Anna, By Dr. Brown Essay

Anna, By Dr. Brown Essay

Length: 1689 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Anna is a 23-year-old woman who wants to give birth to a premature baby who is diagnosed with Down’s Syndrome while she has not yet graduated from university. She does not have any immediate family to help her and she may also have to drop out of university if the baby survives. Due to her personal circumstances, Dr. Brown insists on not providing medical treatment and allowing the infant to die naturally after birth. In Anna’s situation, Dr. Brown’s suggestion is based on his opinion of what he thinks is best for both the mother and baby. Dr. Brown feels as though Anna is making a poor decision and that her actions will be putting her education and potential strengths at stake and the baby may suffer from further impairments. Although Anna understands the responsibilities, she claims that she has the resources to raise her baby despite the child growing up severely impaired. Anna is optimistic and values the life of a human regardless of disabilities. Although Anna demonstrates these character traits, Dr. Brown is discouraged by the baby’s poor prognosis. Anna has multiple possible courses of action that include providing the infant with medical treatment or allowing her baby to die. I think Anna ought to save the baby through the use of medical treatment despite the risks and responsibilities.
The action that I disagree with is the action proposed by the physician, Dr. Brown. The moral theory that applies to Dr. Brown’s perspective is utilitarianism. Mill developed two characterizations of the principle of utility, known as “The Greatest Happiness Principle” (Collier & Haliburton, 2015, p. 9). The first characterization states that actions are only right if they promote happiness; however, they are wrong if they promote the opp...


... middle of paper ...


..., Anna’s decision is more morally justified. Virtue ethics takes emotion into consideration in two different ways. Emotions give individuals the reason to be virtuous, which means living well, and, therefore, happy. “Doing the right thing also means doing what we want to do” (Collier & Haliburton, 2015, p. 29). Anna wanted to save her baby in order to raise her child despite all the risks, and because she wanted to do this, she did the right thing on consenting to treatment. The second way is that virtue ethics does not only appear on certain days, but in everyday lives. Due to this, people are able to differentiate the special relationships between certain individuals. Anna is an example of a virtuous parent because she may not have the same perspective towards another in comparison to her own because a particular relationship has been acknowledged between the two.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Anna Harrison

- The wife of William Henry Harrison, the ninth President of the United States, Anna Harrison never assumed her duties as first lady, however, she did achieve many firsts among those who held this position. Not only was she the first in her position to receive a formal education, she was, at age 65, the oldest woman to become first lady. Because she was the first to become a widow while her husband was in office, Anna Harrison was the first former first lady to receive a pension. She was also the first to become the grandmother of a future President, Benjamin Harrison....   [tags: Biography]

Better Essays
751 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Feminism, By Anna Carastathis

- Intersectionality is the idea that women, especially of different race, class, or sexual orientation, experience discrimination in varying degrees. This means that a female of color or race is not discriminated against for being female and a certain race, but is discriminated against for being a female of a different race. For example, a white woman may receive more privileges than a Mexican woman, but both still are objectified against for being female. In the article “Intersectionality & Feminism” written by Anna Carastathis, she describes how in the past women of color in the workplace were put behind the men of color who were behind the need of the white woman....   [tags: Race, Racism, White people, Woman]

Better Essays
1146 words (3.3 pages)

Mother Daughter Bond By Anna Quindlen Essay

- ... So I can only see them once in three years. Growing up with “knowing that I have a mother and she is never around me whenever I need her” throughout my childhood, I identify with the author 's utter jealousy over the fact that she will never have that mother-daughter bond ever again, just as “ when I see a mother and a daughter having lunch in a restaurant, shopping at sakes, talking together on the crosstown bus, I no longer want to murder them” I can feel the jealousy and animosity and how much she want to have a mother and daughter relationship again....   [tags: Mother, Want, Need, 2006 singles]

Better Essays
721 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Film Analysis of Anna And The King

