Essay about A Controversial Issue Of Authority

Essay about A Controversial Issue Of Authority

Length: 1280 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In recent class discussions of authority, a controversial issue has been whether it is wrong to obey authority. Some argue that it is always wrong to disobey authority. From this perspective, some believe that because their superior is above them, they know whats better and we need to comply. On the other hand, however, others argue that if you believe you are being told to do something that is morally wrong, you have the choice not to do it and to go against your authority. In the words of Plato, one of this view’s main proponents, “you mustn 't let any fears on these grounds make you slacken your efforts to escape; and you mustn 't feel any misgivings about what you said at your trial, that you wouldn 't know what to do with yourself if you left this country” (Plato par. 32). According to this view, Crito is explaining to Socrates that even though he has been sentenced to death, to disobey authority because he can’t be afraid to escape in order to be successful and do it. I believe Crito is trying to shame him into escaping so that he can clear his conscious about getting I 'm in prison in the first place and having the opportunity to get him out and not take it. In sum, then, the issue is whether it is wrong to disobey authority or whether it is okay to disobey authority.
My personal view is that it is wrong to disobey authority, unless I am in a situation where I believe it would be completely wrong to continue, and I question how far I will go before I reach a point where there is shame for what I have done. Though I recognize that authority might be more knowledgable about a subject than their inferior, I still support that different people are going to have different types of moral wrongs and rights, and should be able to...

... middle of paper ...

... not ask about or take into consideration was “the experimenter did not threaten the subjects with punishment — such as loss of income, community ostracism, or jail — for failure to obey” (Milgram par. 54). No threat at all was expressed by the authority to the Learner. The learner took it upon themselves to assume there was consequences for not obeying their superior. It is a natural thought to believe that punishment and consequences would be certain for not obeying authority, but they never asked or pushed enough to hear what they would say if you didn 't comply. This is a point you need to get to if you believe that what you are doing is morally wrong. To question and disobey authority long enough to make an effect on what they are doing and thinking is where you have to get to make any progress on sticking with your moral beliefs and compromising with authority.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Holocaust Was A Controversial Issue Essay

- Introduction: The Holocaust was an event that took place in Germany which means ‘sacrifice by fire’ in Greek; many murdered Jews were the consequences of this terrible action caused by Adolf Hitler. According to the website United States Holocaust Memorial Museum (USHMM) it states that “The Holocaust was the systematic, bureaucratic, state-sponsored persecution and murder of six million Jews by the Nazi regime and its collaborators.” This terrific slaughter was a racial and discriminatory oppression for the Nazis to the minorities....   [tags: Nazi Germany, Adolf Hitler, The Holocaust]

Better Essays
1798 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on Assisted Suicide : A Controversial Issue

- Assisted Suicide Assisted suicide has been a controversial subject for many years all around the world. Assisted suicide is also known as euthanasia. Two type of euthanasia are passive and active euthanasia. In passive euthanasia life-saving support is withdrawn from a patient. Conversely, active euthanasia is when measures are purposefully taken to end one’s life. Another form of assisted suicide is referred to as physician-assisted suicide. In physician-assisted suicide, a medical doctor typically administers a lethal dose of medication that brings an end to a patient’s life....   [tags: Death, Euthanasia, Suicide, Medical ethics]

Better Essays
1638 words (4.7 pages)

Essay about Abortion : A Controversial Issue

- Abortion Abortion is a subject that rises controversy throughout the United States. Pro-life groups protest the practice in peaceful and others in violent acts. Pro-choice groups feel that it is the woman’s choice to decide if abortion is right for her, and religious groups feel that abortion is murder of the fetus and against God’s will. The word abortion by definition, the deliberate termination of a human fetus during pregnancy, most often performed during the first 28 weeks of pregnancy. Abortion is an extremely controversial issue because while some people are completely against it, others believe that a woman should have the right to make her own choice....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Roe v. Wade, Fertility]

