Ambiguity And Uncertainty Of New Zealand 's Overall Constitutional System

Ambiguity And Uncertainty Of New Zealand 's Overall Constitutional System

Length: 1684 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Ambiguity and uncertainty characterise New Zealand’s overall constitutional system. Along with constitutional and administrative law. Nonetheless, the phrase, “The Queen reigns but the Government rules”, stands as an overlying solid summary of it. This phrase demonstrates that as a Constitutional Monarchy, the real power actually lies within government with the support of the House of Representatives (the executive). Nonetheless, New Zealand’s legal architecture and constitutional arrangements aim to uphold elements of democracy, equality and justice. Different aspects of the overall constitutional system both allow and limit the upholding of said elements. Overall, these aspects include the three fundamental principles that dominate New Zealand’s constitutional law, the current voting system that aims to endorse and display both representative and responsible government, the absence of a written constitution, the amendments and repeals that allow changes to be made to legislation and constitutional conventions that are not crystallized into law.

In order to prevent arbitrary power, administrative and constitutional law act as the legal architecture that supports New Zealand’s constitutional system. The New Zealand constitutional system relies on three main pillars. These pillars are the Rule of Law, Parliamentary Supremacy and the Separation of Powers. They are in place in order to ensure that the constitutional system upholds both democracy and justice in the relationship between the state and its citizens. The Rule of Law itself is a rather ambiguous concept that is defined differently by different scholars. Nonetheless, the essence of it is that it places constraints on arbitrary power. Parliamentary supremacy on the other h...


... middle of paper ...


...ible to always “do the right thing” due to the different views a person has on said notion. However, the separation of powers allows more chance of equality.



In conclusion, the statement does describe New Zealand’s legal architecture and constitutional arrangements accurately. However, the extent in which is adequate is questionable. Other factors than those that were listed in the statement give the legal architecture both strong and comprehensive qualities. On the other hand, whether the “direct application of democratic practice” is possible in any relationship between the state and citizen, is arguable. Regardless, it can be argued that it is skeletal in the sense that there are many ambiguities and uncertainties that plague the system. However, these ambiguities and uncertainties are required in order to uphold flexibility when it comes to applying the law.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Constitutional Interpretation Of The Constitution

- As the United States continues to develop in the context of the modern world, law and government is forced to adapt to new political ideologies and circumstances as they begin to emerge. This change in political ideologies and processes then leads to the questions regarding the application of the Constitution in what is known as constitutional interpretation. Since the Constitution’s official establishment in 1789, political figures have debated how to best interpret its provisions in determining the constitutionality of legal measures....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
753 words (2.2 pages)

Constitutional Framers vision and the Washington Community Essay

- “Knowledge about the inner life of the governmental community of Washington becomes imperative for understanding the political system of the new nation.” ( Young p.108) The Constitutional Framers envisioned a national government that is similar to the concept of Plato's cave which is that it would be "at a distance and out of sight" of the everyday affairs and thoughts of ordinary Americans. The end result, it was anticipated, would be a new form of "national" and "long term" thinking by men of prominence, motivated only by their devotion to a national public interest and legacy....   [tags: government, constitutional framer, plato]

Better Essays
1099 words (3.1 pages)

The Constitutional Convention Simulation : New Jersey Essay examples

- In our constitutional convention simulation, I played the role of a representative from New Jersey. New Jersey had a wide range of goals, but by far the most important was equal representation for the states in the federal government. New Jersey, at the time, had a population of only about 175,000 people, which, while not the smallest state, meant that they would have minimal representation in a population based legislature. In order to keep states like Virginia from completely taking over, New Jersey wanted each state to have an equal number of representatives in congress....   [tags: United States, United States Constitution]

Better Essays
746 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The Constitution's Ambiguity