- Film Analysis of Anna And The King When we want to analyze a film, we must know what films represent. Film is the term we use to describe a particular material and medium of communication that has certain specific properties governed by certain physical laws…use to produce particular communicative texts that formulate particular fields of symbolic meaning and effects, and meet particular sets of criteria that give them particular value. (Sobchack et al, 1987, P.3). We need to investigate the films deeply so as to understand its explicit and implicit meanings....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1490 words (4.3 pages)

Influence of Trisha Brown and Steve Paxton on Modern Dance Essay

- The direct relationship in the artistic practices and methodologies of Trisha Brown and Steve Paxton played a role in facilitating new ways of appreciating and developing movement. Trisha Brown is considered to be one of the most pivotal choreographers of the 1960’s as her work and practice shifted away from historically considered “appropriate” movement for choreography. This ideology references the modern era of choreographers, moving away from the aesthetics of Martha Graham and Merce Cunningham who worked with codified techniques, virtuosity and expressionism, whereas Brown saw dance as being of greater importance to the physical and mental process of the performer....   [tags: Choreography, Dance, Perfoming Arts]

Better Essays
2275 words (6.5 pages)

Essay on Anna Julia Cooper

- Anna Julia Cooper "Only the BLACK WOMAN can say 'when and where I enter, in the quiet, undisputed dignity of my womanhood, without violence and without suing or special patronage, then and there the whole . . . race enters with me'" The life of Anna Julia Cooper (1858-1964) affords rich opportunities for studying the developments in African-American and Ameri can life during the century following emancipation. Like W.E.B. DuBois, Cooper's life is framed by especially momentous years in U.S. history: the final years of slavery and the climactic years of the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960's....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Better Essays
2460 words (7 pages)

Essay about Personal Experience: Cantonese and English Language

- A Mother’s Daughter I smelled different. I wasn’t allowed to shave my legs, I attended Chinese School for ten years, and my favorite meal consisted of a warm barbecue flavored pork atop a bowl of white rice. Still, I loved the fireworks on the Fourth of July. Still, I would swim in the public pool and eat blue popsicles in the summer. At home, my mother would speak Cantonese to me and I would respond in English. As an American-born girl of twelve in a predominately white town, we had a system. In public, I was the mother—checking out our library books, reading the labels on the packages of ground pork and beef in the supermarket....   [tags: Anna Karenina, mother]

Better Essays
529 words (1.5 pages)

Drowning Anna by Sue Mayfield Essay

- I read the book Drowning Anna by Sue Mayfield. It is a book about a girl who is forced to deal with a ruthless bully, Hayley Parkin. She also goes through heartbreak, backstabbing, and much more. Anna Goldsmith, the main character of my book, moves from a classy city in London, England, to a small Yorkshire town. At first, she is treated like a queen, mostly because of her movie-star good looks. She has beautiful black hair, and perfect, glowing skin. She is also an A student. She plays the in the orchestra and succeeds in everything that she does....   [tags: Drowning Anna, Sue Mayfield]

Better Essays
1211 words (3.5 pages)

Regaining Control in Anna Karenina Essay

- Regaining Control in Anna Karenina Anna Karenina features significant clusters of scenes, all of which describe notable moments in the development of the novel's major figures. One of the most important clusters is when Anna travels to see Vronsky. On her way her perceptions change; she throws her "searchlight" upon herself. Arriving at the next station she sees the rails and knows what must be done. Anna has had control over her own life taken away from her, due to the societal limitations on her choices as a woman....   [tags: Tolstoy Anna Karenina Essays]

Better Essays
2239 words (6.4 pages)

Foreshadowing in Anna Karenina Essay

- Foreshadowing in Anna Karenina Throughout life there are situations which arise that seem to have been hinted earlier. You might not have noticed the hint when it first appeared, but suddenly at one point it finally dawns on you. The same goes for the literary aspect of foreshadowing. The novel Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy has many instances where the situations are similar to the one described above. The following paragraphs will present the foreshadowing that is included in this novel....   [tags: Tolstoy Anna Karenina Essays]

Free Essays
478 words (1.4 pages)