Better Essays
1057 words (3 pages)

An Controversial Issue Of Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

- Physician assisted suicide has remained one of the most controversial topics that continues to generate division among doctors, patients, and people in general. It grants doctors with the authority to intentionally provide a terminally ill patient with lethal doses of drugs to end their life voluntarily. Those who oppose assisted suicide, cite religious and moral reasons. On the other hand, supporters refer to the pain and anguish many patients must suffer before their death. Ben Mitchell, in his article (2015) argues that “Doctors have a duty to do what they can ethically to alleviate suffering, but they cannot knowingly involve themselves in the death of a patient, even if the patient requ...   [tags: Suffering, Death, Pain, Physician]

Better Essays
1255 words (3.6 pages)

The Controversial Issues of Obedience Essay

- Individuals think differently when it comes to obedience. One might think of how we train dogs to be obedient, another might relate obedience to punishing a child for breaking a rule, or even others think about Hitler's Regime in Germany. When it comes to obedience, there are several sides. Stanley Milgram's article, "Obedience to Authority," expresses his view of obedience as an intensely embedded behavioral tendency to obey where a potent impulse can override training in ethics, sympathy, and moral conduct....   [tags: Comparative Literature]

Better Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Common Core : A Controversial Issue Regarding Many Kinds Of People

- Common Core is a controversial issue concerning many different kinds of people. Teachers are concerned because they feel like the new standards implemented restrict their abilities to create a lesson that fits their specific student’s needs. Students are concerned because of the increased amount of testing associated with Common Core. Parents are concerned because they have no say in what their children learn. Lastly, the government is concerned because of the state our country is in education wise and how far behind we are falling....   [tags: Education, School, Teacher, Student]

Better Essays
1054 words (3 pages)

The Controversial Marijuana Essay

- Medical Marijuana: America's Plant The use of marijuana, for both medical and recreational purposes, has long been a topic of much controversy. Using marijuana is seen as morally wrong by many, however to others it is seen as a plant with major health benefits. Upon first introduction to the subject it seems unclear as to why so much controversy is caused by this plant. The answer is rooted deep in America's history and to this day effects several parts of everyday American life. Marijuana policy affects Americans economically and health-wise....   [tags: Cannabis, Medical, Drug, ]

Better Essays
2960 words (8.5 pages)

Genesis 3 : 16 Is A Controversial Verse Essay

- Genesis 3:16 is a controversial verse. After conducting my research, I could appreciate that God issue a punishment to Adam and Eve due to their sin. God pronounces judgment on the woman. The woman 's craving for her husband will be so strong that to satisfy it she will be ready to face all the pains and sorrows of childbearing. This is to be understood of her being exclusively at the will and satisfaction of her husband; that whatever she desired should be referred to him, whether she should have her desire or not, or the thing she desired; it should be legally responsible to be controlled by his will, which must settle on it....   [tags: Adam and Eve, Book of Genesis, Woman]

Better Essays
797 words (2.3 pages)

Constitutional Authority Of The President Essay

- Constitutional Authority Of The President One of the greatest debates in the short history of the United States was over the proposed Constitution and did not solely take place inside the walls of the Constitutional convention. Throughout our great nation many individuals from different class levels and occupations became involved in the question over the new plan of government. Many views were expressed through the distribution of pamphlets, sermons, and the release of newspaper essays to sway citizens on the changes proposed....   [tags: US Government Political Science]

Better Essays
1926 words (5.5 pages)

Essay about Controversial Aspects of Decommissioning the Edwards Dam

- Controversial Aspects of Decommissioning the Edwards Dam In 1991 the Edwards Manufacturing Company, owner of the Edwards Dam on the Kennebec River in Augusta, ME, applied to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) for a renewal of their license to operate a privately owned hydroelectric dam. Their application was denied; Edwards Manufacturing Company was required to come up with a plan for the enacting and financing of decommissioning the dam, as well as the restoration of the river....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
4459 words (12.7 pages)