the meaning is compounded by referring to P’s. In fact these letters are not even on the outside of the letter. This is an example of both Malvolio’s stupidity and his uncouthness. It’s not certain whether Malvolio was meant to understand or if he is really that dense. Shakespeare, on the other hand, intentionally added the sexual joke because he wanted to undermine the Puritans. The example of the trickery played on Malvolio is several different types of humor in one....   [tags: Love, Comedy, Romance, Marriage]

Strong Essays
886 words (2.5 pages)

Malvolio: Undeserved Contempt? Essay

- Twelfth Night is written by William Shakespeare. It was named after a Christian feast of the Epiphany, which is celebrated on the 6th January (12 days after Christmas.) Twelfth Night is a comedy and a very entertaining play, surrounding the character Malvolio, who is very impolite and disrespectful to the rest of the characters. As a result to this they decide to trick him, but however it gets out of hand when they decide to lock him up and claim that he is mad. Malvolio then stands as an unpopular steward and a vulgar character....   [tags: Shakespearean Literature, Characters]

Strong Essays
2632 words (7.5 pages)

The Role of Malvolio in Twelfth Night Essay examples

- The Role of Malvolio in Twelfth Night The main storyline in Twelfth Night is love between Cesario, Orsino, Olivia and later on in the play Sebastian. Malvolio’s part in the play is a backdrop situation separate from the main story. He brings a level of both humour and sympathy to the play. Malvolio is one of the main sources of humour in Twelfth Night. In the later part of the play a different side of him is exposed. Malvolio is Olivia’s steward and his job is to manage Olivia’s house; he is her chief servant....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1551 words (4.4 pages)

Audience's Perceptions of Malvolio Essay

- Audience's Perceptions of Malvolio Malvolio is Olivia’s administrator. He is the one and only character in this play who ever seems to be making a mindful effort to be ‘honest’ but also the only one of the household who shows no genuine like towards fellow workers and masters. This immediately tells us that people are going to dislike him and, in a way try to get back at him. On the other hand, he is the only effective and with no doubt devoted employee. As a steward his main job is to manage Olivia’s household and arrange certain affairs....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1156 words (3.3 pages)

Essay Feeling Sympathy for Malvolio

- Feeling Sympathy for Malvolio Malvolio plays the role of Olivia’s self admiring butler. He takes advantage of his position in the house to abuse of those lower ranked in the house than him. These people are Sir Toby, Maria and Fabian, (Sir Andrew doesn’t work in the house). These people have got fed up of this and decide to get their own back throughout the play. The dispute is that may be they went too far. Malvolio is smart in appearance and well dressed. Apart from this, Malvolio is pompous, vane, arrogant and has a lack of forgiveness....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
945 words (2.7 pages)

Malvolio's Mistreatment in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night Essay

- Malvolio's Mistreatment in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night Although Malvolio is a pompous, arrogant, and vain character, I still think he was mistreated because he didn't deserve what he got from sir Toby, sir Andrew, Fabian, and Maria. What they did was too harsh on Malvolio and he didn't deserve it. Malvolio's soaring high opinion of himself makes him believe what he wants to, because of this he misunderstands everything Olivia says. When she orders him to 'go to bed' to sleep off his madness he believes she means to go to bed with her, 'I'll come to thee.' Olivia shows concern for her loyal servant and asks for 'special care' of her 'fellow.' Malvolio is a very bighea...   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1053 words (3 pages)