- The preamble of the Constitution lays out six reasons for its establishment of which two reasons standout, the establishment of justice and providing for the common defense. The national security of the United States was of paramount importance to our founders and remains so today after over 200 years. While there is no clear answer on how to achieve security, our constitutional system of government provides the framework for seeking its ends. The Constitution itself, in its ambiguity and deliberate requirement for interpretation, along with the elements of division of power and the rule of law, play key roles in how our government provides the blanket of security for our nation....   [tags: Separation of Power, Branches]

Better Essays
1142 words (3.3 pages)

The Supreme Court And The Constitutional System Essay

- The Supreme Court plays a vital role in our constitutional system, as well as an important role in the daily lives of citizens. As one of the three branches of government, the judiciary maintains checks and balances with the legislative (House of Representatives and Senate) and executive (Governor) branches of government. The Minnesota Supreme Court also serves as the final guardian of the state constitution and interprets and applies the state’s constitution. But, beyond that, the Supreme Court serves people....   [tags: Separation of powers, Law]

Better Essays
1159 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on First Amendment and the Constitutional Freedoms in Amercan Schools

- The First Amendment, usually equated with freedom of speech, affords five protections: Establishment Clause, Free exercise of religion, Freedom of speech, Freedom of press, and Freedom to peaceable assemble. Students (and student groups) in public colleges and universities enjoy full protection under the First Amendment; however, this right depends greatly on the context in which a student might raise a free speech claim. Once an institution creates a limited public forum for a student or group, administration cannot deny recognition to particular student or groups based on viewpoints....   [tags: freedom of speech, constitutional freedoms]

Better Essays
1264 words (3.6 pages)

Parliamentary And Presidential Constitutional Systems Essay

- Both the parliamentary and presidential constitutional systems of government are popular choices of democratic countries around the world. Nevertheless, despite their core similarities, each form of government poses unique ideologies of representation, as well as methods of conducting the business of governing. Circumstance leads to the organization of a representative body given the power to make and enforce law, as well as a basic mutual agreement between the people and their government. The end result of this agreement is a system of government unique to the culture, values, and circumstance of a population....   [tags: Presidential system, Separation of powers]

Better Essays
1001 words (2.9 pages)

Theme Of Ambiguity In The Monument By Elizabeth Bishop Essay example

- In The Monument by Elizabeth Bishop ambiguity is crucial to the audience's perception of the monument. Bishop refrains from telling the audience the meaning of the monument in order to maintain the theme of ambiguity. By using ambiguity Bishop allows her audience to develop their own interpretation of the monument. The text begins with, “Now can you see the monument. It is of wood/ built somewhat like a box. No. Built/ like several boxes in descending sizes/ one above the other.”(line 1) The narrator starts off the poem by telling the audience to look at the monument with the statement, “Now can you see the monument?” It is important that the audience is fully aware of the monument as it is...   [tags: Ambiguity, Ambiguity tolerance, Audience]

Better Essays
1136 words (3.2 pages)

Essay On Ambiguity

- Ambiguity in Sentence Processing Introduction Numerous psycholinguistic research suggests that human language comprehension is incremental. In other words, once the sentence is being heard, listener start parsing the sentence by building structures. The sentence processing will not wait until the whole sentence is being heard. Processors apply different strategies, such as minimal attachment and late closure, to comprehend the sentence. However, the fast and instant sentence processing may sometimes lead to ambiguity....   [tags: Ambiguity, Phrase, Syntax, Word]

Better Essays
1149 words (3.3 pages)

The Second Constitutional Convention Essay

- The Second Constitutional Convention has introduced three new ideas to the United States government to help create a more balanced effective and limited political institution. The three proposals include switching the electoral system in the House of Representatives to proportional representation. Another proposal introduced to the conveners was to change the current presidential system to a parliamentary system. The last proposal was to change the rules for the selection of senators. The proposals are vague, leaving a lot of room for the smaller details....   [tags: Separation of powers, Presidential system]

Better Essays
1520 words (4.3 pages)